• Welcome to Religious Forums, a friendly forum to discuss all religions in a friendly surrounding.

    Your voice is missing! You will need to register to get access to the following site features:
    • Reply to discussions and create your own threads.
    • Our modern chat room. No add-ons or extensions required, just login and start chatting!
    • Access to private conversations with other members.

    We hope to see you as a part of our community soon!

Search results

  1. ~Amin~

    Why Do Shia Muslims Reject Ali Being the 4th. Caliph?

    Assalamu alakum wb, subhanAllah, i dont see the how you compare this verse with 9v40. There are two ways Allah Taala is with people. 1 He is with them through His Infinite Knowledge, even non Muslims know this.. 2 He Taala is WITH them PROTECTING and SUPPORTING them, and this is exactly what the...
  2. ~Amin~

    Why Do Shia Muslims Reject Ali Being the 4th. Caliph?

    Assalamu Alakum Wa Rahmatullahi Wa Barakatu How does it condemn the sahabi? The text of the Qur'an which is Allah Taala's Word, SAYS, '' Surely Allah is with US'' note, He didnt say Allah is with ME. Also, ''He Taala Says, ''he Muhammad(saas) said to his companion'' meaning his friend. Is Allah...
  3. ~Amin~

    Why Do Shia Muslims Reject Ali Being the 4th. Caliph?

    Assalamu alakum, this is not true, there are authentic narrations according to the Sunni sources, that hadith was recorded in the time of the Prophet saas. It is True that initially the recording of hadith was prohibited, and latter this was abrogated, and the recording of hadith was instructed...
  4. ~Amin~

    Why Do Shia Muslims Reject Ali Being the 4th. Caliph?

    Assalamu alakum, thank you, you posted more than i expected. Quick questions. 1. In Surah 9 verse 40 who is the word ''Sahibi'' companion referring to? 2. According to Shia, does the word Ahlil Bayt, also encompass the Prophet saas, wives? or is it just blood relations?
  5. ~Amin~

    Why Do Shia Muslims Reject Ali Being the 4th. Caliph?

    Assalamu alakum everybody,i follow the sunna of the Prophet, and i love his family and companions, Alhamdulliah. Want to learn what are the Shia most reliable sources after the Qur'an?????? May Allah expand our knowledge of his Deen.
  6. ~Amin~

    Why Do Shia Muslims Reject Ali Being the 4th. Caliph?

    First i want to by Assalamu alakum, evidence please? References please? Where does Sayyid Qutb say this about Uthman?
  7. ~Amin~

    Happy news for males ,Most Of Those Who Will Enter Hell Will Be Women!!

    SubhanAllah, you guys are so funny. Swear to God I've never been lost for words.:D Sorry i cant stop laughing.
  8. ~Amin~

    Suppose evolution was refuted, then what?

    This is very strange, i would like anybody to show me, in ANY religious text, where we are called ''creationists'' or ''Intelligent design''? i personally reject this, you should refer to us as what we are referred to in scripture. Wonder who is doing the deceiving?
  9. ~Amin~

    Suppose evolution was refuted, then what?

    Camanintx, cam you get to the point, and tell us the problem with the definition of God?:)
  10. ~Amin~

    Suppose evolution was refuted, then what?

    Every other thing is limited by boundaries, you may refer to this as time and space, but their movement within this boundary may differ, example, an angel may be in multiple places in one time, but within time and space. God is Unique and doesn't resemble His creation, example, we are living...
  11. ~Amin~

    Suppose evolution was refuted, then what?

    When i said its fine, i was refering to your approach even though you disagree with me, that this is fine. Your right, either you or i, are on guidance or clear error. All that exists.
  12. ~Amin~

    Suppose evolution was refuted, then what?

    Thats fine, your right to think that.
  13. ~Amin~

    Suppose evolution was refuted, then what?

    You have spoken trully, still it only seems strong from a material approach prespective, and can be refuted, through science.
  14. ~Amin~

    Suppose evolution was refuted, then what?

    I did NOT post this to prove any position, except to show the extent of human thought, this was only something to be thought of by those who say '' existence only seems organised and balanced'', but that its only our mind that makes it appear so.
  15. ~Amin~

    Salamu alakum how are you?

    Salamu alakum how are you?
    • ~Amin~
    • Profile post
  16. ~Amin~

    Suppose evolution was refuted, then what?

    "Cogito ergo sum" I think therefore, I am. This is Rene Descartes statement, when he was thinking if existence is real or not, he denied his own body, then he tried to deny the existence of his mind, but then thought, the moment i try to deny my mind, i am actually using my mind, and so he made...
  17. ~Amin~

    Suppose evolution was refuted, then what?

    I have NEVER made a statement unless i honestly believe it, but truly i have great respect, for someone who says i don't know, when they don't.
  18. ~Amin~

    Suppose evolution was refuted, then what?

    Wouldn't say outside of time and space, but rather not bound by time and space. It is also conceivable to say outside of time and space, from a spiritual context if understood correctly. And i really don't think the world supernatural describes this the best way, although it is close.
  19. ~Amin~

    Suppose evolution was refuted, then what?

    This is definitely not acceptable from our position, because there is no limit to this kind of thought, there are people in certain areas that have gone to the extent of saying, ''we really don't exist, even what we SEE is not really there, that all this is only our impression of what we see...
  20. ~Amin~

    Suppose evolution was refuted, then what?

    I didn't say science is better, all these branches of knowledge should be looked at together, to get a complete and overall picture.
Top