• Welcome to Religious Forums, a friendly forum to discuss all religions in a friendly surrounding.

    Your voice is missing! You will need to register to get access to the following site features:
    • Reply to discussions and create your own threads.
    • Our modern chat room. No add-ons or extensions required, just login and start chatting!
    • Access to private conversations with other members.

    We hope to see you as a part of our community soon!

Trump Impeachment 2.0

tytlyf

Not Religious
They better hurry up... they only have 6 days left (since today is over).
Isn't that up to Mitch McConnell?
Mitch wouldn't vote to remove. Just like before.
So the democratic senate will take care of it.
 

Evangelicalhumanist

"Truth" isn't a thing...
Premium Member
Isn't that up to Mitch McConnel?
Mitch wouldn't vote to remove. Just like before.
So the democratic senate will take care of it.
Just perhaps you should not be so sure of that. Mitch just lost his pre-eminence in the Senate, largely due to Trump. And it does look to me as if he is preparing to purge "Trumpism" from the Republican mind-set.
 

tytlyf

Not Religious
Just perhaps you should not be so sure of that. Mitch just lost his pre-eminence in the Senate, largely due to Trump. And it does look to me as if he is preparing to purge "Trumpism" from the Republican mind-set.
I didn't expect Mitch to do anything.
We need to write up Impeachment #3 for the Georgia "perfect" phone call.
 

Daemon Sophic

Avatar in flux
No. Mitch said it will wait till their winter break is over. He also said that (as the new senate minority head) he is not sure which way he personally will vote.

It is avtually probably better this way. More republicans will pull their heads out of (insert your choice of holes here) and be more likely to vote in support of the US and the Constitution, rather than the way they would if forced to vote now. :shrug:
 

Sunstone

De Diablo Del Fora
Premium Member
Not to mention that if the senate also impeaches him, he loses most if not all of the perks of a former president.

I believe he keeps the perks unless the Senate votes to deny them to him following his conviction. Same as he retains the right to run for office unless the Senate votes to deny that to him, too.
 

Sunstone

De Diablo Del Fora
Premium Member
Isn't that up to Mitch McConnell?

The timing of the Senate trial is largely up to Nancy Pelosi. She can hold the articles of impeachment for as long as she likes before sending them over to the Senate. Once the Senate has received them, they have a limited time -- a few days -- before they must hold a trial. But that time is long enough to enable McConnell from preventing a trial before Trump is out of office.

If Pelosi has any brains, she will carefully weigh when she sends the articles to the Senate. The trade-offs are what she must consider. Send them sooner, maybe there's a better chance of conviction, but then the Senate will be busy with the trial rather than implementing Biden's program as fast as possible. Send them later -- say, a hundred days later -- and there are again benefits and disadvantages to that. This is a real test of her political skills.
 

Heyo

Veteran Member
They better hurry up... they only have 6 days left (since today is over).
Nope. They have all the time. If he gets ousted by the Senate (and that can happen even after he left office), he can't run again in 2024. (Which makes it much more likely that the republicans go along this time. One competitor eliminated.)
 

Heyo

Veteran Member
The timing of the Senate trial is largely up to Nancy Pelosi. She can hold the articles of impeachment for as long as she likes before sending them over to the Senate. Once the Senate has received them, they have a limited time -- a few days -- before they must hold a trial. But that time is long enough to enable McConnell from preventing a trial before Trump is out of office.

If Pelosi has any brains, she will carefully weigh when she sends the articles to the Senate. The trade-offs are what she must consider. Send them sooner, maybe there's a better chance of conviction, but then the Senate will be busy with the trial rather than implementing Biden's program as fast as possible. Send them later -- say, a hundred days later -- and there are again benefits and disadvantages to that. This is a real test of her political skills.

I thought about making an OP about that but it seems to little for a discussion.

The US system is full of single points of failure. Pelosi (or rather her office) is one, McConnell is one (independent from his office), (which now(soon?) is held by Schumer), Pence was one.
These are offices held by a single person with the duty (or power if you like) to perform a function which, if not done, halts a whole process.

(Why Pence? If he didn't oversee the counting of the votes, Biden couldn't have officially become president. The insurrection was an attempt to intimidate Pence, the single point of failure.)
 

We Never Know

No Slack
I believe he keeps the perks unless the Senate votes to deny them to him following his conviction. Same as he retains the right to run for office unless the Senate votes to deny that to him, too.

Those perks include:

  • Pensions equal to the annual pay of a cabinet member ($221,400 in 2021).
  • Starting six months after leaving office, a governmental allowance for an office, staffing and equipment.
  • Reimbursed travel expenses of up to $1 million annually for the ex-president and up to two staffers; spouses are allowed up to $500,000 for travel.
  • Lifetime security services provided by the Secret Service.
  • Health benefits through the government’s Federal Employees Health Benefits Program, but only if they had five years of federal employment (Trump, like Jimmy Carter, would not qualify with only four years of civilian service).
  • Funerals with full honors and the option of burial at Arlington National Cemetery.
Would Trump lose those benefits if impeached and convicted?

Probably, though maybe not all of them. Under the Former Presidents Act of 1958 (FPA), which created many of the ex-president perks, presidents removed by impeachment are ineligible. But the NTU noted the 10-year limit on post-presidential Secret Service protection was increased to lifetime protection in 2013 and the statutory language did not include the prohibition on benefits for impeached and removed former chief executives.

Notably, the FPA only makes convicted presidents ineligible — impeached but not convicted presidents remain eligible. And with the language that presidents still get benefits if they leave office “other than by removal” through the U.S. Constitution’s impeachment clause, it is unclear a Trump convicted after he’s left the White House — which appears more likely with Mitch McConnell, for now, in possession of the upper hand in a dispute over whether the Senate can be called back into session under this emergency scenario — would lose the perks.


What could Trump lose by being impeached and removed? A lot.
 

tytlyf

Not Religious
The timing of the Senate trial is largely up to Nancy Pelosi.
In that case, good. She should hold onto the articles until the new leadership comes in to the senate.
No point passing the articles to Mitch if we already know (from past experience) Republicans won't do the right thing and hold this POTUS accountable.
 
Top