• Welcome to Religious Forums, a friendly forum to discuss all religions in a friendly surrounding.

    Your voice is missing! You will need to register to get access to the following site features:
    • Reply to discussions and create your own threads.
    • Our modern chat room. No add-ons or extensions required, just login and start chatting!
    • Access to private conversations with other members.

    We hope to see you as a part of our community soon!

When it Comes to Honesty and Ethics, Trust in Clergy is at an All-Time Low

Woberts

The Perfumed Seneschal
Speaking of unreported, I was listening to the radio yesterday on my commute home, and they were grilling the Church over Los Angeles Bishop Alexander Salazar not having been formally added to a public "list" of clergy who have been charged with sexual misconduct.

...But the thing is -he hadn't even been charged, yet he is already presumed guilty. This is insanity.
Sure thing , buddy. :rolleyes:
 

BilliardsBall

Veteran Member
"What profession has the highest rating in terms of honesty and ethics?

Gallup said today that nurses, once again, top their annual list with 84% of people ranking them positively.

Only 37% said the same thing about clergy members. That’s the lowest number religious leaders have received in 34 years of polling.

ec2j8lsovke2ymmkqgtwdg.png
Just look at this glorious fall from grace:

u2u_eqkbl0cwuc80jwlmra.png
source



Objectively, this is a pretty sad state of affairs. These are people who are supposed to be paragons of honesty and ethics, and yet can't hold a candle to high school teachers, police officers, accountants, and funeral directors. AND, their image continues to head toward the basement.

So, what's going on here? Can going from a 67% to a 37% positive rating, a 45% drop in just 33 years, all be laid on the backs of the abusing clergy, or is there more that goes into the mix?

.

Fortunately, trust in non-religious persons, as arbiters of love, justice, morality, wisdom, kindness and charity is at an all-time high. For example, thousands of religious people went to help recent hurricane victims in New Orleans, New York, etc. while millions of atheists descended on these locations to help.

Praise God, for atheists!
 

Ellen Brown

Well-Known Member
It's interesting, as my tag line figures show - we come down
harder upon priests these days (and rightly so) but AT THE
SAME TIME we are SEXUALIZING OUR KIDS, CHILD PORN
is rampant, half our kids COME FROM BUSTED HOMES,
children have NO MORAL COMPASS and our sexy actresses
become YOUNG AND YOUNGER.
In other words, we target the church for being what we are
becoming. This is called Freudian Projection.


I can't disagree with a thing that you've reported. I do think, however that an undetermined part of this group of "failures" are victims, rather than perpetrators. Certain factors in the Mental Health organizations, the Mental Health Drug Companies, and part of the LGBT organizations are culpable in engineering the downfall of many. The Bible supports this premise in multiple places. The best that some can do is wait upon God for mercy.
 

Skwim

Veteran Member
then again, that is all they report... bad press at the expense of the hundred of thousands of good news :) I wonder what the percentage of good vs bad is. ;)

For Catholic clergy it appears to be no better than 24:1.

.
 
Last edited:

sun rise

The world is on fire
Premium Member
Also, I keep hearing that their faith & god give them strength.
I have none of that, yet I manage to avoid being evil (by my standards).
How are all these believers so much worse off?
Like this guy....
Boise priest who lived in ‘world of Satanism and pornography’ sentenced to 25 years in prison
Maybe it's the ability to blame Satan that they use to rationalize getting off the hook, eh?

Rationalization is certainly a mechanism: I want to be a good person but I keep getting tempted and failing. It can't be me. It can't be God. So some evil force is getting in the way.
 

9-10ths_Penguin

1/10 Subway Stalinist
Premium Member
then again, that is all they report... bad press at the expense of the hundred of thousands of good news :) I wonder what the percentage of good vs bad is. ;)

For Catholic clergy it appears to no better than 24:1.

.
IIRC, that Australian inquiry implicated 7% of Australian Catholic priests, which works out to about 1 in 14.

And that's just looking at abuse in general; the number who did other problematic things (e.g. failing to report abuse) is probably several times the number who actually committed the abuse.
 

Kenny

Face to face with my Father
Premium Member
IIRC, that Australian inquiry implicated 7% of Australian Catholic priests, which works out to about 1 in 14.

And that's just looking at abuse in general; the number who did other problematic things (e.g. failing to report abuse) is probably several times the number who actually committed the abuse.
Can't argue with those numbers... it is a shame.
 

Trackdayguy

Speed doesn't kill, it's hitting the wall
Don't you realize it doesn't matter what you, personally, believe? The comment was made specifically about clergy who perpetrate the disgusting sexual acts they are accused of by innocent children, while holding a belief in hell and eternal punishment. Do you honestly believe that the set of clergy who sexually molest children is exclusive from the set of clergy who believe in hell and eternal torment? No overlap? Do you honestly believe that all of the clergy who sexually molest children believe as you do about God? You can believe that God is a happy fluff-ball that is so comfy to hold that once you metaphorically grab hold you never let go. You're within your rights to do so - fine. But what difference should that view of God make when we're talking about clergy taking advantage of their positions?

Also, the "Merry Christmas" following what was obviously a "preachable moment" was a bit much. How can I possibly be expected to resist rolling my eyes, I ask you?

I dont believe in hell....
 

Revoltingest

Pragmatic Libertarian
Premium Member
Rationalization is certainly a mechanism: I want to be a good person but I keep getting tempted and failing. It can't be me. It can't be God. So some evil force is getting in the way.
What a very different way of seeing things.
 

PruePhillip

Well-Known Member
Fortunately, trust in non-religious persons, as arbiters of love, justice, morality, wisdom, kindness and charity is at an all-time high. For example, thousands of religious people went to help recent hurricane victims in New Orleans, New York, etc. while millions of atheists descended on these locations to help.

Praise God, for atheists!

I wasn't aware of this. Is it even true?
If it is then there could be various reasons. One of these is the need
for people to seek meaning, validation and a new moral compass in
their life. That's why many environmentalists are not religious - the
new religion is the environment. Studies show that people tested for
honesty after doing a "good deed" are actually less honest - as if
they feel they have already done their deed.
Also, religion is an intensely private affair - public deeds are corporate
by nature. Our moral are increasingly corporate, tribal and political.
 

PruePhillip

Well-Known Member
I can't disagree with a thing that you've reported. I do think, however that an undetermined part of this group of "failures" are victims, rather than perpetrators. Certain factors in the Mental Health organizations, the Mental Health Drug Companies, and part of the LGBT organizations are culpable in engineering the downfall of many. The Bible supports this premise in multiple places. The best that some can do is wait upon God for mercy.

Wait, what, you don't agree with my premise of falling standards?
Look at my tag line below, taken from a Gallup Poll. It doesn't even
touch upon the burgeoning industry of child porn and related issues.
Do you want me to get figures for these too?
 

URAVIP2ME

Veteran Member
I dont believe in hell....
Seems to me the clergy of Christendom don't believe in hell. So, they have No fear of it.
One person told me she knew someone who entered the Seminary and left.
Left because he was told to forget about the Bible and stick to church teachings (church traditions)
Clergy often teach a religious-myth hell of burning forever as a Bible teaching when it is Not.
Whereas, biblical hell is just mankind's stone-cold temporary grave for the sleeping dead.
So, the days that dead Jesus spent in the 'Bible's hell' he was in an unconscious state - Acts of the Apostles 2:27.
Unconscious state in biblical hell because Jesus taught ' sleep in death ' at John 11:11-14.
Jesus learned that sleeping state for the dead while in biblical hell at Ecclesiastes 9:5.
The dead know nothing, nothing but ' sleep ' as also stated at Psalms 115:17; Psalms 146:4.
If biblical hell was a permanent place then Jesus would still be in hell.
 

URAVIP2ME

Veteran Member
I would be too if I was a Christian, but as we've all read, the bad press is of the church's own doing.
Don't want bad press? Then don't do bad things. Seems pretty obvious to me :shrug:
.

Seems to me spiritual house cleaning does start with the religious House of God as per 1 Peter 4:17.
As a 'new broom sweeps clean ', so to speak, then Jesus as that figurative new broom, will be sweeping out the dirt.
 

URAVIP2ME

Veteran Member
Demon influenced people sometimes fabricate due to the Father of Lies.

I find mankind's ' religious kingdom ' has already fallen (dried up spiritually) due to the influence of devils..... and the nations have become 'drunk', so to speak, because earth's kings/rulers commit a spiritual fornication with 'her' (religious Babylon the Great who thinks she is some sort of a ' religious queen '- Revelation 18:7).
- Revelation 18:1-9
 

URAVIP2ME

Veteran Member
Wait, what, you don't agree with my premise of falling standards?

I find the Bible agrees with your premise of falling standards because many religious people are dried up spiritually.
As the literal waters of ancient Babylon were dried up (Revelation 16:12) so are many religious people dried up today.
Man's religious kingdom sits upon many 'waters' meaning 'peoples' as per Revelation 17:1,15; Isaiah 57:20.
This is why spiritual 'house cleaning' will begin with the religious House of God. Those claiming to follow the Bible.
 

Skwim

Veteran Member
Seems to me spiritual house cleaning does start with the religious House of God as per 1 Peter 4:17.
As a 'new broom sweeps clean ', so to speak, then Jesus as that figurative new broom, will be sweeping out the dirt.
Curious, just when is this sweeping going to start? Millions of people have come and died ostensibly waiting for the sweeping to begin. Seems like a lot of wasted lives to me.

.
 

It Aint Necessarily So

Veteran Member
Premium Member
Can going from a 67% to a 37% positive rating, a 45% drop in just 33 years, all be laid on the backs of the abusing clergy, or is there more that goes into the mix?

The media has to be a factor. Churches and clergy are generally portrayed in a negative light. Even on a show like Law & Order, where a couple of the detectives are good Catholics and good people, most depictions of religious matters are negative.

The 4,392 priests who were accused amount to approximately 4% of the 109,694 priests in active ministry during that time.

These are the fruits of the No Child's Behind Left program.
 
Top