Intro
This comes up as a result of another thread. I am not Jewish and apologize if this mischaracterizes the understanding of Jews or modern ones. It is Christianity I am discussing primarily. I also apologize to fellow Christians for my pointed dislike of the way things are in churches currently. Miracle services are horrendous abuses of Christians that should stop immediately. I will attempt to explain why and to attempt to explain that as Christians continue to pursue understanding of the roots of their religion that they will become increasingly skeptical and embrace Liberal forms of Christianity, and this is the future of Christianity should they continue to do so.
Roots of Judaism to be aware of
(NIV Deut 13:1-3)
"If a prophet, or one who foretells by dreams, appears among you and announces to you a sign or wonder, and if the sign or wonder spoken of takes place, and the prophet says, 'Let us follow other gods' (gods you have not known) 'and let us worship them,' you must not listen to the words of that prophet or dreamer. The LORD your God is testing you to find out whether you love him with all your heart and with all your soul."
An entire culture called Judaism develops around the words of Moses, over centuries. They had centuries to grow into a unique culture that refused to accept miracles as signs that someone was telling the truth. To do otherwise was a sin called 'Divination'. Jews (and also Christians by extension) are not to be swayed by miracles, and so the best way for the gospel writers to let readers know that they are not speaking literally is to say they should listen because of a miracle. It is a literary device through common understanding of the evil of divination. Embrace Deuteronomy as if it were a guide through a creepy cave. Deuteronomy is foundation, not cake. It is milk, not meat; and it says not to be swayed by miracles and this becomes the Jewish way of life. It also applies to the gospels or should be. Because Jesus is Jewish, at that moment where someone in the gospels is asked to believe something because of a miracle, consider it as if the writer has used the term 'like' or 'as'; because believing on the basis of a miracle is not allowed by Moses and by extension not allowed by Jesus as I intend to represent. It is a command infusing skepticism into religious life. (correct me)
Notice in the above passage that Deut 13:1-3 specifically says "gods you have not known." Obviously Moses believes (from this and other passages) it is up to each individual to already know God or they could not test the prophet's words. Hence, miracles are only for teaching and illustrating. One plain meaning is God cannot be revealed through miraculous proofs, and this is part of the culture surrounding Moses words. It is innate knowledge, not something the gospel writers are ignorant of, yet so many Christians today are ignorant of it I think. It is part of Jesus whole life, his synagogues, his un-Roman culture which everyone living in his day is aware of. It is part of their rejection of the gods of all of their conquerors. The gospels count upon their readers to understand miracles are nothing, but they don't expect their words to become scripture to those who refuse to study the law and who don't know basic things like 'Miracles aren't proofs'. So please consider this: "Miracles are nothing." You will be far better off than thinking "Miracles matter." The fact is, they don't matter. They are unnecessary for Christianity, for any of it. Throw them away except for the lessons.
Jesus
Do you remember the story in which Jesus turns water to wine and the writer says "So his disciples put their faith in him?" First of all it is unlawful for the disciples should put their faith in him over a miracle. It is also unlikely for them to go against the Torah that they love. That said, the gospel is not attempting to deceive through describing miracles but is simply teaching something. The miracle is a literary device if we are following Moses instruction.
Snake Handling
Perhaps healing ministry in churches seems innocent to many; but it is extremely bad, warped religion and ranges in how damaging it is. To begin with it is used to shore up belief or is claimed to. It is put forward as Jesus idea which is preposterous! That is a sign that everything is upside down. For an extreme example of the consequences: these days we have snake handling ministers, and this ought not to be. It is only possible because of the extreme ignorance of the ministry and of lay people (sorry if this seems dismissive but I am not saying that they are bad people just ignorant and kept ignorant and this is part of my argument). It should not surprise that snake handling originates with the hillbillies in the USA. Great people, very hard working, but they do not embrace Moses principle of skepticism or Jesus principle of skepticism, either. The gospel writer assumes that we know the Torah, so he assumes that we will understand miracles are meant to teach us something but that signs do not convert, do not convince, do not establish. (I intend to mention Jesus own teachings about this, further down.) How many times have I heard a minister imply that miracles can convince the unbelieving? Many! We ought not to be handling snakes to shore up our beliefs, or looking for comets, or trying to make wine from water.
Signs
...But a minister might argue (ignorantly) "What about the resurrection of the dead? Surely you aren't going to deny that is a sign?" What if I do? I'm only following Jesus own example, and I hope you will do the same and be healed! In his parable a rich man dies and goes to a place of suffering, but a poor man goes to a place of comfort. The rich man wishes to warn his own family but is not permitted, and Jesus ends with this point: If they do not believe Moses and the Prophets, they will not even if someone rises from the dead!
The Skeptical Future of Christianity
(NIV Matthew 12:39)
"He answered, 'A wicked and adulterous generation asks for a sign! But none will be given it except the sign of the prophet Jonah.' "
Jesus not only embraces Jewish skepticism, but it is fair to assume the culture that surrounds him does also from the early apostle to his brother, James, to all of his followers. The more the miracles, the more skeptical we should consider them to be and we ought to be. Ignoring modern pop culture, let us examine the ancient paths. What is the sign of the prophet Jonah? Why, it is the sign you will get if you go following signs, dying of anger only to learn at the very end that you have ignored the compassion, the forgiveness required that is the whole idea all along. Prepare to be swallowed.
Christians today are considered to be 'Conservative' or 'Liberal'. I view them as 'Dying' and 'Renewing'. Expect the future of Christianity to be more informed, more skeptical, more genuine, more biblical.
Aftermath
Torah is reality for Jesus and the gospel writers, and as you move away from that reality disintegrates. A person with no 'Root' is a person with no knowledge of the Law and culture, and so that person will not understand. If you then pay them to preach they will completely miss the message of the gospels and waste your time. They will teach crazy things like that Satan drops out of heaven or that Jesus pre-exists the world. They will hold 'Miracle' services. They will hold exorcisms. In fact that is what they do, today. There are even snake handling services. It is because ignorant people have been paid to teach.
The emphasis upon miracles in the gospels is indication that the writer is making a simile or allusion. Miracles are like those paintings of angels with wings -- symbolic illustrations that mean something. Miracles cannot prove Jesus is a prophet, because that is not how things work. It is ignorance that causes readers to think miracles are descriptions of physical events that create faith in onlookers.
This comes up as a result of another thread. I am not Jewish and apologize if this mischaracterizes the understanding of Jews or modern ones. It is Christianity I am discussing primarily. I also apologize to fellow Christians for my pointed dislike of the way things are in churches currently. Miracle services are horrendous abuses of Christians that should stop immediately. I will attempt to explain why and to attempt to explain that as Christians continue to pursue understanding of the roots of their religion that they will become increasingly skeptical and embrace Liberal forms of Christianity, and this is the future of Christianity should they continue to do so.
Roots of Judaism to be aware of
(NIV Deut 13:1-3)
"If a prophet, or one who foretells by dreams, appears among you and announces to you a sign or wonder, and if the sign or wonder spoken of takes place, and the prophet says, 'Let us follow other gods' (gods you have not known) 'and let us worship them,' you must not listen to the words of that prophet or dreamer. The LORD your God is testing you to find out whether you love him with all your heart and with all your soul."
An entire culture called Judaism develops around the words of Moses, over centuries. They had centuries to grow into a unique culture that refused to accept miracles as signs that someone was telling the truth. To do otherwise was a sin called 'Divination'. Jews (and also Christians by extension) are not to be swayed by miracles, and so the best way for the gospel writers to let readers know that they are not speaking literally is to say they should listen because of a miracle. It is a literary device through common understanding of the evil of divination. Embrace Deuteronomy as if it were a guide through a creepy cave. Deuteronomy is foundation, not cake. It is milk, not meat; and it says not to be swayed by miracles and this becomes the Jewish way of life. It also applies to the gospels or should be. Because Jesus is Jewish, at that moment where someone in the gospels is asked to believe something because of a miracle, consider it as if the writer has used the term 'like' or 'as'; because believing on the basis of a miracle is not allowed by Moses and by extension not allowed by Jesus as I intend to represent. It is a command infusing skepticism into religious life. (correct me)
Notice in the above passage that Deut 13:1-3 specifically says "gods you have not known." Obviously Moses believes (from this and other passages) it is up to each individual to already know God or they could not test the prophet's words. Hence, miracles are only for teaching and illustrating. One plain meaning is God cannot be revealed through miraculous proofs, and this is part of the culture surrounding Moses words. It is innate knowledge, not something the gospel writers are ignorant of, yet so many Christians today are ignorant of it I think. It is part of Jesus whole life, his synagogues, his un-Roman culture which everyone living in his day is aware of. It is part of their rejection of the gods of all of their conquerors. The gospels count upon their readers to understand miracles are nothing, but they don't expect their words to become scripture to those who refuse to study the law and who don't know basic things like 'Miracles aren't proofs'. So please consider this: "Miracles are nothing." You will be far better off than thinking "Miracles matter." The fact is, they don't matter. They are unnecessary for Christianity, for any of it. Throw them away except for the lessons.
Jesus
Do you remember the story in which Jesus turns water to wine and the writer says "So his disciples put their faith in him?" First of all it is unlawful for the disciples should put their faith in him over a miracle. It is also unlikely for them to go against the Torah that they love. That said, the gospel is not attempting to deceive through describing miracles but is simply teaching something. The miracle is a literary device if we are following Moses instruction.
Snake Handling
Perhaps healing ministry in churches seems innocent to many; but it is extremely bad, warped religion and ranges in how damaging it is. To begin with it is used to shore up belief or is claimed to. It is put forward as Jesus idea which is preposterous! That is a sign that everything is upside down. For an extreme example of the consequences: these days we have snake handling ministers, and this ought not to be. It is only possible because of the extreme ignorance of the ministry and of lay people (sorry if this seems dismissive but I am not saying that they are bad people just ignorant and kept ignorant and this is part of my argument). It should not surprise that snake handling originates with the hillbillies in the USA. Great people, very hard working, but they do not embrace Moses principle of skepticism or Jesus principle of skepticism, either. The gospel writer assumes that we know the Torah, so he assumes that we will understand miracles are meant to teach us something but that signs do not convert, do not convince, do not establish. (I intend to mention Jesus own teachings about this, further down.) How many times have I heard a minister imply that miracles can convince the unbelieving? Many! We ought not to be handling snakes to shore up our beliefs, or looking for comets, or trying to make wine from water.
Signs
...But a minister might argue (ignorantly) "What about the resurrection of the dead? Surely you aren't going to deny that is a sign?" What if I do? I'm only following Jesus own example, and I hope you will do the same and be healed! In his parable a rich man dies and goes to a place of suffering, but a poor man goes to a place of comfort. The rich man wishes to warn his own family but is not permitted, and Jesus ends with this point: If they do not believe Moses and the Prophets, they will not even if someone rises from the dead!
The Skeptical Future of Christianity
(NIV Matthew 12:39)
"He answered, 'A wicked and adulterous generation asks for a sign! But none will be given it except the sign of the prophet Jonah.' "
Jesus not only embraces Jewish skepticism, but it is fair to assume the culture that surrounds him does also from the early apostle to his brother, James, to all of his followers. The more the miracles, the more skeptical we should consider them to be and we ought to be. Ignoring modern pop culture, let us examine the ancient paths. What is the sign of the prophet Jonah? Why, it is the sign you will get if you go following signs, dying of anger only to learn at the very end that you have ignored the compassion, the forgiveness required that is the whole idea all along. Prepare to be swallowed.
Christians today are considered to be 'Conservative' or 'Liberal'. I view them as 'Dying' and 'Renewing'. Expect the future of Christianity to be more informed, more skeptical, more genuine, more biblical.
Aftermath
Torah is reality for Jesus and the gospel writers, and as you move away from that reality disintegrates. A person with no 'Root' is a person with no knowledge of the Law and culture, and so that person will not understand. If you then pay them to preach they will completely miss the message of the gospels and waste your time. They will teach crazy things like that Satan drops out of heaven or that Jesus pre-exists the world. They will hold 'Miracle' services. They will hold exorcisms. In fact that is what they do, today. There are even snake handling services. It is because ignorant people have been paid to teach.
The emphasis upon miracles in the gospels is indication that the writer is making a simile or allusion. Miracles are like those paintings of angels with wings -- symbolic illustrations that mean something. Miracles cannot prove Jesus is a prophet, because that is not how things work. It is ignorance that causes readers to think miracles are descriptions of physical events that create faith in onlookers.