• Welcome to Religious Forums, a friendly forum to discuss all religions in a friendly surrounding.

    Your voice is missing! You will need to register to get access to the following site features:
    • Reply to discussions and create your own threads.
    • Our modern chat room. No add-ons or extensions required, just login and start chatting!
    • Access to private conversations with other members.

    We hope to see you as a part of our community soon!

Search results

  1. Ghazaly

    Debate a Muslim

    - Yeah, I'm not arguing with you about this. Either way, as I stated, both spellings can mean both meanings. & I will leave it at that. - You haven't answered my question. What's it to you whichever way it was? Why does it bother you?
  2. Ghazaly

    Debate a Muslim

    - %!^$!%$ doesn't make sense the way %$*!&^% doesn't make grammar sense. That's how what you said looks to me. Not because it made sense in your head for whatever reason would that make it actually sensible!
  3. Ghazaly

    Debate a Muslim

    - So you're saying the interpretation of the Quran is safeguarded but the text is corrupted? Are you Ismailia? - No. You don't know what you're talking about. What is your point here anyways? If it's attached or not? - That's why I asked are you Arab, because you say things which makes...
  4. Ghazaly

    Debate a Muslim

    - A priori, because the Prophet (pbuh) said so. The simple rational is that there is no penetration in lesbian acts, this also extends to all sexual encounters where no penetration occurred, no penalty shall therefrom ensue. Lesbianism in the tradition is just thought of categorically different...
  5. Ghazaly

    Debate a Muslim

    - This relates to the concept of Ismah – Inviolability in Sharia. There are two schools on this [there is a 3rd view but it's minor & inconsequential in history]. The Hanafi view is that the basis of inviolability is humanity: al-Ismah al-Adamiah – Human Inviolability. Thus, the default assumed...
  6. Ghazaly

    Debate a Muslim

    - Where do you get this nonsense? Are you Arab? - You must be joking. What you're saying is just pure drivel. I can't even begin to qualify it. How come you believe the Quran is true & now you say it's corrupt? You're self-contradicting. - You mean in Rasm? There is no "most" in Rasm. - Where...
  7. Ghazaly

    Debate a Muslim

    - I already said I will do a thread explaining Ilm Rijal. What is that you're proposing? What's the one on one thing?
  8. Ghazaly

    Debate a Muslim

    - Does it though? Maybe a different example could've been more pertinent. But in this particular case both can mean both. Elyassen can be interpreted as a name or as a plural possessive for the name, idem for El Yassen.
  9. Ghazaly

    Debate a Muslim

    - You told no lie, indeed. - Then we would having a Fiqh lecture instead, not a Forum discussion. - Cool... - Are you for the Bible or against? Seems like you contract yourself!
  10. Ghazaly

    Debate a Muslim

    - They do, the ones I'm talking about. - Then we don't have anything further to argue. - A Muslim can be truthful or a liar. One who consistently tells the truth is a truthful person, one who lies is a liar. This is a statement of fact. - I assure you, the 10 Recitations have zero Shia. I...
  11. Ghazaly

    Debate a Muslim

    - It says investigate the truth of information when reported. That is all. - Then how do you know the Quran was perfectly transmitted to you? - You have it backwards. The Shia reject Hadith sciences because they don't have authentic narrations, because if they apply the rules of Hadith...
  12. Ghazaly

    Debate a Muslim

    - No such thing in Arabic. Where are you from? Qubul is the action of acceptance, & Ijab is the action of offering in Arabic. - Qubul wa Ijab is a principle (rukn) in 'Uqud (contracts) in Sharia.
  13. Ghazaly

    Debate a Muslim

    - Clearly you don't understand it yourself.
  14. Ghazaly

    Debate a Muslim

    - You're already back! Sharia is wholly from the Quran & Prophet Muhammed (pbuh). I don't have to quote the Quran or the Prophet (pbuh) every time I state something that relates to Sharia. - Since this is the lifestyle you're aspiring to, while you're at it, get your birthday suit, grow some...
  15. Ghazaly

    Debate a Muslim

    - Rationally, the cause is a necessary being –for otherwise it itself is an event, which can only be singular. Since it's different from the world, then it's transcendent. Since it's the cause of all the world, then it's absolute. Hence, the singular absolute necessary transcendent being...
  16. Ghazaly

    Debate a Muslim

    - I don't see the connection! Scribes use nibs to write letters, pressmen use blocks to imprint letters. Both copy from somewhere else. Where is the perfection here? - How would you know you have the originals? How would you know those recordings if you had them are authentic? - What is...
  17. Ghazaly

    Debate a Muslim

    - That's irrelevant. You have a western mindset, not a Muslim one. Your ancestors founded some of the greatest empires of the world & spread the most humane & enlightened civilization history has ever seen emerging from the prophetic legacy of Prophet Muhammed (pbuh); & yet you are running after...
  18. Ghazaly

    Debate a Muslim

    - Not a problem. - Lust is not a sin. Obsession with lust at the expense of one's faith or action upon it beyond Sharia's boundaries is. Homosexual feelings are just that, feelings. As long as they are inconsequential, they are inconsequential in Sharia; or if privately consequential, then...
  19. Ghazaly

    Debate a Muslim

    - I take this as a concession. You got nothing. Dismissed. - More nonsense. Your extreme lack of historical knowledge is showing! Muslims went into Spain at the behest of the Count of Ceuta & the Lord of Sevilla to take revenge for his daughter Florinda who was raped by the Visigoth king when...
  20. Ghazaly

    Debate a Muslim

    - There are several proof for God established in the Ashaari school, the most important of which is Burhan al-Huduth (proof from eventuality/occurrence/change), a version of which is sometimes translated as the Kalam Cosmological Argument ['Kalam'= 'Islamic theology']. Ashaaris reject most of...
Top