• Welcome to Religious Forums, a friendly forum to discuss all religions in a friendly surrounding.

    Your voice is missing! You will need to register to get access to the following site features:
    • Reply to discussions and create your own threads.
    • Our modern chat room. No add-ons or extensions required, just login and start chatting!
    • Access to private conversations with other members.

    We hope to see you as a part of our community soon!

What Did Jesus Know?

rrobs

Well-Known Member
Speaking of his return to set up the everlasting kingdom on earth, Jesus said,

Matt 16:27-28,

27 For the Son of man shall come in the glory of his Father with his angels; and then he shall reward every man according to his works.

28 Verily I say unto you, There be some standing here, which shall not taste of death, till they see the Son of man coming in his kingdom.​

Many say that the “end times” Jesus spoke of occurred in 70 A.D., when Herod’s temple was destroyed. On the one hand, that would certainly explain Jesus’ statement that some of those to whom he spoke would live to see them. But on the other hand, speaking of the end times, Jesus plainly said that at the end of the day there would not be one stone left on top of another (Matt 24:2). To this day there are some 45 layers of stone piled one atop another. Besides, when has history recorded Jesus coming in glory with his angels? Sorry, it just hasn’t happened. It’ll be hard to miss when it does happen! When Jesus spoke these words in Matthew he was referring to the events that will yet take place as recorded in Revelation.

So how can we explain Jesus’ words that some to whom he personally spoke would live to see his second coming? Do we have 2,000 year old (and counting) people walking this earth today? Of course not! There is a much better explanation: with the information that Jesus had when he was here for the first time, he was absolutely correct in his statement. But there was something about which he knew not.

The only scriptures Jesus had available to learn from were Genesis to Malachi. From those scriptures he understood that God promised Israel an everlasting Kingdom of which he would be the king. He also knew that before his glory he would have to suffer. There are tons of verses that taught him that very thing as he studied them and grew in stature and wisdom.

From the scroll of Daniel, Jesus ascertained that the time between his first coming and his second coming would be 7 years. That is why, to the best of his knowledge, he thought some of those to whom he spoke would be alive when he returned as King of Kings and Lord of Lords.

But Jesus did not know everything about his Father’s plan, the logos of John 1:1. Specifically he knew nothing about the administration in which we are currently living, which began on the day of Pentecost and will end when Jesus gathers us together (1 Thes 4:13) just before his second appearance as King of Kings and Lord of Lords, i.e the Book of Revelation. It is a very unique time that really has no parallels in the Old Testament, including the Gospels. Grace vs. law being perhaps the most notable difference, but there are many others. Jesus came for Israel (Matthew 15:24). That was the mission assigned to him by God. He knew nothing about Christians. The first Christians were not to be seen until the day of Pentecost, some 50 days after Jesus’ resurrection.

A few years after Jesus’ ascension; God gave Paul a revelation which the King James calls “the mystery.” The Greek word (musterion) is better translated as secret. A mystery may never be understood, but a secret, once revealed can easily be understood. Paul speaks of this mystery/secret many times in his Epistles. One only needs to look up the word “mystery” in a concordance.

Paul, by inspiration of God, said that the mystery was kept secret since the beginning of time (Ephesians 3:4-5, et. al.). God was the only one who knew about His complete plan (the logos). 1 Corinthians 2:8 says that the devil would not have crucified Jesus had he known the secret. Why? Part of God’s secret plan was that all born again believers would have Christ dwelling within (Col 1:25-27). Instead of one Jesus for the devil to keep track of, he now has many millions of people filled with the same power and authority Jesus had when he lived. That must have blown the devil’s mind when Paul finally revealed the secret in his Epistles. Of course he can largely mitigate his problem by keeping Christians from a knowledge of the mystery. Judging from a virtually total lack of teaching on the subject in our churches every Sunday, he seems to be doing a pretty good job of it. I’m amazed at how the vast majority of Christians I mention the mystery to stare back at me with an inquisitive look. “The what?,” they often say. And yet, the mystery is “what’s happening” in our day and age.

To get to the point of why Jesus thought some of those to whom he spoke would be around at his second advent, it is simply because Jesus knew nothing about the mystery/secret, God revealed later to the Apostle Paul. From the only scriptures he had at hand (he of course didn’t have Paul’s epistles) , he thought he’d be back in seven years. Of course we now know that this age of grace has lasted at least 2,000 years. How much longer will it last? I have no idea and neither does anybody else.

With the only information available to Jesus, he was spot on right about his statement. I think it is that simple.
 

Rational Agnostic

Well-Known Member
Why did he make a false prediction about something he was ignorant about? If he got this wrong, why should we trust anything else he said?
 

leov

Well-Known Member
Speaking of his return to set up the everlasting kingdom on earth, Jesus said,

Matt 16:27-28,

27 For the Son of man shall come in the glory of his Father with his angels; and then he shall reward every man according to his works.

28 Verily I say unto you, There be some standing here, which shall not taste of death, till they see the Son of man coming in his kingdom.​

Many say that the “end times” Jesus spoke of occurred in 70 A.D., when Herod’s temple was destroyed. On the one hand, that would certainly explain Jesus’ statement that some of those to whom he spoke would live to see them. But on the other hand, speaking of the end times, Jesus plainly said that at the end of the day there would not be one stone left on top of another (Matt 24:2). To this day there are some 45 layers of stone piled one atop another. Besides, when has history recorded Jesus coming in glory with his angels? Sorry, it just hasn’t happened. It’ll be hard to miss when it does happen! When Jesus spoke these words in Matthew he was referring to the events that will yet take place as recorded in Revelation.

So how can we explain Jesus’ words that some to whom he personally spoke would live to see his second coming? Do we have 2,000 year old (and counting) people walking this earth today? Of course not! There is a much better explanation: with the information that Jesus had when he was here for the first time, he was absolutely correct in his statement. But there was something about which he knew not.

The only scriptures Jesus had available to learn from were Genesis to Malachi. From those scriptures he understood that God promised Israel an everlasting Kingdom of which he would be the king. He also knew that before his glory he would have to suffer. There are tons of verses that taught him that very thing as he studied them and grew in stature and wisdom.

From the scroll of Daniel, Jesus ascertained that the time between his first coming and his second coming would be 7 years. That is why, to the best of his knowledge, he thought some of those to whom he spoke would be alive when he returned as King of Kings and Lord of Lords.

But Jesus did not know everything about his Father’s plan, the logos of John 1:1. Specifically he knew nothing about the administration in which we are currently living, which began on the day of Pentecost and will end when Jesus gathers us together (1 Thes 4:13) just before his second appearance as King of Kings and Lord of Lords, i.e the Book of Revelation. It is a very unique time that really has no parallels in the Old Testament, including the Gospels. Grace vs. law being perhaps the most notable difference, but there are many others. Jesus came for Israel (Matthew 15:24). That was the mission assigned to him by God. He knew nothing about Christians. The first Christians were not to be seen until the day of Pentecost, some 50 days after Jesus’ resurrection.

A few years after Jesus’ ascension; God gave Paul a revelation which the King James calls “the mystery.” The Greek word (musterion) is better translated as secret. A mystery may never be understood, but a secret, once revealed can easily be understood. Paul speaks of this mystery/secret many times in his Epistles. One only needs to look up the word “mystery” in a concordance.

Paul, by inspiration of God, said that the mystery was kept secret since the beginning of time (Ephesians 3:4-5, et. al.). God was the only one who knew about His complete plan (the logos). 1 Corinthians 2:8 says that the devil would not have crucified Jesus had he known the secret. Why? Part of God’s secret plan was that all born again believers would have Christ dwelling within (Col 1:25-27). Instead of one Jesus for the devil to keep track of, he now has many millions of people filled with the same power and authority Jesus had when he lived. That must have blown the devil’s mind when Paul finally revealed the secret in his Epistles. Of course he can largely mitigate his problem by keeping Christians from a knowledge of the mystery. Judging from a virtually total lack of teaching on the subject in our churches every Sunday, he seems to be doing a pretty good job of it. I’m amazed at how the vast majority of Christians I mention the mystery to stare back at me with an inquisitive look. “The what?,” they often say. And yet, the mystery is “what’s happening” in our day and age.

To get to the point of why Jesus thought some of those to whom he spoke would be around at his second advent, it is simply because Jesus knew nothing about the mystery/secret, God revealed later to the Apostle Paul. From the only scriptures he had at hand (he of course didn’t have Paul’s epistles) , he thought he’d be back in seven years. Of course we now know that this age of grace has lasted at least 2,000 years. How much longer will it last? I have no idea and neither does anybody else.

With the only information available to Jesus, he was spot on right about his statement. I think it is that simple.
Answer is in v 16-17. 'Coming of Christ is enlightenment, as with Peter, to whom this information came from the F'ather.
 

rrobs

Well-Known Member
Why did he make a false prediction about something he was ignorant about? If he got this wrong, why should we trust anything else he said?
Ignorant? He was actually the greatest scripture student who ever lived.

Ignorance is a lack of knowledge. In some arena or another we are all ignorant of something. I myself am ignorant to the nuances of performing brain surgery. You definitely don't want to trust me to open hour skull! However, having been a commercial pilot for many years, I am not ignorant of the things it would take for me to get you safely and comfortably from point A to point B.

The point is, are you going to distrust a real brain surgeon to operate on you just because he is ignorant of the things it takes to fly from point A to point B? That's what you appear want to do with Jesus. And that because he hadn't been informed of something God didn't tell him. Like I said, he did the absolute best he could with the available information. One thing is for certain, there was nobody else in the crowd who knew .01% of what Jesus knew about the scriptures. Give the guy a break! :)
 

rrobs

Well-Known Member
Answer is in v 16-17. 'Coming of Christ is enlightenment, as with Peter, to whom this information came from the F'ather.
Well, I'm not sure what the question is for which you offer those verses as an answer. They are good verses, that's for sure!

Do they somehow explain why Jesus told those people some would be alive to witness Jesus' second advent as Lord of Lords and King of Kings, i.e. the book Revelation? Two thousand years later we're still waiting. There needs to be some explanation. I'm just not sure how those 2 verses offer such an explanation.
 

leov

Well-Known Member
Well, I'm not sure what the question is for which you offer those verses as an answer. They are good verses, that's for sure!

Do they somehow explain why Jesus told those people some would be alive to witness Jesus' second advent as Lord of Lords and King of Kings, i.e. the book Revelation? Two thousand years later we're still waiting. There needs to be some explanation. I'm just not sure how those 2 verses offer such an explanation.
he told Peter that God opened Peter's eyes that Jesus was Christ, so, Jesus said, will happened to the others. Read the Whole thing, that is one message. Compare with Acts 10:40-41.
 

pearl

Well-Known Member
Cyril of Alexandria, 'We have admired his goodness in that for love of us he has not refused to descend to such a low position as to bear all that belongs to our nature, included in which is ignorance.'
 

MikeDwight

Well-Known Member
I'd like to do everything short of trample over rrobs personal 'faith', whatever that is. Jesus Christ promised that all his followers would never taste death. So extreme is that, that those who wish to keep their life will lose it, and those who lose their life will gain it. Very clearly we are all supposed to be ignorant somehow, that those followers he is talking about successfully woke from their graves and met Jesus Christ.
 

Rational Agnostic

Well-Known Member
Ignorant? He was actually the greatest scripture student who ever lived.

Ignorance is a lack of knowledge. In some arena or another we are all ignorant of something. I myself am ignorant to the nuances of performing brain surgery. You definitely don't want to trust me to open hour skull! However, having been a commercial pilot for many years, I am not ignorant of the things it would take for me to get you safely and comfortably from point A to point B.

The point is, are you going to distrust a real brain surgeon to operate on you just because he is ignorant of the things it takes to fly from point A to point B? That's what you appear want to do with Jesus. And that because he hadn't been informed of something God didn't tell him. Like I said, he did the absolute best he could with the available information. One thing is for certain, there was nobody else in the crowd who knew .01% of what Jesus knew about the scriptures. Give the guy a break! :)

He said (in Matthew 16:28): "I TELL YOU THE TRUTH, some who are standing here will not taste death before they see the Son of Man coming in his kingdom."

Apparently, this wasn't the truth. Of course, in Jesus' defense, we don't know if he actually said this. It could have been the author's own agenda and not the actual words of Jesus.
 

rrobs

Well-Known Member
I'd like to do everything short of trample over rrobs personal 'faith', whatever that is.
All you have to do is ask; I believe the scriptures. I shun tradition (unless it aligns with scriptures, which it mostly does not).
Jesus Christ promised that all his followers would never taste death.
He actually said "some" not "all."
So extreme is that, that those who wish to keep their life will lose it, and those who lose their life will gain it.
While true, I'n not sure how that explains Jesus' statement that some of those to whom he spoke would would live to see his second coming. Are they still somehow alive 2,000 years later (and counting)?
Very clearly we are all supposed to be ignorant somehow, that those followers he is talking about successfully woke from their graves and met Jesus Christ.
Matthew 16:28 says some to whom he was speaking would witness his coming. The resurrections occur AFTER he has come and set up his kingdom. When he actually comes in the clouds, the dead, including those to whom Jesus spoke, will have no consciousness whatsoever (Ecclesiastes 9:5, et.al.).

Satan told Eve that God was wrong about dying. God said, "...thou shalt surely die...", but the devil said, "...thou shalt not surely die..." Only if we believe the devil can understand that those people are not really dead and will witness Jesus' second coming in the clouds. But if we believe God then we must come up with some other explanation.

Do you have any knowledge of the mystery Paul spoke about? Did you take the time to look up the word "mystery" in a concordance as I suggested? I'm going to guess not. It took me months of study and pondering to even begin to understand it and your reply came less than 12 hours after my post. You might give serious consideration to learning about the mystery God gave to Paul to reveal to us. I wouldn't just believe what I say. Nor would I believe what your Pastor says. Sad to say, I've met few Pastors who knew much about it. And yet it is the absolute foundation of our faith as Christians living in this age of grace. It's been in the book for some 2,000 years, so take some time and see what it says for yourself. You won't be disappointed!
 
Last edited:

rrobs

Well-Known Member
He said (in Matthew 16:28): "I TELL YOU THE TRUTH, some who are standing here will not taste death before they see the Son of Man coming in his kingdom."

Apparently, this wasn't the truth. Of course, in Jesus' defense, we don't know if he actually said this. It could have been the author's own agenda and not the actual words of Jesus.
Hello Hubert,

How do you see the Paul's mystery fitting in with Jesus' statement?
 

wellwisher

Well-Known Member
He said (in Matthew 16:28): "I TELL YOU THE TRUTH, some who are standing here will not taste death before they see the Son of Man coming in his kingdom."

Apparently, this wasn't the truth. Of course, in Jesus' defense, we don't know if he actually said this. It could have been the author's own agenda and not the actual words of Jesus.

Actually, John of Revelations did see this come to past, in his vision. He wrote his vision down; Book of Revelations, and this is still used as the template of what to expect.

John who was also called Mark was the apostle that Jesus loved the most. He was the youngest and lived the longest; 80's.
 

Samantha Rinne

Resident Genderfluid Writer/Artist
Speaking of his return to set up the everlasting kingdom on earth, Jesus said,

Matt 16:27-28,

27 For the Son of man shall come in the glory of his Father with his angels; and then he shall reward every man according to his works.

28 Verily I say unto you, There be some standing here, which shall not taste of death, till they see the Son of man coming in his kingdom.​

Many say that the “end times” Jesus spoke of occurred in 70 A.D., when Herod’s temple was destroyed. On the one hand, that would certainly explain Jesus’ statement that some of those to whom he spoke would live to see them. But on the other hand, speaking of the end times, Jesus plainly said that at the end of the day there would not be one stone left on top of another (Matt 24:2). To this day there are some 45 layers of stone piled one atop another. Besides, when has history recorded Jesus coming in glory with his angels? Sorry, it just hasn’t happened. It’ll be hard to miss when it does happen! When Jesus spoke these words in Matthew he was referring to the events that will yet take place as recorded in Revelation.

So how can we explain Jesus’ words that some to whom he personally spoke would live to see his second coming? Do we have 2,000 year old (and counting) people walking this earth today? Of course not! There is a much better explanation: with the information that Jesus had when he was here for the first time, he was absolutely correct in his statement. But there was something about which he knew not.

The only scriptures Jesus had available to learn from were Genesis to Malachi. From those scriptures he understood that God promised Israel an everlasting Kingdom of which he would be the king. He also knew that before his glory he would have to suffer. There are tons of verses that taught him that very thing as he studied them and grew in stature and wisdom.

From the scroll of Daniel, Jesus ascertained that the time between his first coming and his second coming would be 7 years. That is why, to the best of his knowledge, he thought some of those to whom he spoke would be alive when he returned as King of Kings and Lord of Lords.

But Jesus did not know everything about his Father’s plan, the logos of John 1:1. Specifically he knew nothing about the administration in which we are currently living, which began on the day of Pentecost and will end when Jesus gathers us together (1 Thes 4:13) just before his second appearance as King of Kings and Lord of Lords, i.e the Book of Revelation. It is a very unique time that really has no parallels in the Old Testament, including the Gospels. Grace vs. law being perhaps the most notable difference, but there are many others. Jesus came for Israel (Matthew 15:24). That was the mission assigned to him by God. He knew nothing about Christians. The first Christians were not to be seen until the day of Pentecost, some 50 days after Jesus’ resurrection.

A few years after Jesus’ ascension; God gave Paul a revelation which the King James calls “the mystery.” The Greek word (musterion) is better translated as secret. A mystery may never be understood, but a secret, once revealed can easily be understood. Paul speaks of this mystery/secret many times in his Epistles. One only needs to look up the word “mystery” in a concordance.

Paul, by inspiration of God, said that the mystery was kept secret since the beginning of time (Ephesians 3:4-5, et. al.). God was the only one who knew about His complete plan (the logos). 1 Corinthians 2:8 says that the devil would not have crucified Jesus had he known the secret. Why? Part of God’s secret plan was that all born again believers would have Christ dwelling within (Col 1:25-27). Instead of one Jesus for the devil to keep track of, he now has many millions of people filled with the same power and authority Jesus had when he lived. That must have blown the devil’s mind when Paul finally revealed the secret in his Epistles. Of course he can largely mitigate his problem by keeping Christians from a knowledge of the mystery. Judging from a virtually total lack of teaching on the subject in our churches every Sunday, he seems to be doing a pretty good job of it. I’m amazed at how the vast majority of Christians I mention the mystery to stare back at me with an inquisitive look. “The what?,” they often say. And yet, the mystery is “what’s happening” in our day and age.

To get to the point of why Jesus thought some of those to whom he spoke would be around at his second advent, it is simply because Jesus knew nothing about the mystery/secret, God revealed later to the Apostle Paul. From the only scriptures he had at hand (he of course didn’t have Paul’s epistles) , he thought he’d be back in seven years. Of course we now know that this age of grace has lasted at least 2,000 years. How much longer will it last? I have no idea and neither does anybody else.

With the only information available to Jesus, he was spot on right about his statement. I think it is that simple.

Best explanation: Have you ever watched the Big O? They live in a city where nobody can remember anything before 40 years ago. It turns out that it's because there wasn't anything then. Kinda think of God's eternal time as this. Each generation has a sort of final days as their life comes to a close. So time is kinda both sequential and a kinda of life cycle. When Stephen dies, he sees Jesus and his kingdom. But as to history, it appears that this hasn't happened yet. In physics, a glass is said to be at rest on a table and broken on a floor at all possible moments. Already happened, yet to happen, same difference.
 
Top