-
Welcome to Religious Forums, a friendly forum to discuss all religions in a friendly surrounding.
Your voice is missing! You will need to register to get access to the following site features:- Reply to discussions and create your own threads.
- Our modern chat room. No add-ons or extensions required, just login and start chatting!
- Access to private conversations with other members.
We hope to see you as a part of our community soon!
Has everything been predestined since the dawn of time?
- Thread starter gseeker
- Start date
Hmm, sounds familiar!Well, we are free to make mistakes if nothing else. I once watched a video of a girl who went to grab a container of syrup and instead she mistakenly grabbed the container of coffee, which she poured on her pancakes. Mistakes are one of our greatest freedoms, not to mention a great source of amusement.
Shuddhasattva
Well-Known Member
Incomplete self-description.
You dont understand conscious processes enough so far as to even be certain a tornado has no consciousness
Exactly. I'm not; rather I suspect that tornadoes do have a certain elemental sort of consciousness born of continuity in physical patterns and information processing/transference, and it's this trend towards continuity in information processing that, in greater or lesser degree, gives rise to self-awareness from more ambient awareness.
PolyHedral
Superabacus Mystic
What does that mean? How does it fit into existing models?
Shuddhasattva
Well-Known Member
Does realizing how quantum mechanics works cause one to be able to advantage oneself of its workings?
Take the answer of this statement and fit it into 'incomplete self-description.' What exactly are we doing in attempting to map out reality?
We're engaged in describing ourselves and reality vis-a-vis neuroscience and quantum mechanics.
Forward or backwards, if understanding how something is affecting us - as deep on a causal level as quantum mechanics, causes us to be able to develop methods or technologies to select for subjectively better outcomes, we're capable of semantically meaningful choice.
Mentally, I would propose that we're scripted in layers; our deepest levels are most scripted and unaware; the more self-aware we are, the less we're moved by scripted impetus. Hence, for example, the practice of mindfulness.
PolyHedral
Superabacus Mystic
At the level of quantum mechanics, we cannot make choices, because there is no us - there is only an evolving wavefunction, of which a brain is an arbitrary subset. (That may not even be disentangleable from the whole WF.)
Sir Doom
Cooler than most of you
As much as my environment and my upbringing (which is really environment as well, imo) are a determining factor on who I am and the choices I make, who I am and the choices I make are a factor on my environment as well. Thus, our choices have a lasting effect on reality as much as reality has a lasting effect on us. Even better is the intentional nature of this process by us (and all other life as far as I can tell) and not by the universe itself that we can tell. We plan for reality to be a certain way in the future and we take steps to make sure that it happens. Sometimes succeed, sometimes fail, and sometimes anything in between the two. Its really always between the two if you think about it, but that's probably another topic.
Anyway, I think that sort of qualifies as free will. We intentionally determine the future of reality and it totally works (a little bit, sometimes)!!!
Anyway, I think that sort of qualifies as free will. We intentionally determine the future of reality and it totally works (a little bit, sometimes)!!!
Here's what I think.....(and I'm a westerner who took on an eastern (Indian) prospective)
God (Brahman) is the only thing real. Like our dreams at night which we believe are real while they're happenning become unreal when we wake up. In the same vein our waking state is unreal when we awaken to higher spiritual states of consciousness (but we believe the waking state is real while we're in that state). Ultimately we find we are the only ONE consciousness (God) and that is the only reality. This is all a dream/thought-form of God.
　
In the final end free-will (like everything in the great drama/play)is illusory. But relative to us, the temporary characters in the play, we have free-will.
Relative to us in addition to heredity and environment influencing us there are also spiritual levels in us that effect our paths in life.
God (Brahman) is the only thing real. Like our dreams at night which we believe are real while they're happenning become unreal when we wake up. In the same vein our waking state is unreal when we awaken to higher spiritual states of consciousness (but we believe the waking state is real while we're in that state). Ultimately we find we are the only ONE consciousness (God) and that is the only reality. This is all a dream/thought-form of God.
　
In the final end free-will (like everything in the great drama/play)is illusory. But relative to us, the temporary characters in the play, we have free-will.
Relative to us in addition to heredity and environment influencing us there are also spiritual levels in us that effect our paths in life.
gseeker
conflicted constantly
By environment I meant location on the face of the earth. I believe that if you could program all variables into a computer powerful enough to process it you could see the future completely. That would mean that the future is already set in stone, life itself is nothing except a massive mathematical equation, the future is just the process of figuring the equation. That means no free will.
Shuddhasattva
Well-Known Member
That computer might look something awfully like... oh, hey - the universe. And it has one hell of an RNG.
I used to have that opinion but I've changed.
Spiritual factors (super-physical/spiritual phenomena) exist and they cannot be programmed into or be predicted by your computer. The universe is more complex than we think.
By definition, what is in the future is what doesn't exist yet, and what has past does not now exist. So yes, the past exists exactly as much as the future.The future exists exactly as much as the past exists - our maps of both are inferred from evidence. The territories, however, are more complicated.
However, our picture of the past, of the actual, is a bit more reliable, and a bit more relied upon.
Skwim
Veteran Member
Exactly. As mentioned, freewill is an illusion. Things happen because they are either determined, occur at random, or are a combination of the two.
outhouse
Atheistically
Sir Doom
Cooler than most of you
Computers can't actually play chess. That would be like saying the chess pieces can play chess.
PolyHedral
Superabacus Mystic
Computers can play chess better than we can - at least, to say otherwise would be a form of dualism.
Sir Doom
Cooler than most of you
Not really. Every time a computer 'plays' chess, it's really a human doing it. Either a human is playing another human and the computer is little more than the chess board, or a computer is playing a computer, in which case its a complex animation created by a human to look like chess, or it's a human playing a computer which is really a human playing chess by themselves.