Frank Goad
Well-Known Member
@Frank Goad
How you define magic?
Magic is the beliefs and actions employed to influence supernatural beings and forces
Welcome to Religious Forums, a friendly forum to discuss all religions in a friendly surrounding.
Your voice is missing! You will need to register to get access to the following site features:We hope to see you as a part of our community soon!
@Frank Goad
How you define magic?
It's like what happens in the harry potter movies.
but it would be totally inappropriate to call these "magic" in the anthropological sense.
Do you think magic spells work on christians?I think they might.But I am not sure.
No. There's no such thing as magic, especially in the Harry Potter, Hocus Pocus form. That's fiction. The closest to that would be forms of psychological tricks and manipulation. However, I do believe that evil spirits can be called upon to harm people, but that probably would end up harming the one invoking them, too.Do you think magic spells work on christians?I think they might.But I am not sure.
If it works on humans it works on Christians, but any person who has control of themselves and their passions is resistant to control by others.Do you think magic spells work on christians?I think they might.But I am not sure.
Well, let me give you first hand information.Do you think magic spells work on christians?I think they might.But I am not sure.
Also just for information.Do you think magic spells work on christians?I think they might.But I am not sure.
I wondered if there was any such magic spells in the Bible.If it works on humans it works on Christians, but any person who has control of themselves and their passions is resistant to control by others.
Here are scriptures about common gateways of magic used against not only Christians but against all kinds of people:
- "Whoever loves pleasure will become poor; whoever loves wine and olive oil will never be rich." (Proverbs 21:17)
- "Do not accept a bribe, for a bribe blinds those who see and twists the words of the innocent." (Exo 23:8 NIV)
- "Their destiny is destruction, their god is their stomach, and their glory is in their shame. Their mind is set on earthly things." (Phl 3:19)
Also just for information.
I debated with a Muslim scholar a few years ago on social media, with about 50 or so participants, from Islam and Christian faith.
We came to a point where he got frustrated about the topic we discussed, and he proposed that we both pray to our God, and ask Him to set His "Curse" upon the one who is a liar!
Now being a Christian, I was shocked that he would ask something like this.
I let him know that he is free to call on Allah to place a curse on me, but...
I will pray that YHWH blesses him with good health, and prosperity, safety for his family, and happyness.
Neesless to say, Allah did nothing to me, and no bad happened to Ahmed too.
But I wanted to know why on earth would he demand Allah to allow a curse on someone.
Well, it is in the Quran in Surra 3 Aya 61.
And this to me is evidence that Muslims actually believe in such magic spells, because Muhammad received a revelation from Allah to teach Muslims this is a way to learn the truth.
I found it very interesting.
I am not sure about Roman Catholism, but the few believers I know are very supersticious, and scared of spells etc.
Perhaps someone can enlighten us a bit more.
Not on those who worship Jehovah. Not spells.
Jehovah might allow one of His servants to be tested, but not hurt. If they turn to & trust in Him. Proverbs 18:10
The bad one work.Do you think magic spells work on christians?I think they might.But I am not sure.
No it wouldn't. IMO. They change ones internal state or essence.
“magic is about changing the state or essence of persons, objects, acts and events through certain special and non-trivial kinds of actions with opaque causal mediation”
https://www.google.com/url?sa=t&sou...UQFnoECAQQBg&usg=AOvVaw2od5WAb9-K_QeUb7lHFY36
There is the time Jacob cheats Laban. He causes new ewes to become spotted by having the animals rut under inky plants. For some reason this causes them to produce spotted offspring. No one has been able to repeat this trick. (Genesis 30) Jacob has a deal with Laban that Jacob gets all the spotted ewes and Laban gets all the unspotted ewes. Jacob gets all of them using this trick. Somehow the inky plants are able to affect the DNA of the ewes or there is some magical effect.I wondered if there was any such magic spells in the Bible.
I would love to find some.
I think it's weird that you disagree with me and yet provide a definition that precisely proves my point. Magic here is not an internal, psychological phenomenon but explicitly stated to have external, causal effects.
I tried it, and it does not work.There is the time Jacob cheats Laban. He causes new ewes to become spotted by having the animals rut under inky plants. For some reason this causes them to produce spotted offspring. No one has been able to repeat this trick. (Genesis 30) Jacob has a deal with Laban that Jacob gets all the spotted ewes and Laban gets all the unspotted ewes. Jacob gets all of them using this trick. Somehow the inky plants are able to affect the DNA of the ewes or there is some magical effect.