Most Holy Books teaches human has a soul. The Books also talk about a future event, when there will be resurrection of the dead.
For those who believe in these Books, that human has a soul, which lives on after the death of body, and eventually on the day of judgment comes to the physically resurrected body:
How does this idea logially make sense to you?
Why would God resurrect the body physically and return the soul to it, if the soul by itself can just lives on?
Hi
InvestigateTruth
I think your question is interesting. I assume that you are asking why the unembodied spirit/soul of a person (after the body dies) is given a material body in the resurrection if the spirit exists perfectly independently of a body. (I hope I understood your question).
I do not know why there would HAVE to be a body given to a spirit but I assume it has to do with the fact that the universe is, to a large part material and much of the processes going on have to do with material beings interacting with material things.
I think the reason that early Judeo-Christian material worldview was abandoned by some of the later Christian theories and their movements had to do with the attempt to enhance a transcendent theory of what God was like (including the idea that he doesn’t directly come in contact with material or directly work with matter). One of the first things the apostle Peter tells the convert Clement (in recognitions) is that "
we (christians) do not believe matter is inherently evil". Perhaps this early theory of matter and an association with evil was the origin of the religious theory of ex-nihilo creation (i.e. a material universe made of “nothing”) and why the earlier worldview of material creation was abandoned by some later religious movement.
I believe that the idea of “immaterial matter” of later Christian movements is less rational, less logical than the early concept of material creation. The Pistis Sophia, for example, speaks of the spirit itself as “
self willed matter”. The concept of the spirit itself being a finer type of material is, I think, more rational and logical than it being made of "nothing".
In any case, I assume that the early Judeo-Christian concept of the individual spirits of mankind receiving material bodies in the resurrection has to do with the fact that we will always be interacting with materials in ways that will bring greater joy and satisfaction and that there is something about having a Glorified and powerful and perfected body that will bring more joy to us in the eternities than simply existing in the form of a spirit.
For example, I can certainly exist without a material car, but my life is better with it. Perhaps the body is another tool for the spirit. I don't really know. It’s the best concept I have until I have better data.
Good luck coming up with your own models that help you make sense of these things.
Clear
ακτζδρω