• Welcome to Religious Forums, a friendly forum to discuss all religions in a friendly surrounding.

    Your voice is missing! You will need to register to get access to the following site features:
    • Reply to discussions and create your own threads.
    • Our modern chat room. No add-ons or extensions required, just login and start chatting!
    • Access to private conversations with other members.

    We hope to see you as a part of our community soon!

Why Only Christians Go To Heaven ?

Dentonz

Member
Mister_T said:
This is irrelivent to the topic.


I could see how this would work for your argument. But you should post the whole thing becausethere is a discrepancy "36Whoever believes in the Son has eternal life, but whoever rejects the Son will not see life, for God's wrath remains on him." First of all there are 2 distictions of life in this passage. Life and eternal life. "Life" could be refering to this lifetime. The scripture does not say "whoever rejects the son will not see eternal life" It just says life. Jesus was a thing of beauty. People who don't accept him are dissapointing God because they are denying themselves the truth about God and missing the whole point of life through Jesus and his teachings. The wrath of God doesn't necessarly mean eternal damnnation because Christians have also felt the wrath of God for their disobedience (David is a good example)

This passage was directed at the Judaizers who where perverting Christs message (Galatians 2:12). They were perverting it by preaching that one must be circumsized to be saved (2:3. 3:2-5. 5:11-12, 6:13-15) Acts(15:1) Included in this perverted gospel was an obligation to keep the whole law perfectly. Galtaians (3:10, 5:2-3) Paul treats this gospel as cursed because no one is justified before God by law. Galatians (3:11)

When Jesus said "No one can come to the father except through me" How do we know that he wasn't describing his act of sacrifice the only way for us to have our relationship restored with God? After all we will all be "coming to the father" when we die to be judged. No one bypasses this. Jesus would defininatley want to discourage people from not believing in him. But no where does he say believe in me or go to hell. Seeing as how Jesus spoke more about hell than anybody, I'm sure he would have used those exact words. Jesus' 2 greatest commands where to love God and love everyone as you love yourself. People can still love God without believing that Jesus was the son of man. They aren't breaking that 1st command.

Okay, I understand what your saying. For the sake of not giving argument any more glory, I've just got one more thing to say. The major problem I have with this, is how some people can take a scripture here and there and conform it to their own happy feelings. If you take the entire message of the Word of God and use it to judge your individual interpretations, it's hard to see how God could possibly allow anyone a portion of glory that hasn't done the things he said to do. God is the same now as he was in the Old testament. However, for the sake of his son's blood; his hand of wrath can not touch us until the judgement because we are under his grace. God's word is just that. He said it, therefore even he has to comply to his word. If he ever said that we are worthy of death due to sin, than we still are. We either have to die to ourselves, repent of our sins and follow Jesus here; or we will die (be separated from God) at the final judgement. The only way for Christ's atonement to cover us is if we are crucified with him. He died for all who would accept him, not for all period. The most famous verse in the Bible John 3:16 plainly says "...whoever believes in him will not perish.." So simple logic says that whoever doesn't believe in him will perish.

If God is Almighty, righteous, just ,and holy, he will not allow his Word to become void or weak. He will carry it out to the last letter. Your interpretation weakens the power in the blood of Jesus if you accept that it is uneeded to see his kingdom. Do not give the devil a foothold by allowing him to water down the Word of God and endanger your soul. If we believe his word is true we should attempt to live by it as completely as possible. Satan will use every means possible to decieve God's people. God gave man his word in the form of the Bible so we would have something to judge our lives by. Also, it judges all doctrine. If it don't say it, don't believe it.
 

Opethian

Active Member
"...whoever believes in him will not perish.." So simple logic says that whoever doesn't believe in him will perish.

Basic high school math contradicts what you said:

If p => q
not q => not p

What you said is:

If p => q
not p => not q

Which is a logical error.

Just so you know that what seems simple logic can be wrong. Of course when seen in the context you could probably make that assumption, but you can only interpret it like that, you can't really deduct it logically.
 

Mister_T

Forum Relic
Premium Member
The major problem I have with this, is how some people can take a scripture here and there and conform it to their own happy feelings.
The same could be said for self righteous motives. And what you call "happy feelings" I call common sense about a loving relationship.

He died for all who would accept him, not for all period

Hold on a second.....I never said that salvation was Universal. I do not believe that everyone goes to Heaven. That doesn't make any sense. I'm just saying that salvation is broader than what a lot of Christians are trying to make it. dorcas3000 has already provided some good passages. Here's another.....

Romans 5:18-19 "18Consequently, just as the result of one trespass was condemnation for all men, so also the result of one act of righteousness was justification that brings life for all men. 19For just as through the disobedience of the one man the many were made sinners, so also through the obedience of the one man the many will be made righteous."

John 3:16 plainly says "...whoever believes in him will not perish.." So simple logic says that whoever doesn't believe in him will perish.
I love double standards. You guys condemn people for their conflicting beliefs through use of simple logic such as the fundementals of love. But when your own beliefs conflict with other parts of the Bible, simple logic is permissable? ....... That passage you picked was correct. Everyone who believes in Jesus will have eternal life(even that is debatable), everyone else faces judgment. But Judgement doesn't mean automatic Hell like you guys are saying it is. It means that there's a risk. You're playing judge. You're condemning people who don't think and believe exactly like you do and that is wrong. The fact is, most of the world DOESN"T think like you guys. You guys put yourself on a pedestool and condemn everyone with conflicting beliefs. That was not the point of Jesus. Jesus was not sent here to condemn the world.

16"For God so loved the world that he gave his one and only Son,[f] that whoever believes in him shall not perish but have eternal life. 17For God did not send his Son into the world to condemn the world, but to save the world through him." As you pointed out Jesus did not say those who don't believe in him will not have eternal life. To assume such a thing is ignorant. If I want to make something clear to people I tell them. If I don't say something, it's pretty self explanitory. "

"He that believeth on him is not condemned: but he that believeth not is condemned already, because he hath not believed in the name of the only begotten Son of God."
Now this could help your argument. He gives the verdict of those condemned.
"And this is the condemnation, that light is come into the world, and men loved darkness rather than light, because their deeds were evil.

20 For every one that doeth evil hateth the light, neither cometh to the light, lest his deeds should be reproved.
21 But he that doeth truth cometh to the light, that his deeds may be made manifest, that they are wrought in God."

Those who love evil more than God and do not repent are the ones condemned. The thing is, Muslims and Jews recognize their evils and repent as well and they deny Jesus as God. So to say that this defines everyone who doesn't believe in Jesus is to say that people who don't believe in him are people who are unrepentent of their sins and choose to live in them rather than live for God. the problem is, Muslims and Jews DO REPENT of their sins, do live for God and are always doing things to try and make themselves better people. Perhaps one can live in Christ and yet not believe in him.

Your interpretation weakens the power in the blood of Jesus
No it doesn't. It weakens the power of religious dogma. It just shows that you're not always right and could be wrong and that there are flaws in your argument. It also shows your lack of humbleness to admidt that there is a chance you could be wrong, judging by your response.

weakens the power in the blood of Jesus if you accept that it is uneeded to see his kingdom
I never said Jesus' blood wasn't needed. Stop putting words in my mouth.

Satan will use every means possible to decieve God's people.
You are not exempt from this.

I'm well aware of what the Devil is capable of. Debating means discussing different opinions. This is a debate forum not a preaching forum. Preaching is not an rebuttal or argument and it is not helping you look any less prideful. Leave it at the door and stick to debating with evidence and facts. If you're going to continue proove yourself right by preaching, perhaps you should not be partaking in this disscusion.
 

dorcas3000

Member
Dentonz said:
Satan will use every means possible to decieve God's people.

IMO, Satan's number one means these days is the church itself. What decieves people away from God? Self-righteousness, false teaching/doctrines, religious hypocrisy, complacency, church splits, arguing over doctines that no one can prove, and judgemental behavior.
 

Mister_T

Forum Relic
Premium Member
dorcas3000 said:
IMO, Satan's number one means these days is the church itself. What decieves people away from God? Self-righteousness, false teaching/doctrines, religious hypocrisy, complacency, church splits, arguing over doctines that no one can prove, and judgemental behavior.

Bingo. Peace and harmony is much better than conflict.
 

Booko

Deviled Hen
Dentonz said:
Please show a scripture that says you don't have to follow Jesus to go to heaven. I would like to discuss this Biblically if you believe the Bible says it. You stated there is 'plenty of other evidence', I just want to see one.
Thanks.

Jesus said, "In my Father's house there are many mansions. I go there to prepare a place for you."

Clearly, Jesus is going to prepare a place 9mansion] for Christians in His Father's house.

The question is, who are the other mansions for?

I wasn't really intending to take any pov on this, but you did ask, so I thought I'd drop in the verse that often comes up in these discussions.
 

bhakthi

Member
“The one who believes in the Son has eternal life, but the one who refuses to believe in the Son will not see life; instead, the wrath of God remains on him. 3:36
 

Mister_T

Forum Relic
Premium Member
bhakthi said:
“The one who believes in the Son has eternal life, but the one who refuses to believe in the Son will not see life; instead, the wrath of God remains on him. 3:36

But as we pointed out wrath doesn't necessarly mean damnation to Hell. David felt God's wrath. The Jews felt God's wrath. Christians today feel God's wrath. The point of the crucifixion was to restore the broken relationship that we had with God. That why the curtain in the temple ripped: To show that there was no longer a barrier between us and God. The sacrifice was made to make people alive to God. This was done out of the grace of God. The Bible states this was a free gift. To say that a person must accept and believe Christ to be the son of God, doesn't make that gift free anymore. You've attatched a requirement to it. It becomes a work. The Bible says works do not get us in to Heaven. God's grace gets us into Heaven. Nothing else. To attatch a work to salvation no longer makes it God's grace, it makes it YOUR work.
 

dorcas3000

Member
bhakthi said:
“The one who believes in the Son has eternal life, but the one who refuses to believe in the Son will not see life; instead, the wrath of God remains on him. 3:36
1) This verse was already discussed, I believe. If not....oops.

2) I have slightly different viewpoint towards it. Notice that while the believer has gained something, the unbeliever has not lost anything. "the wrath of God remains on him." This is the same as John 3:18: "Whoever believes in him is not condemned, but whoever does not believe stands condemned already..."

Neither of these verse can be rationally interpreted to be referring to a future sentence/judgement. The emphasis on both is that what the believer gains, not what is 'inflicted' on the unbeliever.

Yes, God gives believers eternal life, removes our condemnation, etc etc. That is truely a gift and promise from God. I think Christians on the last day will have infinitely more confidence standing before God because of this. The gospel preaches what we gain from fullfilling this new covenant. Jesus is the TRUE way to God (it's guaranteed through faith). It may be the only way, it may not be. But, it is the most stable bridge - it will not fall through. This message is universally TRUE. It is what God truely wills for us and manifests His will. This way leads to life. That's a promise.

Therefore: "I am the way, the truth and the life."

I'm NOT saying that other faiths WILL go to heaven. I'm only saying-it's a possiblity, so we shouldn't run around proclaiming potentially false doctrine.
 

Mister_T

Forum Relic
Premium Member
Jesus is the TRUE way to God (it's guaranteed through faith). It may be the only way, it may not be. But, it is the most stable bridge - it will not fall through. This message is universally TRUE
This is what I believe as well. After studying other religions I could not possibly consider following any other teachings.
I'm NOT saying that other faiths WILL go to heaven. I'm only saying-it's a possiblity, so we shouldn't run around proclaiming potentially false doctrine.
I'm not saying they will either. I don't say that all "Christians" are going either. I don't even say that I'm going. I'm just saying that we don't know and we shouldn't be going around saying that we do and that everyone else is wrong. Just because a person believes something doesn't automatically make him right. Myself included. That's when common sense and reasoning come into play so that we can try to make the best possible conclusion.
 

blueman

God's Warrior
jeffrey said:
I believe God bases the next life you achieve on what is in your heart. Atheists as well as Christians, Muslims, etc, etc will make it to heaven, or what ever the next life is, on who and how you are. I don't believe God is a petty God, demanding if we don't believe in certain aspects, that we won't get to play in the next life. He's above all that, including the being jealous bit.
We are saved through grace and no work of ourselves. We cannot work our way into heaven through deed (Ephesians 2, 8,9), but only through God's grace and acceptance of His Son Jesus Christ, believing in his death and resurrection as the path back to a relationship with God. Without Christ, you cannot have a personal and loving relationship with God nor have everlasting life in heaven.
 

Mister_T

Forum Relic
Premium Member
blueman said:
We are saved through grace and no work of ourselves.
Yes. I agree.
We cannot work our way into heaven through deed (Ephesians 2, 8,9), but only through God's grace
I agree yet again.


and acceptance of His Son Jesus Christ, believing in his death and resurrection as the path back to a relationship with God.
Whoa cowboy! you just contradicted yourself. You just contradicted the essence of grace.Read this to yourself carefully. This is in the Bible: We are saved through grace and no work of ourselves. You just turned God's grace into a work. You said that we HAVE TO ACCEPT JESUS. Having to accept something is a work. If someone gives you something in grace it means that there is no strings attached to it. If you attach a condition to it, then it's no longer grace. It is instead, earned.

Without Christ, you cannot have a personal and loving relationship with God nor have everlasting life in heaven.
I know of Mormons and Jews who have a great relationship with God. You can't tell them that their relationship isn't genuine because of their beliefs. And on top of that, you just passed judgement on people by saying who's going to Heaven and who's not. As if you were certain. The fact is only God can declare who's going to Heaven and who isn't. You don't have God's authority. And just because you feel that your interpretation and views are true, doesn't mean that they are. Nobody can claim to be all knowing about God and they way he works. That is essentially saying that you know as much as him. And that is ludacris.
 

blueman

God's Warrior
Mister_T said:
[/b][/u] Yes. I agree.
I agree yet again.

Whoa cowboy! you just contradicted yourself. You just contradicted the essence of grace.Read this to yourself carefully. This is in the Bible: We are saved through grace and no work of ourselves. You just turned God's grace into a work. You said that we HAVE TO ACCEPT JESUS. Having to accept something is a work. If someone gives you something in grace it means that there is no strings attached to it. If you attach a condition to it, then it's no longer grace. It is instead, earned.

I know of Mormons and Jews who have a great relationship with God. You can't tell them that their relationship isn't genuine because of their beliefs. And on top of that, you just passed judgement on people by saying who's going to Heaven and who's not. As if you were certain. The fact is only God can declare who's going to Heaven and who isn't. You don't have God's authority. And just because you feel that your interpretation and views are true, doesn't mean that they are. Nobody can claim to be all knowing about God and they way he works. That is essentially saying that you know as much as him. And that is ludacris.
Accepting Christ for salvation is not work, it is based on belief and faith regarding His promise of salvation. Thinking that you are able to receive eternal life in heaven based on exhibiting good deeds or being a good person or even going to church is a misconception according to scripture. To reject Christ is to reject God Almighty.
 

nutshell

Well-Known Member
Mister_T said:
[/b][/u] I know of Mormons and Jews who have a great relationship with God. You can't tell them that their relationship isn't genuine because of their beliefs. And on top of that, you just passed judgement on people by saying who's going to Heaven and who's not. As if you were certain. The fact is only God can declare who's going to Heaven and who isn't. You don't have God's authority. And just because you feel that your interpretation and views are true, doesn't mean that they are. Nobody can claim to be all knowing about God and they way he works. That is essentially saying that you know as much as him. And that is ludacris.

I'm both flattered and put down by this post. Are you suggesting that Mormons don't have a personal relationship with Christ?
 

Mister_T

Forum Relic
Premium Member
nutshell said:
I'm both flattered and put down by this post. Are you suggesting that Mormons don't have a personal relationship with Christ?
No sir. Not at all. I was going for something like this:
If others have found a way to connect with God- even if it's not the Christian way- what's wrong with that? Perhaps there are MULTIPLE ways of abolishing this disconnectedness.

People of other religions are sharing the same relationship with God. They experience the same things. This should ring a bell to people who claim that only their way of thinking can give you a 1 on 1 relationship with God. Does that make sense?
 

Mister_T

Forum Relic
Premium Member
Thinking that you are able to receive eternal life in heaven based on exhibiting good deeds or being a good person or even going to church is a misconception according to scripture
I never said that. I said only God decides who makes the cut and who doesn't. You can't earn anything.


Accepting Christ for salvation is not work
Ok. But right after this you said.
it is based on belief
Belief is a verb. Belief is an action. Belief is a work. You're saying that if you don't believe that you go to Hell. If WE HAVE TO BELIEVE, that is saying that we have to earn our salvation with the action of accepting Jesus. When the Bible clearley states that NO MATTER WHAT YOU DO only he can decide if you make the cut. Grace means giving something with no strings attached. Acceptance of Jesus as God is an attached string.
 

EnhancedSpirit

High Priestess
If Christians go to Heaven, it's because that's what they believe will happen. "Heaven" is a spiritual place, not a physical place. It is a state of 'being'.

The Hindu's reach Nirvana

The Jews will go to the promised land

Islam believes in Heaven, and they also believe in Jesus, so by definition, they have the choice of going to Heaven, same as Christians.

What's the difference between what we call this happy place?
 

Mister_T

Forum Relic
Premium Member
What's the difference between what we call this happy place?
There's a difference between what you're sayimg and what other Christains are saying. Other Christians are saying that all of those religions you just mentioned are going to Hell for eternal torment because they believe something different. That is what the debate is about.
 

Mister_T

Forum Relic
Premium Member
EnhancedSpirit said:
If Christians go to Heaven, it's because that's what they believe will happen. "Heaven" is a spiritual place, not a physical place. It is a state of 'being'.

The Hindu's reach Nirvana

The Jews will go to the promised land

Islam believes in Heaven, and they also believe in Jesus, so by definition, they have the choice of going to Heaven, same as Christians.

What's the difference between what we call this happy place?
BTW, I find this concept interesting being it is the first time I heard it.
 

EnhancedSpirit

High Priestess
Mister_T said:
BTW, I find this concept interesting being it is the first time I heard it.

Yes, I tend to stray from the flock when I talk about what God has revealed to me as truth.

All religions have their "Heaven". You might be shocked to know that all religions have a sense of TRINITY as well. And the major religions believe in Jesus' "name" just like he says.

Even though we live with FREEDOM of Religion, there has not been much deviation with the close mindedness of the CHURCH. It's taken many thousands of years, for us to stop thinking with such tiny minds as to think that God in all his Glory could ever fit into one religion.
 
Top