rosends
Well-Known Member
Some questions came up during the first 2 days of Passover. Some, I'm sure, have been asked before but I wanted to put them all out here just to keep people thinking. And if you know of some good answers, please post.
1. Why are the four questions called the 4 questions. At best, we have 1 question and 4 answers (how is this night different? In the following 4 ways). I know that there is much commentary about the four, but what is it called the four questions?
2. Why those items -- not only have some not happened yet, so a child wouldn't know to ask, but there are more important things about the meal that could be questioned
3. Why claim that on all other nights we don't dip? On the sabbath, we dip bread in salt
4. Why claim that on all other nights we can have chameitz or matzah? For the 2 weeks before Pesach, we cannot eat matzah!
5. If, according to Ha Lachama Anya, the matzah was the bread that we ate in Egypt, why make a big deal about the fact that it was eaten also when we left?
6. Why, as part of telling about the exodus, do we use the frame of 4 sons? Why not just tell the story?
7. Similarly, why add Koreich to the seder?
1. Why are the four questions called the 4 questions. At best, we have 1 question and 4 answers (how is this night different? In the following 4 ways). I know that there is much commentary about the four, but what is it called the four questions?
2. Why those items -- not only have some not happened yet, so a child wouldn't know to ask, but there are more important things about the meal that could be questioned
3. Why claim that on all other nights we don't dip? On the sabbath, we dip bread in salt
4. Why claim that on all other nights we can have chameitz or matzah? For the 2 weeks before Pesach, we cannot eat matzah!
5. If, according to Ha Lachama Anya, the matzah was the bread that we ate in Egypt, why make a big deal about the fact that it was eaten also when we left?
6. Why, as part of telling about the exodus, do we use the frame of 4 sons? Why not just tell the story?
7. Similarly, why add Koreich to the seder?