Welcome to Religious Forums, a friendly forum to discuss all religions in a friendly surrounding.
Your voice is missing! You will need to register to get access to the following site features:We hope to see you as a part of our community soon!
You're conflating YHWH with Elohim. YHWH is one (echad), but Elohim is a plural word.Male and female are also called "one". And the hebrew word "one" (echad) for male and female is the same word used for God.
Moses did not cosign the following:
So God created man in their own image
Some words can be both singular and plural, like "one deer," "many deer." Elohim can meany many gods or heavenly beings, or it can refer to the single God of Israel, which has the name of the tetragrammaton. Echad means both a count of one and unity.You're conflating YHWH with Elohim. YHWH is one (echad), but Elohim is a plural word.
Echad can be used to describe unity or to describe one of many. In the shema (Deuteronomy 6:4) there's nothing that would indicate that echad means unity of anything.
Not in Hebrew though.Some words can be both singular and plural, like "one deer,"
No, The plural word elohim isn't used in that context.Elohim can meany many gods or heavenly beings, or it can refer to the single God of Israel, which has the name of the tetragrammaton.
Yes, this does happen in Hebrew as well. Now, I'm not fluent in Hebrew, so any person who knows Hebrew can correct me ( not you, since you obviously do no speak Hebrew). But this is what I've been taught; not only is Elohim the SINGULAR when used to refer to the One True God (a kind of royal we), but another example would be the word "seed" -- just like in English, it can mean one seed, but more often means many seeds, as in the Seed of Abraham referring to all of Abraham's descendants.Not in Hebrew though.
No, The plural word elohim isn't used in that context.
כה־אמר יהוה אלהי ישראל שלח את־עמי
"Thus saith the LORD God of Israel, Let my people go"
Exodus 5:1
The "One True God" can be anything you like. What you're talking about is Elohist doctrine, and from that doctrine you get the conflation of Genesis 1 with Genesis 2, which implies that incest was unavoidable even through it was forbidden. Also you have to apply special rules when interpreting language like אלהי and אלהינו.But this is what I've been taught; not only is Elohim the SINGULAR when used to refer to the One True God (a kind of royal we), but another example would be the word "seed" -- just like in English, it can mean one seed, but more often means many seeds, as in the Seed of Abraham referring to all of Abraham's descendants.
What I'm talking about is the obvious idea that the God in the Tanakh is the same God whether he is called the tetragrammaton or Elohim or El Shaddai, or any one of a list of other names. The God in Gen 1 and Gen 2 is the same God, even though the two stories are written by very different people in different times. Simply put, only one God exists. Call him what you may, there is only one possible actual deity that may be addressed.The "One True God" can be anything you like. What you're talking about is Elohist doctrine, and from that doctrine you get the conflation of Genesis 1 with Genesis 2, which implies that incest was unavoidable even through it was forbidden. Also you have to apply special rules when interpreting language like אלהי and אלהינו.
Being obvious doesn't make an idea true.What I'm talking about is the obvious idea that the God in the Tanakh is the same God whether he is called the tetragrammaton or Elohim or El Shaddai, or any one of a list of other names.
Alre you talking about Elohim or YHWH Elohim? The point is that when you conflate these two you end up with absurdities like YHWH having a multiple personality disorder.The God in Gen 1 and Gen 2 is the same God
If that were true the first commandment of Exodus 20 would be redundant and Psalm 82 would be a nonsense.Simply put, only one God exists.