It's talking about a battle. It's not saying "go out and kill people who aren't Muslim". Killing non-Muslims makes no sense, anyway, because you're robbing them of a chance to repent.
Last edited:
-
Welcome to Religious Forums, a friendly forum to discuss all religions in a friendly surrounding.
Your voice is missing! You will need to register to get access to the following site features:- Reply to discussions and create your own threads.
- Our modern chat room. No add-ons or extensions required, just login and start chatting!
- Access to private conversations with other members.
We hope to see you as a part of our community soon!
A Challenge for those who believe in a loving God
- Thread starter Rational Agnostic
- Start date
I read what it says, which isn't what you're objecting to.
It speaks to what their god will do to unbelievers.
It's infinitely cruel.
This loving god loves many things, including torture of those who (in my eyes) have done no wrong.
To accept this religion as true is to accept this cruelty.
Food for thought: https://www.quora.com/Are-non-Muslims-going-to-heaven-according-to-Islam
In Islam, those going to hell are usually depicted as the most wicked who have clear proofs of God's religion yet scoff at it, like in the days of Noah. It's more than just "oh, I don't believe". God knows best and He knows all.
Is the translation wrong?
Not that I know of. The Ali translation is probably one of the best English translations but it lacks commentary and is old. You might want to look into getting this, if you really want to delve into the Qur'an: The Study Quran
It rigorously goes into pretty much each verse.
You'll have Muslims who think everyone except them is going to hell and Muslims who think pretty much no one is going to hell. It's a diverse religion, like all others.
The OP is only really applicable to those believing in an omnipotent, omnibenevolent version of God. I've seen the argument made only in relation to some forms of Christianity, to be honest.
I'm aware that there's diversity of belief.
But the translation says what it says.
Is there an objective & verifiable basis to interpret it otherwise?
Jeremiahcp
Well-Known Jerk
God works in mysterious ways.
Yeah, it's called interpretation and theology.
If you don't believe in it, what does it matter?
Jeremiahcp
Well-Known Jerk
The simple and obvious answer is that God's understanding is far beyond that of humans, and for those with faith in God it is simply a matter of trusting that God knows best.
It matters to those of us who consider what religions are all about.
Since this is the Religion & Science forum, we're free to look
at the former from the perspective of methods the latter.
This illuminates how believers will view us, & perhaps deal with us.
Jeremiahcp
Well-Known Jerk
Also you might find this photo a more compelling statement than your bug, people don't care about bugs.
This is 13-year-old Omayra Sanchez who was trapped in debris caused by a mudslide of volcanic ash, which created a concrete like mixture. She remained trapped in that water for three days then died. If you want the details Google it, but it is not a happy read.
This is 13-year-old Omayra Sanchez who was trapped in debris caused by a mudslide of volcanic ash, which created a concrete like mixture. She remained trapped in that water for three days then died. If you want the details Google it, but it is not a happy read.
You just did.
So you judge a religion by a literal reading of a tiny passage in a scripture ignoring the context (a time of war) and ignoring everything else in that scripture and associated (Hadith) that contradicts that one verse such as the verses that say to return evil with good and thus make a friend of your enemy. Or the many Hadith restating the golden rule.
To avoid a certain response, scriptures have passages that I find dark and negative. People find whatever will confirm their prejudices so what people often quote says more about them than about the holy book.
I agree.....the God of the Bible would never do that. (Jeremiah 7:31) Hell is a pagan concept, not a Jewish belief.
Jesus was Jewish, sent to Jews with the Hebrew scriptures.
God gave Israel the choice between life and death....not heaven or hell. (Deuteronomy 30:19-20) He told them to choose life and how to qualify for it. The worst punishment God gives anyone is death.....back to the dust.....gone forever.
The Holy Bottom Burp
Active Member
Meh, the debate about whether caterpillars feel pain aside, I think it was a bit ghoulish of the deity to make it so that one species has to eat another in order to survive. Couldn't he have just made plants super nutritious and tasty? If I was designing a planet full of living beings I don't think I'd make it a rule that one has to eat another in order to survive, it seems unnecessarily brutal. I'm not a vegetarian, but I think god could have made all creatures Vegan, how about some steak flavoured lettuce? He lacks creativity with his thinking...
Oh. Well we believe in an omnipotent "God." Not sure about omnibenevolent. Does that count?
Grandliseur
Well-Known Member
I can see that you really have an open mind on this subject!
As an atheist asked me recently, do you feel better now that you have gotten this off your chest?! It is not as if anything at all I might say would change your mind. In that case, silence is golden.
(I think I could think of many other cases of lack of pity, so to say; I still believe in a loving God. Why do you think I do?)
Last edited: