• Welcome to Religious Forums, a friendly forum to discuss all religions in a friendly surrounding.

    Your voice is missing! You will need to register to get access to the following site features:
    • Reply to discussions and create your own threads.
    • Our modern chat room. No add-ons or extensions required, just login and start chatting!
    • Access to private conversations with other members.

    We hope to see you as a part of our community soon!

Danny Ayalon denies the existence of Palestine

CMike

Well-Known Member
i expected that most of you here (i mean our Jews friends) will agree with me that Palestine does exist and Palestinians deserve to return back to their homeland as they were scattered all over the world and that Ayalon is a liar,but instead of that you do agree with him that there is no Palestine.

Anyway thank you Flankerl for your comment.
I agree they deserve to go back to Jordan, their homeland.

Yanno...if their arab "brother's" cared about them why wouldn't they insist that they join them and give them hospitality rather than keep them in "refugee camps"?
 

F0uad

Well-Known Member
Its stupid to see the Jews raging when Palestinian's are just asking for recognizing there land, clearly they did not learn anything about WW2.
 

F0uad

Well-Known Member
I agree they deserve to go back to Jordan, their homeland.

Yanno...if their arab "brother's" cared about them why wouldn't they insist that they join them and give them hospitality rather than keep them in "refugee camps"?
I am pretty sure those Arabs lived in Palestine before you and your European family came to Palestine.
 

LuisDantas

Aura of atheification
Premium Member
What grounds does a people have to a land after being absent from it for literally millenia?

I am not trying to be smart or to diminish the seriousness of the hardships of the Jewish people through its history, but the question still stands.
 

CMike

Well-Known Member
What grounds does a people have to a land after being absent from it for literally millenia?

I am not trying to be smart or to diminish the seriousness of the hardships of the Jewish people through its history, but the question still stands.
The arabs in judea and samaria already have their lands, they are called Jordan and Egypt. If they wish they can home, since their country lost this land due to their aggresive wars to destroy Israel.

The arabs there are now in Israel.

My point is if you wish to play the who had it first game, then Israel wins.
 

LuisDantas

Aura of atheification
Premium Member
The arabs in judea and samaria already have their lands, they are called Jordan and Egypt. If they wish they can home, since their country lost this land due to their aggresive wars to destroy Israel.

The arabs there are now in Israel.

My point is if you wish to play the who had it first game, then Israel wins.

I don't. I question whether the game makes any sense at all instead.

More to the point, I also question whether a millenia-old claim should be taken seriously at all, particularly when the price paid involves the fates and safety of both the claimants themselves and the people they oppose more or less by choice.

And then there is this talk about the lack of existence of an "independent Palestine". Is it supposed to mean anything at all? Even assuming that "independent" countries exist in the first place, that hardly matters. Displacing Palestinians by force of arms is no more legit for that than, say, occupying Florida would be.
 
Last edited:

FearGod

Freedom Of Mind
Since it doesn't exist that's impossible.

It seems to me that Jews were kicked from Europe and i think if the west really loved the Jews then how comes that they found a land for them to be away from Europe.

The jews lived in Europe and other parts of the world for hundred of years and then all in a sudden they transferred to Palestine and their reason for that is that God promised them the land of Palestine.

[youtube]n3bxj1uvDXU[/youtube]
The History of Palestine - YouTube

[youtube]ftgu6nXpn-c[/youtube]
Israeli police brutally beat an American Jew peacefully protesting in Israel - YouTube

[youtube]mfXOKp40b70[/youtube]
Beat by Israeli police [MFV !] - YouTube
 

Flankerl

Well-Known Member
What grounds does a people have to a land after being absent from it for literally millenia?

I am not trying to be smart or to diminish the seriousness of the hardships of the Jewish people through its history, but the question still stands.

Provide a source which proves that the area was entirely free of jews.

Otherwise your argument breaks apart.
 

CMike

Well-Known Member
It seems to me that Jews were kicked from Europe and i think if the west really loved the Jews then how comes that they found a land for them to be away from Europe.

The jews lived in Europe and other parts of the world for hundred of years and then all in a sudden they transferred to Palestine and their reason for that is that God promised them the land of Palestine.

The reason is has been so important to the jews is because none of the european country wanted them.

However, they had their ancestral homeland of Israel, where a jew doesn't have to be afraid to be a jew.
 

CMike

Well-Known Member
Its stupid to see the Jews raging when Palestinian's are just asking for recognizing there land, clearly they did not learn anything about WW2.
Really?

What about the indiscrimnate firing of rockets into Israeli cities, and all the terrorist attacks against civilans?

You think that may have something to do with it too?

Oh yeah...and they have sworn to completely destroy Israel and kill all the jews may have something to do with it too.
 

Juhurka

Member
I am pretty sure those Arabs lived in Palestine before you and your European family came to Palestine.

Read my words carefully, it is not your or any other arabs business what we Jews do on our land, we do not stick our nose in to your business so stay out of ours.
 
Top