Submit your un-serious proposal. To whom do we give back the land? There are lands whose original inhabitants are extinct. Then there are lands that were inhabited by different tribes at different times. Which tribe gets those lands? And what about those tribes that don’t have any disagreements with how things are? Go ahead and submit you proposal. While you’re at it would you please ask the non-Jews to give us back our land that they stole from us?
Progressives, still making silly arguments.
Nope, completely wrong assumption.
Just highlighting your silly double standards and virtue signalling. You benefitted from ethnic cleansing, that's a fact. Yet it's only others who are guilty and must give back to the "rightful" owners. The US can't let others benefit from ethnic cleansing, just themselves.
Serbs own Kosovo in perpetuity, despite it being populated by Albanians for a similar, or longer, length of time to much of the US. The Albanians aren't the "historical owners of the land" after all.
You get to keep the land, they don't. You position yourself as virtuous for telling others to give back their land, but demand to keep your own.
The history of the world is population movement and conquest, choosing some arbitrary cutoff point and claiming those who had it then are the "true" owners of the land is stupid. Everyone "stole" their land from someone else.
Almost all societies in history have been happy to use violence to acquire land and power, it's only when they got defeated they start to cry about injustice. It's the moralisation of one violent group's ancestors being less competent militarily than another violent group's.
You can recognise that about America, but seem unable to apply the concept to others. That is your hypocrisy.
If they have to give the land to some generic Serbs, you should give the land back to some generic Native Americans. If you think you should keep the land you conquered, you should accept their right to do this also.
Why do you think otherwise?
