The rules that govern participation in the Judaism DIR are the same that govern participation in the Islam DIR, the Christianity DIR and all the other DIRs on the forum. Only those who have identified themselves as members of each specific group can engage in conversation. All others are limited to respectful questions.
You may think the idea of such limitations is not a good one. You may not like the rule, but it is a rule of the forum.
(I have modified my post because the post I responded to has been deleted. I have eliminated the name of the poster to whom I was responding and I have deleted a section that would, perhaps, not make sense without the post I responded to.)