A Greased Scotsman said:
Actually, given that our species is the one most affected by God's erratic behaviour, we're in the best position to call into question his claims to perfection.
What if God's behavior is not erratic at all...what if man's limited understanding makes it just appear that way? I have studied the Bible for many years and I can tell you that I have not found God's behavior to be "erratic" in the slightest way. We don't have to have a full understanding of how God thinks because his ways and thoughts are often beyond our comprehension, but "erratic" is not something he can ever be guilty of. Human behavior is erratic. God is not human.
He claims to be the ultimate moral authority in existence but can't even stick to his own rules;
He proclaims incest to be bad but starts off the human race by telling a man to breed his genetically identical twin sister. Further, he allows his loyal worshipper Lot to be drugged and gang-raped by his own daughters.
This is pure ignorance talking. Did you ever ask why incest was made part of God's law so much later in man's history? It did not come into force until over 2,500 years after Adam was created.
Initially, there was no such thing as incest because there was no law against it. Abraham and Sarah were half brother and sister. It was Abraham's family line that produced the Messiah. It was not a moral law as much as it was a law to protect from defects in the offspring in later generations.
It was actually in the master plan for humans to "fill the earth" with their kind. That would have been a bit impossible if there was no incest allowed. The reason why the law was introduced later is because genetically, inbreeding causes defects in the offspring. The further away from human perfection we get, the greater the defects become. Pakistani Muslims are reaping a bumper harvest of defective offspring because of their traditional first cousin marriages. The tradition is stronger than common sense. Regardless of the consequences, they still carry it on even outside of Pakistan...as Britain is now experiencing.
He claims omniscience and omnipotence but only ever seems to be upset when people start disobeying him. He becomes angry when a group of desert-dwelling tribes back him into a corner and force him to come down hard on then. Too bad he wasn't all-knowing, otherwise he might have seen all that coming... oh wait;
He proclaims envy to be a sin but confesses that He Himself is a jealous god; if his morality is objective then it applies without question to everything including him. If his morality is objective then jealousy doesn't suddenly stop being a sin because God is the one feeling it. That's a cop-out. He's a 'do as I say, not as I do' god
Shaking my head again.....where do you get these ideas? The word "jealous" when it pertains to the Creator is one of tolerating no other God to rule humanity but him. When humans chose to worship other gods and form their own religions outside of his instructions, they only caused unnecessary pain and suffering for themselves. Jehovah is the Sovereign of the universe and following his instructions brings no grief.
His is a jealousy that is positive, not negative. Walking away from the true God to worship false gods has resulted in some of the bloodiest wars on this planet. Religious hatreds still fester even today....Look at Syria.
Sticking with the true God and obeying him would have spared a lot of lives. Put the blame where it lies....with humans.
He tells the Israelites "Thou shalt not kill" because killing is wrong - then proceeds to egg the Israelites on to genocide entire people so they can settle their lands. And by this point he's racked up a body count of his own too.
On the contrary, he never said "thou shalt not kill" He said "you must not murder". Murder is the unlawful taking of human life. God had the death penalty applied in Israel for capital offenses, so taking life lawfully was something God sanctioned in circumstances that warranted it. He is the Creator so he has full authority over life and death.
He's slaughtered an entire generation of Egyptian children
Pharaoh was given so many opportunities to prevent every one of the plagues that God sent to humiliate Egypt's gods. Pharaoh was considered a god in Egypt, but the true God showed him up for what he was. Pharaoh was to blame for the deaths of Egypt's firstborn along with all his cavalrymen who perished in the Red Sea...what a price to pay for pride and arrogance.
wiped out every life form on the planet (except for two of every species and Noah's family) in the Great Flood because most humans chose not to worship Him (how many 'unborn babies' do you think he killed, by the way?), destroyed entire cities, caused many to die in agony for having the temerity to dare to choose another god over him, inflicted suffering on the Israelites for not sticking to a Covenant their ancestors made but they themselves did not. Do you get the idea?
Again, that is a completely twisted view of what really happened.
Noah was warned about what God was going to do to a world of mankind where the "inclinations of his heart was only bad all the time". The only people God found worthy of life was Noah and his family.
It took decades for them to build this enormous structure, the detailed plans of which were given to Noah to follow explicitly. During the whole period, Noah preached righteousness to that faithless and wicked generation, but not a soul listened to his warning, spurred on by the fact that everyone thought he was a crackpot. What were they thinking when the water started swirling around their feet? Too late to change their minds then. Jesus used this as an example of what will happen again. (Matt 24:37-39)
He claims to be a just god, but places us in a system that - since he's all-knowing - is ultimately predetermined. He'll then proceed to reward or punish us for our predetermined 'choices'
Ah, but he pre-determines nothing...that is why we have free will. He forces no one to serve him or to worship him. He allows us enough rope to either hang ourselves, or to pull ourselves closer to him, by our own choices. The trouble is, as you have demonstrated, too many are willing to blame God for everything but not accept responsibility for their own choices and ignorance. People should learn what an "informed choice" really is. Most are "uninformed by choice".
You claim he's omnipotent - so why doesn't he have the power to be consistent?
He's omnipotent - so why does he feel the need to resort to the most extreme measures when dealing with dissent? Why is it 'murder these, destroy that, riddle them with festering disease'? He's all-powerful! He has literally every less lethal option at his disposal. So why does he so often use the lethal ones? It's unnecessary.
You show an extraordinary lack of knowledge of human nature. God's nation of Israel had his laws and were gifted a land that would have become like a paradise if only they had obeyed their God. His blessing would have guaranteed a wonderful life and a brilliant future...but even though they had God's laws, his presence and his backing, he did not condone their disobedience or hold back punishment for their failure to obey him. He allowed them to experience the consequences of failing to do as he instructed them. He gave them the option of serving him or not and they accepted his terms. He lived up to his end of the bargain...they did not.
deeje said:
His might is never used unless it is to accommodate his will and purpose for this earth and those who inhabit it.
Which leads me to my next point.
What's the point of giving us 'free will' if we aren't allowed to use it in ways God doesn't like?
Free will was never given without limits, so it was never that kind of "freedom" to begin with. It was free enough to get human into trouble though.
If humans had used their free will within the parameters set by the Creator, the outcome would have been vastly different. God isn't stupid. Why would he give us free will if he didn't want us to use it wisely? He set the guidelines so that its exercise would be a blessing to us every day...but the abuse of it turned the blessing into a curse. This is the object lesson....we live in a world where free will is abused every day....do we love it?
Given that the Christian god only does what he wants, doesn't answer to anyone, and dictates morality purely because he's the strongest - I'd say he's the definition of self-centredness. Maybe he could abolish himself?
As the creator of the freedom you enjoy to criticize him, perhaps you might just regret your position when he requires an accounting from you for the way you have lived the life he gave you. It really doesn't make sense to bite the hand that created you...unless of course, you don't want to live anymore?
How is using free will abusing it? Again, what's the point of giving us free will if we're not allowed to use it in ways God doesn't like?
Is it using free will correctly to choose to murder someone? To rape, to steal, to defraud, to ram your car into someone who might have cut you off in traffic? Can you use your free will to run a red light or to drive the wrong way down a freeway? Can to assault someone who looked at you the wrong way or made a remark that offended you? Do you see the stupidity in your question?
deeje said:
and the desire to put one's own will above others just leads to chaos and disaster.
Gott, meet kettle.
Greased Scotsman...meet God, your Creator.
No disaster happens when humans obey the instructions of their Maker. If you break the law there are consequences.....its not God's fault if you disobey him because he tells you what the penalty is before you do a single thing. How stupid not to expect the stated penalty.
Not believing in him, doesn't make him disappear.