• Welcome to Religious Forums, a friendly forum to discuss all religions in a friendly surrounding.

    Your voice is missing! You will need to register to get access to the following site features:
    • Reply to discussions and create your own threads.
    • Our modern chat room. No add-ons or extensions required, just login and start chatting!
    • Access to private conversations with other members.

    We hope to see you as a part of our community soon!

British people guess how much US healthcare costs.

SomeRandom

Still learning to be wise
Staff member
Premium Member
My neighbor recently had an accident that required him to be medvac'd to a larger hospital. His medvac bill alone was $18,000.
Wait, seriously? To use a medical emergency service?????
Why bother paying your taxes if emergency services aren’t “free?”
Also at the risk of inciting mod anger may I post this clip, which succinctly sums up my thoughts on the US “health care” system.
upload_2019-12-4_10-46-31.gif
 

Flame

Beware
Wait, seriously? To use a medical emergency service?????
Why bother paying your taxes if emergency services aren’t “free?”
Also at the risk of inciting mod anger may I post this clip, which succinctly sums up my thoughts on the US “health care” system.
View attachment 34882

This was by helicopter and the lowest that I've seen charged. Highest I've heard of was $50,000.

The total bill for accident was around $140k, he's a 75 year old man. I believe he won't have it paid off before he's dead.
 

SomeRandom

Still learning to be wise
Staff member
Premium Member
This was by helicopter and the lowest that I've seen charged. Highest I've heard of was $50,000.

The total bill for accident was around $140k, he's a 75 year old man. I believe he won't have it paid off before he's dead.
Geez!
 

amorphous_constellation

Well-Known Member
People wonder why we're religious here, it's largely because society doesn't give us a good net for downfall. Therefore, we trust in the gods, in forces we can't see. Largely, we retain the ethos of the dark ages in some ways, and in many cases the lifestyle. Any gold I have gathered could be here today and gone tomorrow, I trust superstitiously in the better winds of fate to avoid a storm. I feel spooked even talking about this, but I humbly only want to tell you the truth
 

Cooky

Veteran Member
This was by helicopter and the lowest that I've seen charged. Highest I've heard of was $50,000.

The total bill for accident was around $140k, he's a 75 year old man. I believe he won't have it paid off before he's dead.

The hospital will eat the cost.
 

Cooky

Veteran Member
They'll get paid through his land I assume. He has 50 acres and that can be liquidated.

I think only the IRS can do that in regards to private property as far as I know... I mean aside from mortgage lenders.

...I'm pretty sure private creditors don't have that legal option when collecting debts -They just lose.
 

Cooky

Veteran Member
Business is risky in a free-market. Even for hospitals -they lose all the time.

...Maybe that's why the prices are so high? To compensate for predicted losses?
 

Cooky

Veteran Member
The system will eat the people

I just wish people like this would have family that would help them. The fact that she probably does [Edit: she does have two older children not helping], means that her family has a lot of room for growth as far as compassion.

How unfortunate that it has come to this for so many, because if she just had a residence and people to give her a little help, she could probably get her social security benefits.

...Who could let their own mother live on the streets? As sick as she is... Yet she is so loving, she defends them.
 
Last edited by a moderator:
Brits pay for their healthcare. 12% of earning every week, every month, every year throughout your life whether you are ill or not.

National Insurance isn't an 'NHS tax', it's really about benefits, pensions, etc, and it is significantly less than 12% of earnings. If you earned 30k it would be closer to 7%, 60k would be around 8.5% (although there are employer contributions too).

NHS is mostly paid for out of general taxation revenue and its budget is less than total NI revenue.
 
...Maybe that's why the prices are so high? To compensate for predicted losses?

The prices are so high because your government has decided to make you pay far more than everyone else for things like medicines (could be up to 10 times the cost for the same meds overseas).

You also pay the average doctor lots more, and medical practitioners pay far more in insurances because of your compensation culture and ludicrous payouts.

And that's before the profiteering and systemic overtreatment is taken into account.
 

ChristineM

"Be strong", I whispered to my coffee.
Premium Member
It's My Birthday!
National Insurance isn't an 'NHS tax', it's really about benefits, pensions, etc, and it is significantly less than 12% of earnings. If you earned 30k it would be closer to 7%, 60k would be around 8.5% (although there are employer contributions too).

NHS is mostly paid for out of general taxation revenue and its budget is less than total NI revenue.


You need to brush up on NI if you are going to make sweeping statements about it,

Sure its not all going to the NHS but it is 12% of earnings.

Check the uk government website if you dont believe me
National Insurance
 

HonestJoe

Well-Known Member
You need to brush up on NI if you are going to make sweeping statements about it,
Right back at you. :cool:

As your own links make perfectly clear, you pay nothing on the first £166 pw, 12% on anything between £166 and £962 pw and 2% on anything over that.

If I earn £500 pw, I pay nothing on the first $166 and 12% on the remaining £334, which would be around £40. £40 is around 8% of my £500.

Nobody pays 12% of their total income in National Insurance.
 

Cooky

Veteran Member
The prices are so high because your government has decided to make you pay far more than everyone else for things like medicines (could be up to 10 times the cost for the same meds overseas).

You also pay the average doctor lots more, and medical practitioners pay far more in insurances because of your compensation culture and ludicrous payouts.

And that's before the profiteering and systemic overtreatment is taken into account.

Actually, it's not the governmemt, it's big pharma.
 

ChristineM

"Be strong", I whispered to my coffee.
Premium Member
It's My Birthday!
Right back at you. :cool:

As your own links make perfectly clear, you pay nothing on the first £166 pw, 12% on anything between £166 and £962 pw and 2% on anything over that.

If I earn £500 pw, I pay nothing on the first $166 and 12% on the remaining £334, which would be around £40. £40 is around 8% of my £500.

Nobody pays 12% of their total income in National Insurance.


As i stated in a previous post, thanks
 

ChristineM

"Be strong", I whispered to my coffee.
Premium Member
It's My Birthday!
But you also said "it is 12% of earnings", which isn't true. You just seem to want a simple statement to make it sound worse than it is.

I am stating fact

The government website states

Your pay Class 1 National Insurance rate
£166 to £962 a week (£719 to £4,167 a month) 12%
Over £962 a week (£4,167 a month) 2%


There are exceptions, which i also mentioned in a previous post
 
Top