use_your_brain
Active Member
perhaps they don't know well the quran, hadith and the recent global news.
-
Welcome to Religious Forums, a friendly forum to discuss all religions in a friendly surrounding.
Your voice is missing! You will need to register to get access to the following site features:- Reply to discussions and create your own threads.
- Our modern chat room. No add-ons or extensions required, just login and start chatting!
- Access to private conversations with other members.
We hope to see you as a part of our community soon!
Does Islam have to have a caliph/caliphate?
- Thread starter ZooGirl02
- Start date
Jumi
Well-Known Member
Do you mean the recent news that they burned alive their own soldiers again?
use_your_brain
Active Member
they should know that as well.
Nope, I'd support them if they were good Muslims. So far everything is not in their favor.
use_your_brain
Active Member
me too, if they met that condition.
The Emperor of Mankind
Currently the galaxy's spookiest paraplegic
How do you believe good Muslims would go about establishing a caliphate?
Sorry, I don't know the criteria of a good Muslim for sure. Establishing a caliphate is a great responsibility that has to be considered so very carefully, and I say this out of logical thinking only. For now, I think a good Muslim is a Muslim who is a good human. No good human burns another alive and never repent for good.
I am sorry. I can't answer your question in any way. Not in a thread that is in a Islamic DIR.
I am no Muslim.
You are welcome to bring the matter to one of the debate areas if you want to.
DawudTalut
Peace be upon you.
Peace be on you.....I would like to give my humble input too but to avoid any interference among Islamic DIRs, I have started a thread in religious debates. Kindly have my answer there. Thanks.
http://www.religiousforums.com/thre...-to-believers-and-doers-of-good-works.183533/
use_your_brain
Active Member
Why do ISIS kill other muslims, because didn't Abu Bakr and Ali also kill other muslims?
use_your_brain
Active Member
which verse says that?
Maybe in wars and out of desperation, not because they wanted to. If a Muslim charges at another Muslim to kill them, the target Muslim has the right to defend themselves even if it requires killing.
Necessities have their different rules and we are humans. There are many things in Islam that can be done out of necessity like not fasting or not performing Hajj for a good excuse.
If a Muslim misses a day fasting, killing them would be a crime and a great sin.
use_your_brain
Active Member
yes it is the accepted answer, they are in war situation, muslims in the conflict area are getting killed by their enemies. Therefore, if they don't kill their enemies then they would be get killed first. The fact is, many muslims strive to come to Syria to join ISIS, are they not afraid of getting killed by ISIS?
Hmm, I think it is because I S I S started the killing, that many Muslims don't approve of them. I heard they kill Muslims just for skipping a day fasting or for deciding to leave I S I S, is that true? Kinda like the Jordanian pilot they burned alive and he was just a hopeless and harmless prisoner. He was a hostage, not someone charging at them to kill them.
use_your_brain
Active Member
Why don't the muslims approve ISIS?
The Jordan pilot burnt the muslims alive also, he was the one who started the killing first before getting retaliation.
Abu Bakr also killed the muslims who denied to pay the zakat.
Muslims not approving of them have their own information that the above details are false too or at least there are explanations for it.
I don't say they are not Muslims, I just believe they are wrong. That's just my opinion.
use_your_brain
Active Member
It's too much to talk about really and I don't feel like it at the moment. Not to mention it would be off-topic and a debate subject which are a possible violations of the rules. You can start a new thread about it and will get better results.