• Welcome to Religious Forums, a friendly forum to discuss all religions in a friendly surrounding.

    Your voice is missing! You will need to register to get access to the following site features:
    • Reply to discussions and create your own threads.
    • Our modern chat room. No add-ons or extensions required, just login and start chatting!
    • Access to private conversations with other members.

    We hope to see you as a part of our community soon!

Earth: 0% religion

ChristineM

"Be strong", I whispered to my coffee.
Premium Member
But there are plenty of non-civilized cultures even today. They all seem to have their religions -- though some hunter-gatherer cultures don't divide it into a separate cultural category.
I don't think religion is an artifact of civilization. I blame neurology. ;)

Going back 20 or 30 thousand years there are no indications of religion. It only began to show after the first civilisations developed
 

Valjean

Veteran Member
Premium Member
I hate to ruin your illusion, but that certainly isn't any kind of "default"...

Both history and, increasingly, science attest to this.
Fair point.
I was thinking more in terms of political development, comparing secular and religious societies, for example.
The human brain is hard wired to promote tribalism. Removing religion won't magically change our evolved cognition.
Agreed, tribalism and the precursors of religion both seem hard-wired.
It's a nice comforting myth to think our problems can be solved by removing religion, but it's about as likely as the return of Jesus.
Not all problems, but life does seem better in the more secular, democratic societies. I agree that removing religion would be problematic but religiosity does seem related to security, diminishing in stable, secure, égalitarian societies.
 

Left Coast

This Is Water
Staff member
Premium Member
First, there would be no atheists. A-theism is a result of theism. And it seems there is a way of humans to have no religion as there are (very few) tribes in the Amazon who don't have a concept of gods.

Are you talking about the Pirahã?
 

Valjean

Veteran Member
Premium Member
Going back 20 or 30 thousand years there are no indications of religion. It only began to show after the first civilisations developed
What would you consider indications?
My disagreement is with the implication that there's a post hoc relationship.
 

ChristineM

"Be strong", I whispered to my coffee.
Premium Member
What would you consider indications?
My disagreement is with the implication that there's a post hoc relationship.

Artifacts.

Religion always produces artifacts, jewelry, documentation, painting sculpture etc.
 

Heyo

Veteran Member
Going back 20 or 30 thousand years there are no indications of religion. It only began to show after the first civilisations developed
True but we have indications of proto-religious behaviour from 2 million years ago. (Ritual burial) The "Venus von Willendorf" is 25,000 years old and has been connected to a fertility cult (with very thin evidence, but non-the-less).
 
I was thinking more in terms of political development, comparing secular and religious societies, for example.

Secular societies are very culturally contingent. Even the idea of the possibility of splitting religion/secular can be seen as culturally contingent.

Not all problems, but life does seem better in the more secular, democratic societies. I agree that removing religion would be problematic but religiosity does seem related to security, diminishing in stable, secure, égalitarian societies

There is some truth in this, but secular democratic societies are the product of a particular cultural tradition that has a large debt to a certain type of religion.

These societies have also generally been peaceful and prosperous domestically post WW2 and we only have a short timescale to go on.

So we have a potential correlation/causation problem, and also the problem of not knowing whether these are simply short term blips that will not stand the test of time.

We also have the 20th C totalitarianisms to show we can easily make up new belief systems that are worse than what came before.
 

ChristineM

"Be strong", I whispered to my coffee.
Premium Member
True but we have indications of proto-religious behaviour from 2 million years ago. (Ritual burial) The "Venus von Willendorf" is 25,000 years old and has been connected to a fertility cult (with very thin evidence, but non-the-less).

Tribal thanks for the food that sustains them or art works... i dont really see as a religion. There are lots of cro magnon works of art around my home area, not one of religion.

I've also investigated ritual burials of Neanderthals, proto religion? Possibly more likely honour of loved ones
 
True but we have indications of proto-religious behaviour from 2 million years ago. (Ritual burial) The "Venus von Willendorf" is 25,000 years old and has been connected to a fertility cult (with very thin evidence, but non-the-less).

We also have cognitive sciences showing human tendencies towards "religious type" worldviews.

There is at least a reasonable case to be made that "religion" of some form is the default for (non-infant) humans.
 

Valjean

Veteran Member
Premium Member
Artifacts.

Religion always produces artifacts, jewelry, documentation, painting sculpture etc.
OK, but, save documentation, those things did exist 20 or 30 thousand years ago. Moreover, I don't think they're necessarily artifacts of religion.
 

Heyo

Veteran Member
Tribal thanks for the food that sustains them or art works... i dont really see as a religion. There are lots of cro magnon works of art around my home area, not one of religion.

I've also investigated ritual burials of Neanderthals, proto religion? Possibly more likely honour of loved ones
I'm also not happy with anthropologist everything they don't understand calling "cultic" or "religious" but burials and ancestor worship is still pretty much connected to religions. It could have been appropriated by religion but it seems more likely that religion rose from it. Inventing myths about an afterlife are a religious thing.
 

Heyo

Veteran Member
We also have cognitive sciences showing human tendencies towards "religious type" worldviews.

There is at least a reasonable case to be made that "religion" of some form is the default for (non-infant) humans.
Yes, though I would call it "superstition" or "spirituality". Religion only seems to forms in cultures above the Dunbar's Number threshold.
 

ChristineM

"Be strong", I whispered to my coffee.
Premium Member
OK, but, save documentation, those things did exist 20 or 30 thousand years ago. Moreover, I don't think they're necessarily artifacts of religion.


They certainly don't appear to be religious artifacts. More likely tribal heirlooms

Documentation comes in several forms. I have recently seen a series of cave paintings that depict a hunt of aurochs, it's clear that at least 1 hunter lost their life in the hunt and that 2 aurochs were killed. Another giving rudimentary instructions on trapping wild horses.

I can see thousands of such pieces of cave art. I never see any on religion.
 

ChristineM

"Be strong", I whispered to my coffee.
Premium Member
I'm also not happy with anthropologist everything they don't understand calling "cultic" or "religious" but burials and ancestor worship is still pretty much connected to religions. It could have been appropriated by religion but it seems more likely that religion rose from it. Inventing myths about an afterlife are a religious thing.

Ancestor worship, animal worship tranquil glade worship, i think probably were a stepping stone to religion.
 

Valjean

Veteran Member
Premium Member
"Religion" can be a pretty broad subject, not necessarily connected with theology or even worship. A belief or set of beliefs that manifests an ethic in a society might be considered religious. Such beliefs/rules/attitudes would be needed for group solidarity and cohesion even in small, band-based societies.
 

ChristineM

"Be strong", I whispered to my coffee.
Premium Member
"Religion" can be a pretty broad subject, not necessarily connected with theology or even worship. A belief or set of beliefs that manifests an ethic in a society might be considered religious. Such beliefs/rules/attitudes would be needed for group solidarity and cohesion even in small, band-based societies.

That's as i see it but call it tribalism rather than religion. Religion grew from it with several additions to make a full blown religion
 
Top