• Welcome to Religious Forums, a friendly forum to discuss all religions in a friendly surrounding.

    Your voice is missing! You will need to register to get access to the following site features:
    • Reply to discussions and create your own threads.
    • Our modern chat room. No add-ons or extensions required, just login and start chatting!
    • Access to private conversations with other members.

    We hope to see you as a part of our community soon!

Chimpanzee Religion

Mock Turtle

Oh my, did I say that!
Premium Member
'Bonobos and Chimpanzees are BOTH our closest relatives Bonobos and Chimpanzees both share close to 98%'

And socially we don't use sex for group bonding like bonobos

And Chimpanzees are rather violent at times - just like us - so we are more a mix of both.
 

Heyo

Veteran Member
And walking on water, don't forget the walking on water
giphy.gif
 

Bear Wild

Well-Known Member
Well, I didn't say it was your list.
Only that you listed it.

Those are things which would apply to atheists too.

Icon reverence?
Holding church services?

So are icon reverence and holding church services necessary for a religion?
Would you say that a case for chimpanzee religion cannot be made? How would you know if chimpanzees do not have behaviors that could be seen as religion?
 

cladking

Well-Known Member
Come on! How is an animal going to have religion with no ability to make abstractions? Granted very few words are known yet in any animal language but they have no words for "thought", "belief", reductionism, and taxonomies. When there is sufficient sample size we'll find they break Zipf's Law as well. We are merely anthropomorphizing their behavior which has never really been studied in any animal since "consciousness" has never been defined. Without abstractions and symbolism what exactly could they believe in and what evolutionary advantage can belief and superstition possibly confer?

https://www.cbc.ca/news/technology/prairie-dogs-language-decoded-by-scientists-1.1322230

We don't understand language and consciousness so we tend to ascribe them where they don't exist. We think and use abstraction, metaphor, and symbolism to communicate but no evidence exists that this has always been true or is true today for animals.

No, animals have no religion old time or other.
 

Twilight Hue

Twilight, not bright nor dark, good nor bad.
It wouldn't suprise me if there was some sort of proto-spirituality or religiosity to be detected in the behaviours of chimps.
There would need be self reflection and contemplation first I think.

As evolution continues I think it can be developed as the progression for sapience draws closer.

I'm probably one of the few people here at RF who thinks Planet of the Apes could actually come true in the far future.
 

Revoltingest

Pragmatic Libertarian
Premium Member
So are icon reverence and holding church services necessary for a religion?
Merely indicators.
Would you say that a case for chimpanzee religion cannot be made? How would you know if chimpanzees do not have behaviors that could be seen as religion?
Chimpanzee religion is like pornography....I'll know it when I see it.
 

Left Coast

This Is Water
Staff member
Premium Member
Chimpanzee Religion

Do Chimpanzees have religion?

Do we have any evidence that Chimpanzees have religious behavior or is there clear evidence that chimpanzees cannot have religion.

James B. Harrod proposed the following Trans species dimensions to try and define what may be observed as evidence for religion.

“· Reverence (showing devotion, intense love, deep respect)

· Careful observance, which may involve a calling-out announcement or remark

· Experiencing or expressing emotion of dread (awe in its terror or astonishment aspect) before that which overwhelms the subject by its magnitude, grandeur, beneficence, or lethality; mysterium tremendum

· Experiencing or expressing emotion of wonder (awe in its fascina-tion, curiosity, or desire-to-know-more aspect) with respect to a phenomenon (especially a movement) which is surprising, non-ordinary, extraordinary, special, or ‘miraculous’; mysterium fascinans

· Binding individuals together or back together in empathic intimacy or communion with respect to experiences of aliveness and animacy, including other living beings or things that appearto be alive, which may secondarily involve the witnessing of this by a collective social group. “



The article and its evidence can be read at this sight.

www.researchgate.net/publication/276915021_The_Case_for_Chimpanzee_Religion_2014



The evolution of humans behavior patterns has created religion in humans. Certainly our closely related family on this planet – the other apes – have significant behavioral traits in common with us.

Is there a case for chimpanzee religion?

People, especially atheists, are giving you a pretty hard time about this for some reason, but personally I think the basic idea is plausible. Obviously other primates don't have anything as complex and nuanced and ideologically developed as what we call "religion." But from a naturalistic perspective, religion certainly had to come from somewhere, and it's clear that it operates at a very basic emotional, almost instinctual level in people. It makes sense that other primates would display proto-religious behaviors, as our primate/hominid ancestors likely did before us. Thanks for sharing.

As an aside, there is analogous research on moral behavior in animals.
 

Windwalker

Veteran Member
Premium Member
Chimpanzee Religion

Do Chimpanzees have religion?

Do we have any evidence that Chimpanzees have religious behavior or is there clear evidence that chimpanzees cannot have religion.

James B. Harrod proposed the following Trans species dimensions to try and define what may be observed as evidence for religion.

“· Reverence (showing devotion, intense love, deep respect)

· Careful observance, which may involve a calling-out announcement or remark

· Experiencing or expressing emotion of dread (awe in its terror or astonishment aspect) before that which overwhelms the subject by its magnitude, grandeur, beneficence, or lethality; mysterium tremendum

· Experiencing or expressing emotion of wonder (awe in its fascina-tion, curiosity, or desire-to-know-more aspect) with respect to a phenomenon (especially a movement) which is surprising, non-ordinary, extraordinary, special, or ‘miraculous’; mysterium fascinans

· Binding individuals together or back together in empathic intimacy or communion with respect to experiences of aliveness and animacy, including other living beings or things that appearto be alive, which may secondarily involve the witnessing of this by a collective social group. “



The article and its evidence can be read at this sight.

www.researchgate.net/publication/276915021_The_Case_for_Chimpanzee_Religion_2014



The evolution of humans behavior patterns has created religion in humans. Certainly our closely related family on this planet – the other apes – have significant behavioral traits in common with us.

Is there a case for chimpanzee religion?
I downloaded the PDF and can't wait to read it. The abstract really grabbed me. I have little doubt this is not completely true. We humans think much too highly of ourselves that we completely unique and above all other animals.
 

cladking

Well-Known Member
... and it's clear that it operates at a very basic emotional, almost instinctual level in people. It makes sense that other primates would display proto-religious behaviors, as our primate/hominid ancestors likely did before us.


I don't see that that is clear at all. Even were I to grant that the belief in "God" is "natural" how is an animal to hold or formulate such an abstraction?

How can an animal go from perception of what's around him to something or someone must have caused it?
 

Left Coast

This Is Water
Staff member
Premium Member
I don't see that that is clear at all. Even were I to grant that the belief in "God" is "natural" how is an animal to hold or formulate such an abstraction?

We're animals and we hold and formulate such an abstraction. How do we do it?

Are you an atheist? If so, if belief in God isn't "natural," what is it?

How can an animal go from perception of what's around him to something or someone must have caused it?

We're animals and we go from perceptions of what's around us to inferring cause. How do we do it?

You understand that I'm not suggesting that other primates literally have a religion, or that they're as cognitively evolved as us, right?
 

viole

Ontological Naturalist
Premium Member
Chimpanzee Religion

Do Chimpanzees have religion?

Do we have any evidence that Chimpanzees have religious behavior or is there clear evidence that chimpanzees cannot have religion.

James B. Harrod proposed the following Trans species dimensions to try and define what may be observed as evidence for religion.

“· Reverence (showing devotion, intense love, deep respect)

· Careful observance, which may involve a calling-out announcement or remark

· Experiencing or expressing emotion of dread (awe in its terror or astonishment aspect) before that which overwhelms the subject by its magnitude, grandeur, beneficence, or lethality; mysterium tremendum

· Experiencing or expressing emotion of wonder (awe in its fascina-tion, curiosity, or desire-to-know-more aspect) with respect to a phenomenon (especially a movement) which is surprising, non-ordinary, extraordinary, special, or ‘miraculous’; mysterium fascinans

· Binding individuals together or back together in empathic intimacy or communion with respect to experiences of aliveness and animacy, including other living beings or things that appearto be alive, which may secondarily involve the witnessing of this by a collective social group. “



The article and its evidence can be read at this sight.

www.researchgate.net/publication/276915021_The_Case_for_Chimpanzee_Religion_2014



The evolution of humans behavior patterns has created religion in humans. Certainly our closely related family on this planet – the other apes – have significant behavioral traits in common with us.

Is there a case for chimpanzee religion?
Chimpanzee Religion

Do Chimpanzees have religion?

Do we have any evidence that Chimpanzees have religious behavior or is there clear evidence that chimpanzees cannot have religion.

James B. Harrod proposed the following Trans species dimensions to try and define what may be observed as evidence for religion.

“· Reverence (showing devotion, intense love, deep respect)

· Careful observance, which may involve a calling-out announcement or remark

· Experiencing or expressing emotion of dread (awe in its terror or astonishment aspect) before that which overwhelms the subject by its magnitude, grandeur, beneficence, or lethality; mysterium tremendum

· Experiencing or expressing emotion of wonder (awe in its fascina-tion, curiosity, or desire-to-know-more aspect) with respect to a phenomenon (especially a movement) which is surprising, non-ordinary, extraordinary, special, or ‘miraculous’; mysterium fascinans

· Binding individuals together or back together in empathic intimacy or communion with respect to experiences of aliveness and animacy, including other living beings or things that appearto be alive, which may secondarily involve the witnessing of this by a collective social group. “



The article and its evidence can be read at this sight.

www.researchgate.net/publication/276915021_The_Case_for_Chimpanzee_Religion_2014



The evolution of humans behavior patterns has created religion in humans. Certainly our closely related family on this planet – the other apes – have significant behavioral traits in common with us.

Is there a case for chimpanzee religion?

probably. And those pious chimps get mad when some cleverer chimp tells them that they share a common ancestor with humans.

ciao

- viole
 

cladking

Well-Known Member
We're animals and we hold and formulate such an abstraction. How do we do it?

Are you an atheist? If so, if belief in God isn't "natural," what is it?

Abstractions like "thought", "belief", reductionism, and taxonomies are part of modern languages and these languages are the formatting of thought. We do it by means of a highly complex and symbolic language. Animal languages are neither complex nor symbolic. Like Ancient Language they lack the vocabulary and means to express any sort of abstraction.

We're animals and we go from perceptions of what's around us to inferring cause. How do we do it?

That there exists a cause at all is an abstraction. I'm sure all animals see that all effects have causes but the the extrapolation that there mustta been an initial cause is an abstraction and that this initial cause is a consciousness is a speculation and circular argument. This is what Homo Omnisciencis does; create circular arguments and then live our lives in terms of these arguments.
 
Top