Doc
Space Chief
One particular think seems to irk me in my christian class at school. I have certainly learned a lot from it, but it is usually the discussion part where I am bothered.
First off, I am a cunning speaker, debater, and personality changer. (I play as a one man news cast with my camera at home) So when I speak in class, it has to be well thought out and I can always say in such a way where neither side is offended. However I am always intrigued when others speak in class.
When it comes to matters of opinion and some philosophy, it is not uncommon for people to flat out say that the other speaker was wrong. One boy once said that a fairly upper class girl was too engrossed in her fashion because she always wanted the nicest things. And that another girl was too caught up in what she was going to wear and who she was going to impress.
The common teacher response was to say that we should not judge because only God can judge. I hold this to be true also, but does not Jesus say to help those on the wrong path?
When is it right for us to say that the other person is wrong? When do we have that right? Most of the things I hear in school is that we should not judge others based on a philosophy or belief. "That's there belief and you should not judge it!"
To a certain extent, it is true, but it can greatly be bypassed. Sometimes, we must stand for what we hold to be true and right. Am I wrong to call a racist a fool and tell them they are wrong? Is it so hard to say what Hitler did was wrong? That the extermination of 6 million Jews was okay just because that was Hitler's belief and we should not judge? I think not. The same applies on the smaller scale debates in philosophy. So can we accuse a very rich self centered person of being greedy? I think so.
I may be judging, but what do you think?
First off, I am a cunning speaker, debater, and personality changer. (I play as a one man news cast with my camera at home) So when I speak in class, it has to be well thought out and I can always say in such a way where neither side is offended. However I am always intrigued when others speak in class.
When it comes to matters of opinion and some philosophy, it is not uncommon for people to flat out say that the other speaker was wrong. One boy once said that a fairly upper class girl was too engrossed in her fashion because she always wanted the nicest things. And that another girl was too caught up in what she was going to wear and who she was going to impress.
The common teacher response was to say that we should not judge because only God can judge. I hold this to be true also, but does not Jesus say to help those on the wrong path?
When is it right for us to say that the other person is wrong? When do we have that right? Most of the things I hear in school is that we should not judge others based on a philosophy or belief. "That's there belief and you should not judge it!"
To a certain extent, it is true, but it can greatly be bypassed. Sometimes, we must stand for what we hold to be true and right. Am I wrong to call a racist a fool and tell them they are wrong? Is it so hard to say what Hitler did was wrong? That the extermination of 6 million Jews was okay just because that was Hitler's belief and we should not judge? I think not. The same applies on the smaller scale debates in philosophy. So can we accuse a very rich self centered person of being greedy? I think so.
I may be judging, but what do you think?