• Welcome to Religious Forums, a friendly forum to discuss all religions in a friendly surrounding.

    Your voice is missing! You will need to register to get access to the following site features:
    • Reply to discussions and create your own threads.
    • Our modern chat room. No add-ons or extensions required, just login and start chatting!
    • Access to private conversations with other members.

    We hope to see you as a part of our community soon!

Is Twitter Trump good for the Republican Party, or bad for the Republican Party?

Is Twitter Trump good for the Republican Party, or bad for the Republican Party?

  • Good

    Votes: 3 11.1%
  • Bad

    Votes: 16 59.3%
  • Don't know

    Votes: 8 29.6%

  • Total voters
    27

fantome profane

Anti-Woke = Anti-Justice
Premium Member
Please note that I am asking a specific question. Other general opinions can go it the other thread open on this topic: Fox news: Trump will be reinstated to Twitter

But just on the question about the Republican Party. Do you think Trump on Twitter will be good for the Republican Party, or Bad?

Will Trump use Twitter to attack other Republican politicians? Will he derail their agenda? Will his mere presence be an embarrassment and hinder their ability to attract moderates or independents?

What do you think?
 

Windwalker

Veteran Member
Premium Member
Trump is the greatest threat to the Republican party out there, so yes, anything he says is like cancer cells to the GOP.

But I doubt Trump will even go back on Twitter because he has already said he has his own platform he uses now. I doubt his bruised ego would let him come back either now. But even if he does, Twitter will be dead within a couple months anyway because Musk destroyed it overnight from within, losing his core knowledge teams that built it up, due to his own oversized ego, flushing $44 billon straight down the toilet.

So Trump being reinstated is like winning a ticket for a ride on the Titanic, whose destination is an iceberg and the bottom of the ocean. Ironically, if you think about this, Trump is that iceberg that Twitter hit, and now he will ultimately sink it to the bottom of the ocean. It was because of Trump's antics, that Captain Musk took the helm and steered Twitter straight down to its watery grave.
 
Last edited:

Sand Dancer

Crazy Cat Lady
Please note that I am asking a specific question. Other general opinions can go it the other thread open on this topic: Fox news: Trump will be reinstated to Twitter

But just on the question about the Republican Party. Do you think Trump on Twitter will be good for the Republican Party, or Bad?

Will Trump use Twitter to attack other Republican politicians? Will he derail their agenda? Will his mere presence be an embarrassment and hinder their ability to attract moderates or independents?

What do you think?
He is bad for the human race. He has already turned much of the right off.
 

exchemist

Veteran Member
Please note that I am asking a specific question. Other general opinions can go it the other thread open on this topic: Fox news: Trump will be reinstated to Twitter

But just on the question about the Republican Party. Do you think Trump on Twitter will be good for the Republican Party, or Bad?

Will Trump use Twitter to attack other Republican politicians? Will he derail their agenda? Will his mere presence be an embarrassment and hinder their ability to attract moderates or independents?

What do you think?
He will try to make the Republican party all about him, yet again, and that will be bad for the party. I do not believe, based on recent expressions of public opinion, that Trump would be a successful candidate next time. So he will be a distraction. He is quite capable of damaging the other saner candidates and his continued presence will contaminate the party in the minds of the all-important swing voters. Last time, people gave Trump the benefit of the doubt, thinking he would be better in government than he seemed. That proved not to be the case, hence why he failed to get a second term. I do not see swing voters opting for a second helping of Trump and I think the Republican party is now realising that.

I think they will try to wheel him off - but they will have a struggle and that will be a damaging sub-plot for them, if highly entertaining for the rest of us. :D
 

Twilight Hue

Twilight, not bright nor dark, good nor bad.
Please note that I am asking a specific question. Other general opinions can go it the other thread open on this topic: Fox news: Trump will be reinstated to Twitter

But just on the question about the Republican Party. Do you think Trump on Twitter will be good for the Republican Party, or Bad?

Will Trump use Twitter to attack other Republican politicians? Will he derail their agenda? Will his mere presence be an embarrassment and hinder their ability to attract moderates or independents?

What do you think?
Your question asks respondents be specific weither Trump is good or bad, but you go on to ask if he will attack and derail other Republican agendas , embarrass,, and attack moderates or independents.

The op is far too loaded to answer effectively.
 

Shaul

Well-Known Member
Premium Member
The question is hypothetical or moot. Trump has announced he won't be returning to Twitter.
 

Stevicus

Veteran Member
Staff member
Premium Member
Please note that I am asking a specific question. Other general opinions can go it the other thread open on this topic: Fox news: Trump will be reinstated to Twitter

But just on the question about the Republican Party. Do you think Trump on Twitter will be good for the Republican Party, or Bad?

Will Trump use Twitter to attack other Republican politicians? Will he derail their agenda? Will his mere presence be an embarrassment and hinder their ability to attract moderates or independents?

What do you think?

I look at politics as something not unlike a pendulum which goes back and forth, but never in the exact same place as before. Both the Democrats and Republicans have had their ups and downs, where one party appeared unstoppable and other looked weak. The history of both parties is intertwined with the history of US politics, which also has been rather wild in spots.

Parties are often defined by their leading figures, and Trump appears to be the leading figure of the Republicans at present. Others might look back to other Republicans in the past, such as Eisenhower or Henry Cabot Lodge Jr. Many still look to Reagan as the defining leader of the GOP even today, though many still refer to it as the party of Abraham Lincoln.

For the purpose of your question, I would define "good" or "bad" only in the sense of whether Trump can help Republicans win elections (or whether he himself can get re-elected). At this point, I voted "I don't know," since it appears that the predicted "red wave" was narrowly averted, but not by much.

Another major factor is the general quality of life and state of affairs in the country and the world as a whole, the economy, supply chain, energy costs, shrinking paychecks, healthcare costs, housing costs and an increasingly impatient public waiting for their elected officials to do something beneficial for the people. Depending on whether the overall situation is good or bad, that will influence whether Trump's presence in US politics is benign or malignant.
 

England my lionheart

Rockerjahili Rebel
Premium Member
I voted bad,give him a shovel and give him a stage and let him speak,for rational people it’s easy to spot BS,the problem is that the millions of Trump supporters can’t imo.
 

SomeRandom

Still learning to be wise
Staff member
Premium Member
Please note that I am asking a specific question. Other general opinions can go it the other thread open on this topic: Fox news: Trump will be reinstated to Twitter

But just on the question about the Republican Party. Do you think Trump on Twitter will be good for the Republican Party, or Bad?

Will Trump use Twitter to attack other Republican politicians? Will he derail their agenda? Will his mere presence be an embarrassment and hinder their ability to attract moderates or independents?

What do you think?
He has claimed that he rejected the offer to return. Not sure if that will remain to be true, perhaps it will.
I’m not American so I can only comment from what I’ve seen from folks trying to “analyse Trump” so to speak.
There seems to be a fear that the loyal Trump supporters will break off from the Reps if Trump decides to split off and form his own party. And I honestly can see him doing just that. The man just wants praise and his loyalists seemingly worship him, it’s honestly kind of creepy to watch.
Not saying a person can’t support Trump if they want to. Whatever
I’m just saying, from afar the super loyal Trump base looks like a cult
 

Evangelicalhumanist

"Truth" isn't a thing...
Premium Member
Definitely bad. But then, Trump is bad for the Republican party on whatever platform he rants on.

Most members of political parties have enough sense not to dis other members, because that tends to make it more difficult for the party to focus on its agenda. Any disagreements they have are usually fought out in camera. But Trump doesn't care about anyone, anything or any party except Trump. He's not interested in helping the Republican party focus on its agenda, if its agenda isn't Donald Trump
 

Twilight Hue

Twilight, not bright nor dark, good nor bad.
The question is hypothetical or moot. Trump has announced he won't be returning to Twitter.
Yea. That ole' stick of dynamite had fizzled and has no more punch for the buck.

Time to seek out new faces and places and light another fuze and dance away.

 

fantome profane

Anti-Woke = Anti-Justice
Premium Member
Yea. That ole' stick of dynamite had fizzled and has no more punch for the buck.

Time to seek out new faces and places and light another fuze and dance away.

albert-einstein-definition-of-insanity2661617-prints.jpg
 

Father Heathen

Veteran Member
Yea. That ole' stick of dynamite had fizzled and has no more punch for the buck.

Time to seek out new faces and places and light another fuze and dance away.

The American people took that stick of dynamite and slam dunked it into the latrine, where it exploded and splattered the GOP.
 

lewisnotmiller

Grand Hat
Staff member
Premium Member
Please note that I am asking a specific question. Other general opinions can go it the other thread open on this topic: Fox news: Trump will be reinstated to Twitter

But just on the question about the Republican Party. Do you think Trump on Twitter will be good for the Republican Party, or Bad?

Will Trump use Twitter to attack other Republican politicians? Will he derail their agenda? Will his mere presence be an embarrassment and hinder their ability to attract moderates or independents?

What do you think?

Sorry, I don't know.

I suspect it'll have a strong polarising effect. That could mean the GOP primary battle gets very dirty and causes scars that negatively impacts on their run to the general election.
Or it could mean one candidate (either Trump or his most public opponent...perhaps DeSantos) builds a lot of momentum.

I'm finding it a little hard to know which. I will say, I think it's good for Trump. It introduces an additional element into the public discourse, and his current position isn't as strong as he'd want. A change element like this, that's been politically useful in the past, gives some strategic optionality for him.
 

Hermit Philosopher

Selflessly here for you
Please note that I am asking a specific question. Other general opinions can go it the other thread open on this topic: Fox news: Trump will be reinstated to Twitter

But just on the question about the Republican Party. Do you think Trump on Twitter will be good for the Republican Party, or Bad?

Will Trump use Twitter to attack other Republican politicians? Will he derail their agenda? Will his mere presence be an embarrassment and hinder their ability to attract moderates or independents?

What do you think?

I think that Trump on twitter will be good for Democrats.

And it will be good for twitter traffic. It will be good for Elon Musk.

I think that Trump, in general, is bad for everybody.


Humbly
Hermit
 

Daemon Sophic

Avatar in flux
Your question asks respondents be specific weither Trump is good or bad, but you go on to ask if he will attack and derail other Republican agendas , embarrass,, and attack moderates or independents.

The op is far too loaded to answer effectively.
The OP did list possible bad aspects of Trump getting back onto Twitter; but perhaps you could name some features that his theoretical return to Twitter that would improve the odds for his party and their causes. For example; "His inspirational and inciteful tweets will motivate the working class Americans to rise up en masse, and as one, vote all Republicans into office in a landslide victory the likes of which even God has not witnessed."
You know, :shrug: or whatever. It's an open forum.

The question is hypothetical or moot. Trump has announced he won't be returning to Twitter.
And as a true and honorable man of his word, you expect that he would never come out with some excuses to get back on again? o_O
 
Top