Welcome to Religious Forums, a friendly forum to discuss all religions in a friendly surrounding.
Your voice is missing! You will need to register to get access to the following site features:We hope to see you as a part of our community soon!
That depends entirely on your soteriology. As an Orthodox Christian (as in a member of the Eastern Orthodox Church) mine is not entirely dependent on the Crucifixion, but rather on the entire Incarnation. Only in western churches do you get the emphasis on the Crucifixion alone as the means of our salvation. For us, Christ need not have been betrayed by Judas and would still have succeeded in saving us - the Resurrection is more important than the Crucifixion.orichalcum said:Yes, but my point is if Judas had not betrayed him, he would not have been crucified. Jesus knew he had to be killed.
I'm no expert but I don't believe it would have been the same since Christ was the sacrifice for our sins. If he had just died of old age, then it would not have been a sacrifice.orichalcum said:So what your saying is that Jesus would have lived a full life, died and had the ressurection still take place?
Thats a view I have not heard of before, but interesting if true.
I would have phrased orichalcum's phrase using 'could' rather than 'would', but yes. Your idea of Christ being the sacrifice for our sins was exactly what I was talking about when I spoke of western soteriology being different to eastern. We see Christ's sacrifice as being self-sacrifice. As He was Immortal by nature, dying in any way at all would be self-sacrifice, so the manner of His death is not necessary to it's sacrificial nature - at least not in my opinion. We do not believe that God sacrificed Christ as the only suitable substitute for mankind's punishment. That juridical, western concept is pretty repugnant to us. Note that self-sacrifice need not be to something/someone, only for somebody - in this case for all mankind.Melody said:I'm no expert but I don't believe it would have been the same since Christ was the sacrifice for our sins. If he had just died of old age, then it would not have been a sacrifice.
p1 Jesus is predestined for death and Judas is part of the plan by announcing JesusIacobPersul said:I think you're confusing foreknowledge with pre-destination. Most Christians (Calvinists excepted) believe in free will and that God will not oppose our use of it. Just because Christ knew Judas was going to betray Him doesn't mean that Judas didn't do so willfully. Christ (being God) allowed Judas to betray Him but didn't force Him to, so the fault rests entirely with Judas.
James
How do you know that God condemned Judas?robtex said:p5 God condems Judas for his actions.
orichalcum said:Yes, but my point is if Judas had not betrayed him, he would not have been crucified. Jesus knew he had to be killed.
I think Judas was playing his part (if one buys the story at all). I've always wondered if he really was a bad guy.linwood said:I think Judas was playing his part and that part was being the bad guy.
Sounds good to me Rich.retrorich said:How come Judas has such a bad reputation? I'm not sure, but I think it had something to do with a cock crowing, a same-sex kiss and thirty pieces of silver.
Quite a few bible scholars believe that this line was actually a reference to a psalm. (I don't know the number off the top of my head, but look around and you'll be sure to find it)linwood said:"Father, father, why have you forsaken me?"
Psalm 22Khale said:Quite a few bible scholars believe that this line was actually a reference to a psalm. (I don't know the number off the top of my head, but look around and you'll be sure to find it)
Sorry I took a long time to get back to you. Judas is revealed to all as the traitor in John chapter 18.lilithu said:How do you know that God condemned Judas?
(This is, btw, one of the first questions that I asked my religion teacher as a kid.)
All four gospels call Judas a traitor. I am more interested in whether God actually condemned Judas.robtex said:Sorry I took a long time to get back to you. Judas is revealed to all as the traitor in John chapter 18.
Interesting! If you go back a little further in the text it says:robtex said:In Acts 1:18 I qoute from Biblegateway.com NIV version: " With the reward he got for his wickedness Judas bought a field. There he fell headlong his body burst open and all his intestines spilled out.
What I gathered from this is that ones body does not burst open naturally from falling from a standing position to flat ground. Those words imply divine intervention.