• Welcome to Religious Forums, a friendly forum to discuss all religions in a friendly surrounding.

    Your voice is missing! You will need to register to get access to the following site features:
    • Reply to discussions and create your own threads.
    • Our modern chat room. No add-ons or extensions required, just login and start chatting!
    • Access to private conversations with other members.

    We hope to see you as a part of our community soon!

The one true religion

Godwilling

Organic, kinetic learner
I am a fairly staunch Jew. And I don't consider all other religions as false. I just consider them to be for the religious and spiritual needs of non-Jews.

I think that God is Infinite, and has infinite aspects. I think that God speaks to different peoples in different voices, and demands different things of them. Judaism is the way of the Jews, and we are bound to our covenant with God, and may not follow others. But there's no reason to think that God can't or doesn't have other covenants with other peoples, and that other religions aren't perfectly viable and acceptable relationships between God and other peoples.
You must have invented your own brand of Judaism because the Judaism of the Torah clearly states that there is one true god and that it is the god of the Jews. It also describes in detail the horrible punishments that those worshiping any god other than the God of Abraham will suffer.
 

Godwilling

Organic, kinetic learner
It's not a "hypothesis." It's a religious belief. But just to clarify:

1. I don't believe salvation to be contingent upon "getting all of the answers on the test right."
2. I don't believe that our mortal lives mark "The End" of our opportunities to learn, grow, and make decisions.
3. I believe that living life in accordance we what one sincerely believes to be right is very important to God.
4. I don't believe that salvation is a "one-size-fits-all" kind of thing.

I don't see how it implies that at all. I never said anything to that affect.

Well, we can't all be right, can we? If I believe He is one thing and someone else believes Him to be quite the opposite, either one of us is right or neither of us is right, but we both can't be.

While we're on the subject of what humans conceive, how do you know I'm anything at all like you think I am? You seem to have made a number of assumptions about me, based solely upon the fact that I am a theist, and possibly upon the fact that I am a Christian and a Mormon. You're probably wrong about most of them.
Actually, my only assumption about you is that I know nothing about you but what you say.

Your statement that, "either one of us if right or neither of us is right, but we both can't be" proves my original point. That is exactly what I stated at the begining of this thread.
 

Godwilling

Organic, kinetic learner
Carbon.

The one true religion. See how simple that was? Nothing to argue... nothing to debate... if you're not carbon; you're not.

Which is a clear illustration. "One" + "true" + "religion" = debate.
To say that we are carbon is like saying that carrots are vitamin A. You cannot make a human being from carbon any more than you can make a carrot from vitamin A. To make a human being you need a female human (a universe to herself) and a male human (a universe to himself) both with well functioning reproductive systems. To make a carrot you need to plant one from seed or a piece of carrot containing root sprouts.

Also carbon itself is not just carbon. There are many types of carbon and carbon in any form is much more complex than many scientists believe. What is the ratio of "dark matter" in carbon? Clearly there are many possible debates about carbon.
 

Godwilling

Organic, kinetic learner
My father was Jewish. A few years back, he "found Jesus" and became a Pentacostal Christian. He says he has a personal relationship with God and talks to him. It has really made him a better person- all the anger issues he had have disappeared, and though I know his beliefs aren't for me, I'm happy for him.

My girlfriend was raised Christian, but felt it wasn't right for her. She had a strong experience with spiritual possession, and now is following a Druidic kind of path. She has become more confident and assertive as a result.

These might both be psychotic delusions, or hallucinations, or contact with the one God (Judeo-Christian), or the Goddess, or a transcendent power that shares all names, or an alien telepath. But what CAN'T be denied is this: those experiences had a profound life-changing impact on those two people. Can I say that one is wrong while the other is right?

We can discuss and debate what might have happened in the mental or spiritual realms. What can NOT be argued is that these events created a positive change in the physical world! Whatever the belief, "Believing is being." It's the changes created in the world that make a thing true. If you have a spiritual experience and you act on it, what matters more: where it came from, or how you act on it?

I think what's true are the things we make real based on what we believe. If we act positively on a belief, we have made things better, and I can't fault that belief just because it doesn't inspire me the same way.
Your tolerance and understanding of the beliefs of others is commendable.
 

Godwilling

Organic, kinetic learner
hi
do you beleive that guestion has answer before 1432 years in "holy quran" and you can check if you looking for true
Sounds like you are quite convinced. Please let us know the part of the "holy quran" that we should check and perhaps we will become convinced as well.
 

Zardoz

Wonderful Wizard
Premium Member
You must have invented your own brand of Judaism because the Judaism of the Torah clearly states that there is one true god and that it is the god of the Jews. It also describes in detail the horrible punishments that those worshiping any god other than the God of Abraham will suffer.
Levite knows what he's talking about. The " horrible punishments" only applies to Jews. It's only us Jews who can't worship any other god. For example, a triune godhead like the Christian trinity is just fine for Non-Jews, but is prohibited to Jews. Non-Jews are only prohibited from worshiping idols.
 

Wombat

Active Member
Please let me know who will decide the gods that should be shattered to pieces.

God.....in Her own good time ;)


Lk. 6.43, 44

Beware of false prophets, which come to you in sheep's clothing, but inwardly they are ravening wolves.

Ye shall know them by their fruits. Do men gather grapes of thorns, or figs of thistles?

Even so every good tree bringeth forth good fruit; but a corrupt tree bringeth forth evil fruit.

A good tree cannot bring forth evil fruit, neither can a corrupt tree bring forth good fruit.

Every tree that bringeth not forth good fruit is hewn down, and cast into the fire.

Wherefore by their fruits ye shall know them.



The promice here is that the fruitless trees of “false prophets” will be “hewn down, and cast into the fire”.
And so it has been throughout history-
List of thousands of dead gods
http://www.graveyardofthegods.org/deadgods/listofgods.html

Thousands of fruitless dead religion trees hewn down and cast into the fire.
If the religion lives and “bringeth forth good fruit” it is a “true” religion.
Should it be decided by Wahabis, Davidian Mormons, the Opus Dei, or Jehova's Witnesses, or would it be better decided by Bahais

When Chiang Kai-Shek was asked about the impact of the French Revolution he responded that it was “Too early to tell”.
Each of those you mention- “Wahabis, Davidian Mormons, the Opus Dei, or Jehova's Witnesses, Bahais” are sects within or schisms of a major faith, only the latter, Baha’i, is an independent religion.
Will any of them get to “decide” anything in relation to what gets “shattered” and what survives?
It’s “Too early to tell”.
 

Godwilling

Organic, kinetic learner
Levite knows what he's talking about. The " horrible punishments" only applies to Jews. It's only us Jews who can't worship any other god. For example, a triune godhead like the Christian trinity is just fine for Non-Jews, but is prohibited to Jews. Non-Jews are only prohibited from worshiping idols.
Does it mean God likes Jews more, or that God likes them less?
Does it mean that God has higher standards for Jews, or that God wants to make it harder for them for some other reason?
 

Godwilling

Organic, kinetic learner
God.....in Her own good time ;)


Lk. 6.43, 44

Beware of false prophets, which come to you in sheep's clothing, but inwardly they are ravening wolves.

Ye shall know them by their fruits. Do men gather grapes of thorns, or figs of thistles?

Even so every good tree bringeth forth good fruit; but a corrupt tree bringeth forth evil fruit.

A good tree cannot bring forth evil fruit, neither can a corrupt tree bring forth good fruit.

Every tree that bringeth not forth good fruit is hewn down, and cast into the fire.

Wherefore by their fruits ye shall know them.



The promice here is that the fruitless trees of “false prophets” will be “hewn down, and cast into the fire”.
And so it has been throughout history-
List of thousands of dead gods
http://www.graveyardofthegods.org/deadgods/listofgods.html

Thousands of fruitless dead religion trees hewn down and cast into the fire.
If the religion lives and “bringeth forth good fruit” it is a “true” religion.


When Chiang Kai-Shek was asked about the impact of the French Revolution he responded that it was “Too early to tell”.
Each of those you mention- “Wahabis, Davidian Mormons, the Opus Dei, or Jehova's Witnesses, Bahais” are sects within or schisms of a major faith, only the latter, Baha’i, is an independent religion.
Will any of them get to “decide” anything in relation to what gets “shattered” and what survives?
It’s “Too early to tell”.
Is it too early to tell whether, or not, you are correct?
 

Hawkins

Well-Known Member
Even the most staunch believers have "one true religion" and denounce all other religions as false.
That amounts to everyone being atheist to all religions but their own. If we ask people their opinion on all religions and calculate a mean (in colloquial terms people call the mean, "average"), our calculations would reveal that the majority would find all religions as false.

Are there people that believe in all religions, or most religions, or are all religions, or most, mutually exclusive? Or is there a one true religion, and which is it?

All religions have dogmas and rules/laws for people to obey. All other religions are impractical because few people can obey those dogmas/rules/laws set forth for them.

Christianity says that all you need to do is to believe in Jesus Christ. This is as practical as that 1/3 of human beings in the history of humanity just DID.
 

blackout

Violet.
I suppose in theory, each religion is at least true unto itself. ?

In practice, each religion is true unto each individual practitioner "realizing" it.
(according to their Own understanding and design)
 
Last edited:

blackout

Violet.
Levite knows what he's talking about. The " horrible punishments" only applies to Jews. It's only us Jews who can't worship any other god. For example, a triune godhead like the Christian trinity is just fine for Non-Jews, but is prohibited to Jews. Non-Jews are only prohibited from worshiping idols.

I see that this principle applies all around.

(beyond the laws of the land)
People are subject to (the manifestations of)
their own "agreements"/statutes/ways/methods/limitations/
cans/can'ts/will's/won'ts/should's/shouldn'ts/punishments
prohibitions/dogmas/doctrines/whatevers,
not those of others.

If I don't up'hold some philosophy, religion, outlook or belief system,
then it has no hold on me.
(beyond the possible infringment of others, inserting--forcing themselves--or their ways,
unwanted, into the sphere of my own life. In opposition to my will.)
 
Last edited:

Guitar's Cry

Disciple of Pan
Even the most staunch believers have "one true religion" and denounce all other religions as false.
That amounts to everyone being atheist to all religions but their own. If we ask people their opinion on all religions and calculate a mean (in colloquial terms people call the mean, "average"), our calculations would reveal that the majority would find all religions as false.

Are there people that believe in all religions, or most religions, or are all religions, or most, mutually exclusive? Or is there a one true religion, and which is it?

I believe in what "exists," and all religions "exist."
 

Civil Shephard

Active Member
Even the most staunch believers have "one true religion" and denounce all other religions as false.
That amounts to everyone being atheist to all religions but their own. If we ask people their opinion on all religions and calculate a mean (in colloquial terms people call the mean, "average"), our calculations would reveal that the majority would find all religions as false.

Are there people that believe in all religions, or most religions, or are all religions, or most, mutually exclusive? Or is there a one true religion, and which is it?

Well... truth is we really don't know do we? I didn't come to faith in Christ because of religion... after reading and re-reading the New Testament and the Old I began to see a pattern of denial in myself and in my fellow Christians. We... Don't... Know...

But when we Christians get together and pray and read the bible and sing a song and testify a little we know that we know that we know... some of us mess up a bit and start to think that means we've cornered the market on the truth and since we're so spiritual then we know everything... that we have insight into all things as Paul said. So instead of referencing the owners manual thoroughly we go off hafe cocked with a bible and a mission and start messing with peoples heads.

Oh well... I've had to beat up on a few of those types only to see them years later and be jealous of their outright devotion to God. Some got more heart than head... and they're not usually here in these forums but some with head and heart are. To me... the true religion is that of head and/or heart... if you're honest about what you know and what you don't know about God. I know God is Love clearly defined in Christ Teachings... and like an awareness of being I AM pulled me out of the nothingness of entropy. But I don't know a whole lot more than I know...
 
Top