Let's be fair you asked a question and then gave your answer for it... And since you said God didn't legislate it neither the prophet just as you say fallible imams.. Was there really a sincere question in your questioning?
You was in the Arab world but were you looking for ancient Arabic...
which rule exactly cause there are a few? And I am assuming you know the rules...
Bring up whatever you like about al Muwatta since it's funny cause you know that once ab Hadith is changed it's classified as Mulduah, but I have a question can you read and understand Arabic in Oder to look at...
Without Hadith there is no Islam. Any Muslim who doesn't follow the sunnah of the prophet which is preserved in the hadeeth is not a Muslim.. Because if your argument is sound how does a Muslim pray, just any way he wants... How do we perform hajj? How do we pay zakat? All of these are pillars...
Hadith was taken from the companions so how can you say they had no knowledge of it. At the beginning of every Hadith the companion that heard it from the messenger is mentioned and the chain of narrators then followed.. If it's a unknown person well the Hadith becomes weak. According to the...
do you have evidence from tafsir. All the ones you mentioned are idolaters. They have elements of tauhid but they have shirk in their worship. Because they forget about the uloohiyah of the tauhid and that is to worship Allah alone. They add to the worship by putting their prophets, preists...
hey kerr peace and blessings. And hello to everyone been away for a while but I am back.
I agree with you on that they are different, but I would add with similarities. Because the Quran mentioned in several places we have told you these story before in previous scriputures and they were...
Not because it was a threat but more because they as leaders of these superpowers became tyrannical and unjust to their people causing corruption and mischief in the land. they committed injustice, made the people downtrodden by keeping them illiterate, taxing them unjustly, allowing the spread...
give me an example. the later Caliphs were they own men. They grew up in different times the conditions were different. Remember the companions had the most pious hearts and the least superficial. they weren't as corrupt as the later generations. The bidah and fitnah never came from Arabia...
What do you mean?
Yes, and it was to spread the word of Allah and his religion that he legislated throughout mankind, and to also spread his rule all based on the principles of being just, righteous, and not greedy. To stop oppression and tyranny wherever it may be whether caused by non muslims...
wow, I have been away from the forums for a while. really? A muslim treated you this way? that is so not the way of the Messenger pbuh. I guess that is part of the problem, muslims not behaving in this manner.
that is sad. I hate to hear that my brothers and sisters are doing that...
I understand what you are saying but that is something generally the laymen discuss, but not the scholars or students of knowlede. The true historian sifts through the bias statements and looks at the facts.
Because the scholar of history is not trying to establish perspective but just...
How can you as a muslim say that histoy is about perspectives, when we see how the orientalists and enemies of Islam have lied on the Prophet, His companions and all the righteous people before him. Is their perspective correct?
Is the bible from our perspective an accurate depiction of...
It is only legitimate if the intention and application is on what the Quran and sunnah stipulate. fighting oppression, tyranny etc are among the legitamite reasons for regime change. And once the oppressors are removed. The power is given back to the people where they are the one's who rule...
By definition there is only one truth. Especially when talking of actual events. It either happened or didn't, and it either happened this way or it didn't.
Bush either lied about WMD or he didn't. Saddam either killed his people or he didn't. Every body has their own version, but the...
Not if Islam's teaches us to stop oppression, tyranny and injustice no matter where or who it is committed by. Even if its a muslim. The laws of Allah are just. Even to the non muslim.
No, it doesn't especially after knowing the history of Persia, and the hostility of the persian leaders to Arabs. They hated them or any other forms of racism and bigotry. And if you had read my earlier post that me and Odion were discussing where I said that the elite will never give up...
as I said it was peaceful because of the intention. Often times when people do invasions of some sort, history has shown that generally the people invading are doing it to usurp the wealth and resources of the people where often times the invading people are forced to accept whatever is given...