1. Welcome to Religious Forums, a friendly forum to discuss all religions in a friendly surrounding.

    Your voice is missing! You will need to register to get access to the following site features:
    • Reply to discussions and create your own threads.
    • Our modern chat room. No add-ons or extensions required, just login and start chatting!
    • Access to private conversations with other members.

    We hope to see you as a part of our community soon!

Earth as a Test Illogical - How Could I Believe?

Discussion in 'Monotheism' started by Robyn Highart, Dec 11, 2019.

  1. Robyn Highart

    Robyn Highart New Member

    Dec 11, 2019
    Heaven and Hell, the end paths of life are eternal.

    Life on Earth is temporary. Actions done here determine the final destination of the soul. Therefore life on Earth is a test.

    In Christianity, we assume that we only live one life on Earth, therefore the result of the test is final.


    1. The test is wildly unfair, arbitrary and ultimately redundant.

    How can the souls of the living be judged, when they all have free wills, but hugely different starting conditions and surroundings?

    Let's assume that Final Judgement is not a standardised, good or evil test. Let's assume that it is takes into account the actions of the individual, relative to their circumstances. How can such a test be applied, when those relative circumstances are what would alter the individual's choices and responses to the circumstances themselves, including:

    - Parents, family, people who the individual meets.

    - Location and culture at birth (especially pre-global travel)

    - Time of birth (peasant who knows nothing but work and religion vs. highly educated and sceptical person born 1,000 years later. Is the latter less fit for Heaven because he was taught to think critically and rejected illogical religious tenets?)

    - Inherited, innate behavioural traits (genetic traits statistically proven to alter propensity for violence etc.)

    - Geographical concentration of good and/or religious people to influence the individual (If you're surrounded by good people, you will be likely to act in a good way, no?)

    It is said that people like savages who have never been taught about Jesus would be saved. How does that differ from someone who was taught about Jesus, but was brought up by drug dealing, psychopathic animals and lived in an area where crime was commonplace. If they die before repenting, are they going to hell?

    It just seems to me that "Free Will" is influenced by a myriad of factors in life, and that even though we each have a choice to do good or evil, sometimes even our own understanding of those concepts isn't the same.

    I want to believe in God. I don't want to simply wilt and cease to exist. However, we live in a logical universe, and religion has fallen behind in the explanation department considerably. When I talked to priests and asked them these fundamental questions they had nothing. Some even tried to give me some pseudo-scientific babble about outdated models of the atom and trinities and so on. I just cannot respect this belief system if it cannot answer basic questions about it's main appeal.

    2. Babies/mentally disabled/otherwise unconscious beings.

    How can these beings exist in heaven? In fact, how would we, the conscious ones exist in heaven? Would we remember this life? If not, what was it for? Why did we need this lesson, this test? Are we going to be some benign animals without free will? If we do remember this life, then I posit that it takes effort to be good. Will this no longer be the case in Heaven? Will it simply be endless euphoria, as if constantly pumped on heroin? If not, could it be possible to sin in Heaven? After all, even good people sin all the time. Would they be sent to hell from heaven?

    If you've read this, please don't consider me some die-hard fedora atheist. I'm just writing this out of frustration because I don't think I could ever believe in God, and that anyone who does must simply be repressing these questions in the back of their heads or never even considered the logic of it all. It's very convenient to simply say that this world doesn't work like Heaven and people could never understand it whilst in this plane.

    I don't relish in making these accusations against the idea of heaven. But if you look at it objectively it makes absolutely no sense.

    The sad truth is, that it was never meant to make sense. Theology has not advanced in any truly fundamentally significant way since the bible was finalised. No great revelations have come. No answers to explain it all. I think it was always about power and control, and if you learn enough about the world you will eventually see that it's all a big scam.

    Because the alternative would be that God prefers people to be ignorant and only those who blindly follow what the oligarchs of religion say deserve to be in heaven. Not those who use their God-given brain to learn about his creation and figure out that the things purportedly written in his name make very little sense.

    It falls perfectly in line with the decline of Christianity in contrast to Islam's rise. Whilst Christianity is most prevalent in the wealthy and ever-more educated West, the downtrodden and ignorant countries where Islam thrives are to me comparative to the unread masses the Church had under its heels in Europe for over a millennium.

    I look forward to any concrete counter-arguments or critique of my thinking.
    • Like Like x 1
  2. sun rise

    sun rise "This is the Hour of God"
    Premium Member

    Apr 28, 2014
    The part of your post I agree with is that eternal damnation (and heaven) make no sense to me. It's one reason the Eastern concept of reincarnation along with karma makes good sense. There, "heaven" and "hell" are states where the lessons of the past life are reviewed by our higher selves. Positive actions bring positive rewards (bliss/heaven). Negative actions bring negative states (suffering/hell). Once those lessons are reviewed, we get another life to take another step forward.
  3. KAT-KAT

    KAT-KAT Veteran Member

    May 2, 2019
    Daughter of Shiva, also Left Hand Path
    No counter-arguments here, as much of it goes along with my own thinking. I have found depth from reading Hindu stories and beliefs. There's really a lot there. Even if someone believes them, there are still unanswered questions though like "What is Jesus to you?" For me, I consider Jesus like an angel, and God the father to have a lot of confusing things written about him and for the God of everything to be more a mystery than a God of love, etc. So I don't pass too much judgement on his characteristics because I simply don't know. I think he's very intelligent, and in line with science, and is neither a total father figure in the purest sense as some might believe, necessarily, but also isn't what we humans consider evil.
  4. Cooky

    Cooky Veteran Member

    May 12, 2018
    I honestly believe intentions are all that matter.

    ...I've seen people do very selfish things And have little to no regard for other people. They have no remorse, and no desire to change their ways. Their intentions are BAD.

    I've seen others give due respect to everyone they meet, regardless. They still sin, but are willing to recognize their sin, and at least try to change. Their intentions are GOOD.

    it can only be our intentions that matter in the end, since temptation varies based on each person's location. A well off person living in a rural town, for example, will not have to face the same temptations that a poor person living in an inner city will. Location makes an imbalanced playing field, therefore, an all knowing God will recognize this fact.
    #4 Cooky, Dec 11, 2019
    Last edited by a moderator: Dec 11, 2019