• Welcome to Religious Forums, a friendly forum to discuss all religions in a friendly surrounding.

    Your voice is missing! You will need to register to get access to the following site features:
    • Reply to discussions and create your own threads.
    • Our modern chat room. No add-ons or extensions required, just login and start chatting!
    • Access to private conversations with other members.

    We hope to see you as a part of our community soon!

Who's on first?

Tumah

Veteran Member
Bear with me:
Before anything (inb4 atheist retort) there was no other existence except G-d. No time, not space, not even Coca Cola. G-d is everything. There is no concept except G-d. All there is, is G-d.

Now according to Christians, the next step is that we need to create a Jesus.

In order to perform this step, a few things need to exist:
- Time - if we are going to make a change in the current existence, then time will have passed.
- The concept of something that is not what was before - Until now, all there was, was G-d and He was the only concept that existed. Even if the change is within G-d somehow as soon as we can stop using the word G-d or Father, we have created a new concept that didn't exist previously.
- An environment for this new existence - in order for this new entity to exist, it has to have some conceptual room for the possibility of its existence. And don't get me wrong, I'm not talking about physical space. I am saying that two things can't exist simultaneously in the same conceptual space while remaining distinct. Try to imagine a bear that's a cat. Even though your imagination doesn't occupy physical space, an item can either be a bear or a cat.
- Numbers - If there was only one existence and now there are two existences, even if on some level they are really the same thing, the second that we can differentiate between them with regards to some aspect, we have created numbers.

These points are meant to express that Jesus could not have been the first existence to be created who then went and created the world. His existence would inherently either inherently include other existences to be created, -in which he is one of the first - or would require that they pre-exist him.
 

`mud

Just old
Premium Member
I think one is confusing Moses' ramblings from Saul's mumbo.
It's all chowder to me.
~
'mud
 

Tumah

Veteran Member
I think one is confusing Moses' ramblings from Saul's mumbo.
It's all chowder to me.
~
'mud
I was actually wondering what your theological stance was. That's obviously why I made this thread. Thanks for clearing that up for me.
 

2ndpillar

Well-Known Member
Bear with me:
Before anything (inb4 atheist retort) there was no other existence except G-d. No time, not space, not even Coca Cola. G-d is everything. There is no concept except G-d. All there is, is G-d.

Now according to Christians, the next step is that we need to create a Jesus.

In order to perform this step, a few things need to exist:
- Time - if we are going to make a change in the current existence, then time will have passed.
- The concept of something that is not what was before - Until now, all there was, was G-d and He was the only concept that existed. Even if the change is within G-d somehow as soon as we can stop using the word G-d or Father, we have created a new concept that didn't exist previously.
- An environment for this new existence - in order for this new entity to exist, it has to have some conceptual room for the possibility of its existence. And don't get me wrong, I'm not talking about physical space. I am saying that two things can't exist simultaneously in the same conceptual space while remaining distinct. Try to imagine a bear that's a cat. Even though your imagination doesn't occupy physical space, an item can either be a bear or a cat.
- Numbers - If there was only one existence and now there are two existences, even if on some level they are really the same thing, the second that we can differentiate between them with regards to some aspect, we have created numbers.

These points are meant to express that Jesus could not have been the first existence to be created who then went and created the world. His existence would inherently either inherently include other existences to be created, -in which he is one of the first - or would require that they pre-exist him.

Dear Tumah,
If you are going to rely on "Christian" dogma for your starting point, you will have to more specific as to which of the approximate 43,000 different denomination or creeds you are referring to.

If you are interested in what happened at the "beginning", it would better described as in the beginning there was the "Word". The "Word" would refer to the Law and the prophets, for in order to have a physical existence, you would have to have laws regulating that existence, such as the laws of opposites. Without bad, how could you discern good, and without light, how could you discern darkness, and without sweet, how could you discern sour. For every action there is an opposite and equal reaction.

Yeshua was simply the fulfillment of the prophecies of the "Word", in that he was the prophet who was to come, testified to by Moses, who the people were to listen to. His message was in opposition to the false prophet Paul, who is simply a self professed Pharisee and prophet, and accurses anyone who does not listen to his message. As the religion of "Christianity" was basically institutionalize at the Council of Nicaea, which was convened by the Roman emperor, and built around the supposed testimony of the "worthless shepherd", Peter, and the self professed apostle Paul, it would futile to follow such a path with high hopes.
 

Tumah

Veteran Member
Dear Tumah,
If you are going to rely on "Christian" dogma for your starting point, you will have to more specific as to which of the approximate 43,000 different denomination or creeds you are referring to.

If you are interested in what happened at the "beginning", it would better described as in the beginning there was the "Word". The "Word" would refer to the Law and the prophets, for in order to have a physical existence, you would have to have laws regulating that existence, such as the laws of opposites. Without bad, how could you discern good, and without light, how could you discern darkness, and without sweet, how could you discern sour. For every action there is an opposite and equal reaction.

Yeshua was simply the fulfillment of the prophecies of the "Word", in that he was the prophet who was to come, testified to by Moses, who the people were to listen to. His message was in opposition to the false prophet Paul, who is simply a self professed Pharisee and prophet, and accurses anyone who does not listen to his message. As the religion of "Christianity" was basically institutionalize at the Council of Nicaea, which was convened by the Roman emperor, and built around the supposed testimony of the "worthless shepherd", Peter, and the self professed apostle Paul, it would futile to follow such a path with high hopes.
Really, 43,000? Ouch.

Anyway, I was thinking along the lines of John 1. The simple reading of the first chapter seems to indicate that Jesus was this Word.
 

Tumah

Veteran Member
Not necessarily. See, for example, here.

Sorry, the translation you are reading there is basing its position off Jewish lore from Talmudic and Kabbalistic sources. Both of which do refer to creation ex nihilo. You are missing some background information there.

Since Christians don't have access to these sources, we are referring to just a simple rendering of the verse.
 

Yokefellow

Active Member
Before Creation was the Word...

John 1:1
"In the beginning was the Word, and the Word was with God, and the Word was God"

According to Hebrews 11:3, the Word of God (at the Quantum Level) is similar to a programming language...

mhp-0660.png


The Atom would be the Godhead.

Or to put it another way... the Godhead is like God's "Three Dimensional Pixel" that we all interact with...

mhp-0659.png
 

Tumah

Veteran Member
Before Creation was the Word...

John 1:1
"In the beginning was the Word, and the Word was with God, and the Word was God"

According to Hebrews 11:3, the Word of God (at the Quantum Level) is similar to a programming language...

mhp-0660.png


The Atom would be the Godhead.

Or to put it another way... the Godhead is like God's "Three Dimensional Pixel" that we all interact with...

mhp-0659.png
You.... information.
 

Yokefellow

Active Member
Now according to Christians, the next step is that we need to create a Jesus.

At the Sub-Atomic Level, Jesus would represent the Proton.

Why?

Because Jesus is the Word of God.

How does this relate to the Proton?

The Proton is what Scientists use to determine what an Atom is.

1 Word of God = Hydrogen
2 Words of God = Helium
7 Words of God = Nitrogen

...and so on.

mhp-0650.png


Note that at the Atomic Level, Jesus would represent Hydrogen, the Chief Cornerstone of the Periodic Table of Elements...

1 Proton (Son/Word)
1 Electron (Holy Ghost)

;)
 

Tumah

Veteran Member
At the Sub-Atomic Level, Jesus would represent the Proton.

Why?

Because Jesus is the Word of God.

How does this relate to the Proton?

The Proton is what Scientists use to determine what an Atom is.

1 Word of God = Hydrogen
2 Words of God = Helium
7 Words of God = Nitrogen

...and so on.

mhp-0650.png


Note that at the Atomic Level, Jesus would represent Hydrogen, the Chief Cornerstone of the Periodic Table of Elements...

1 Proton (Son/Word)
1 Electron (Holy Ghost)

;)

If my first response to you was somehow unclear, allow me to repeat myself:

You are missing large swaths of information needed to render what you are posting into intelligible concepts for the uninitiated. Especially vis a vis its relation to this thread.
 

The_Evelyonian

Old-School Member
Now according to Christians, the next step is that we need to create a Jesus.

This is where you're going to run into trouble, at least with Christians who believe in the Trinity. See, according to that doctrine, Jesus was never created. He always existed. In the pre-creation, pre-Coca-Cola, state of infinity that you described, Jesus was there, as was the Holy Spirit, as part of the eternal, triune, Godhead.
 

Tumah

Veteran Member
This is where you're going to run into trouble, at least with Christians who believe in the Trinity. See, according to that doctrine, Jesus was never created. He always existed. In the pre-creation, pre-Coca-Cola, state of infinity that you described, Jesus was there, as was the Holy Spirit, as part of the eternal, triune, Godhead.
Well, I don't think the concept of a trinity needs me to discredit. It's doing a fine job by itself. But wasn't there something about him being god's breath? And god birthing him? Something like that?
 

The_Evelyonian

Old-School Member
Well, I don't think the concept of a trinity needs me to discredit. It's doing a fine job by itself. But wasn't there something about him being god's breath? And god birthing him? Something like that?


Not to my knowledge, though I freely admit it has been a long time since I've read a Bible.
 

Yokefellow

Active Member
If my first response to you was somehow unclear, allow me to repeat myself:

You are missing large swaths of information needed to render what you are posting into intelligible concepts for the uninitiated. Especially vis a vis its relation to this thread.

Of course I understood you. So I gave you more info, which of course you ignored.

Can't debate it eh?
 
Top