• Welcome to Religious Forums, a friendly forum to discuss all religions in a friendly surrounding.

    Your voice is missing! You will need to register to get access to the following site features:
    • Reply to discussions and create your own threads.
    • Our modern chat room. No add-ons or extensions required, just login and start chatting!
    • Access to private conversations with other members.

    We hope to see you as a part of our community soon!

Has 'The Doc' Got A Point?

Yerda

Veteran Member
In another thread NetDoc said:

True belief in a creator is ANYTHING but lazy. Indicating such is truly condescending for those of us who expend a TON of energy in the following of our faith. Creationists are constanly villified by many of those who purport to be a part of the current intelligencia. We are often depicted as lazy, stupid, insecure, full of nonsense, intellectually dishonest, etc. etc.

Rather than seeing the bias continue, I thought I would attempt to set the record straight, and perhaps shed some light on just how this intellectual bigotry is seen by those of us on the receiving end.


Although I feel this was a complete misunderstanding of my own post, I am curious to hear if others share these feelings.

Do you spend large amounts of energy following your faith?

Do you feel intellectual bigotry is rife amongst the current intelligencia? (Whatever the hell that is).

Does this bigotry pervade even RF?

My own conviction is that God is an extremely sluggish explanation for...anything.
 

painted wolf

Grey Muzzle
God is only a sluggish expanation if you let it rest at that.
If you never bother to look into things and just slap the 'god did it' label on everything that is lazy.
You can have faith in 'god' and be intellectually curious IMHO.

My faith demands lots of energy on my part as it is part of the whole of my life. I expend a lot of energy in living life, so naturally a lot in my faith. ;)

As for bigotry... perhaps some small bias on the part of some. Those who assume that people of faith are using god as an excuse not to think. (not that some don't but certenly not all)

wa:do
 

lilithu

The Devil's Advocate
Why is this thread in science vs religion debate? I will answer your questions, but I have no intention of getting into a debate over my own views and observations.

truthseekingsoul said:
Do you spend large amounts of energy following your faith?
YES!! To truely believe in God is to live a godly life. (Which is not to say that people who don't believe live "ungodly" lives.) Afterall,if you don't truly live your beliefs, how does anyone (including yourself) know that the truly believe them?

God for me is not some father-figure up in the sky who's going to give me things when I ask, and "save" me just because I happen to believe some thing. As a UU, I believe that there is a divine spark in each of us, that can either be nurtured to grow or diminished with neglect. "Judgement" is not just on the "last" day, it's everyday. Everyday I hold myself accountable to God and to myself as to whether I nurtured my own spark of divinity and those of others. (And I have to say I usually fall short.) Whether it's meditation/reflection for myself or volunteering in the community or just plain being nice to someone else, that's all rooted in my faith (for me).



truthseekingsoul said:
Do you feel intellectual bigotry is rife amongst the current intelligencia? (Whatever the hell that is).
Rife? I don't know. Is there a significant amount of it? Yes. And I'm saying that as a member of the "current intelligentsia" (by which I assume NetDoc means over-educated academicians and their sympathizers). There is a tendency to assume that if someone believes in God it's because we don't know any better. Because we're uneducated. Or because we haven't questioned what we were taught. Or because we can't deal with uncertainty. Or because we want the easy way out. :rolleyes:


truthseekingsoul said:
Does this bigotry pervade even RF?
Have I seen it? Yes. Does it pervade? No. In general, I find the members of RF to be refreshingly openminded. And of those who are less so, there seem to be equal numbers all around.


truthseekingsoul said:
My own conviction is that God is an extremely sluggish explanation for...anything.
It can be. That doesn't mean that it is for everyone. Nor does it mean that those who reject the concept of God are necessarily using more brain cells. It really doesn't take that much more thought to reject something than to accept it. It's what comes after that that's important.

But God for me is not an "explanation." The idea that God created the universe is rather incidental to my daily life. Much more important is God as the ideal towards which I strive, a relationship for which I work to cultivate. For me, to say that "I believe in God" isn't just saying that I believe that God exists, the way that a toaster exists. Who cares? When I say "I believe in God" I mean it like I believe in truth, love, beauty, justice... I mean it like when I say to someone I love "I believe in you."
 

Jayhawker Soule

-- untitled --
Premium Member
truthseekingsoul said:
My own conviction is that God is an extremely sluggish explanation for...anything.
"Sluggish" is, in my opinion, too polite a term, but clearly NetDoc is correct when asserting that "true belief in a creator is ANYTHING but lazy" - although reference to 'true belief' invites the 'no true Scottsman' fallacy. The fact remains that "true belief in a creator" can easily mandate the most strenuous mental gymnastics to deal with the Problem of Evil. Blaming the victim while defending a malicious, petty, and vindictive Diety as omniscient and omnibenevolent, all while trying to appear 'Christian' and loving, is hardly a task for the lazy.
 

michel

Administrator Emeritus
Staff member
truthseekingsoul said:
In another thread NetDoc said:

True belief in a creator is ANYTHING but lazy. Indicating such is truly condescending for those of us who expend a TON of energy in the following of our faith. Creationists are constanly villified by many of those who purport to be a part of the current intelligencia. We are often depicted as lazy, stupid, insecure, full of nonsense, intellectually dishonest, etc. etc.

Rather than seeing the bias continue, I thought I would attempt to set the record straight, and perhaps shed some light on just how this intellectual bigotry is seen by those of us on the receiving end.


Although I feel this was a complete misunderstanding of my own post, I am curious to hear if others share these feelings.

Do you spend large amounts of energy following your faith?

Do you feel intellectual bigotry is rife amongst the current intelligencia? (Whatever the hell that is).

Does this bigotry pervade even RF?

My own conviction is that God is an extremely sluggish explanation for...anything.
I'm (I was going to say 'afraid' because I don't particularly enjoy contradicting people - one of my many faults) 'with' Net Doc on this one. Yes, I do spend large amounts of energy following my faith.
Yes, I do feel that intellectual bigotry is rife amongst the current intelligencia.
Intelligencia:intellectuals who form an artistic, social, or political vanguard or elite
Does this bigotry pervade even RF? - unfortunately, I have to admit that there appear to be one or two members who behave in that manner.:)
 

Melody

Well-Known Member
truthseekingsoul said:
Do you spend large amounts of energy following your faith?
Yes. How can you possibly understand your faith and explain it to others if you don't take the time to study it and question why you belief what you do. Every day someone on RF will make a comment that requires me to go do some research on my own.

truthseekingsoul said:
Do you feel intellectual bigotry is rife amongst the current intelligencia?
Yes.

truthseekingsoul said:
Does this bigotry pervade even RF?
There are a couple people who fall into the category of bigot, but "pervade"? No. On the whole, most people in this forum seem to respect other's beliefs...even when they disagree with it.
 

roli

Born Again,Spirit Filled
lilithu said:
YES!! To truely believe in God is to live a godly life. (Which is not to say that people who don't believe live "ungodly" lives.) Afterall,if you don't truly live your beliefs, how does anyone (including yourself) know that the truly believe them?
God for me is not some father-figure up in the sky who's going to give me things when I ask, and "save" me just because I happen to believe some thing. As a UU, I believe that there is a divine spark in each of us, that can either be nurtured to grow or diminished with neglect. "Judgement" is not just on the "last" day, it's everyday.
Everyday I hold myself accountable to God and to myself as to whether I nurtured my own spark of divinity and those of others. (And I have to say I usually fall short.) Whether it's meditation/reflection for myself or volunteering in the community or just plain being nice to someone else, that's all rooted in my faith (for me).

Quote Roli I must comment on this first statement in which you say," to believe in God is to live a Godly life", that is a true statement, if you actually know how ( creation)God 's nature,character, personality,principals and standards are and how to fully carry them out.Otherwise, we become decieved into thinking we are Godly when in actuality it is more in our mind then it is our obedience and heart leading to devotion and adherence.
You don't become Godly towards God (creation,),by simply claiming to be Godly,or with good intent.
The whole christian tenet is that if you want to be Godly ,obviously referring to following after Him, you must believe,recieve,see Christ,come to Christ ,follow Christ,obey Christ and adhere to His principals and teachings because God and Christ claim that only thru the son can we be like God and come to the father.
You said QUOTE=lilithu]Which is not to say that people who don't believe live "ungodly" lives.) ,what is up with that, what God are you referring to,because you sure have the whole God ,Godly, affiliation twisted. Your own version perhaps,or copied.
How can you not believe (trust ,rely)in God and live a Godly life?.
Do you see that the 2 just don't go together.
Maybe your creating your own theology by trying to be politically correct,take a stand for God and represent Him accurately or keep him out of you philosophy and vocabulary.
These misconceptions are the very type that pervert the gospel and doctrines of God making the very acts ungodly in themself,how ironic!!!!
lilithu said:
God for me is not some father-figure up in the sky who's going to give me things when I ask, and "save" me just because I happen to believe some thing

Quote Roli
I'm am terribly sorry to make this shocking revealtion to you but God is exactly what you say, he is'nt,that is scriptural, over and over again,even God goes as far to call himself ABBA,father several times ,in Galations.Romans, but hey! what does that mean to you
God says my sheep hear my voice and follow me, what flock are you with is the question.
v6 You will know them by their fruits. by what they produce, what they say or do.
Matt 7 7 "Ask, and it will be given to you; seek, and you will find; knock, and it will be opened to you. 8 For everyone who asks receives, and he who seeks finds, and to him who knocks it will be opened. 9 Or what man is there among you who, if his son asks for bread, will give him a stone? 10 Or if he asks for a fish, will he give him a serpent? 11 If you then, being evil, know how to give good gifts to your children, how much more will your Father who is in heaven give good things to those who ask Him!

13 "Enter by the narrow gate; for wide is the gate and broad is the way that leads to destruction, and there are many who go in by it. 14 *Because narrow is the gate and difficult is the way which leads to life, and there are few who find it.

15 "Beware of false prophets, who come to you in sheep's clothing, but inwardly they are ravenous wolves. 16 You will know them by their fruits. Do men gather grapes from thornbushes or figs from thistles? 17 Even so, every good tree bears good fruit, but a bad tree bears bad fruit. 18 A good tree cannot bear bad fruit, nor can a bad tree bear good fruit. 19 Every tree that does not bear good fruit is cut down and thrown into the fire. 20 Therefore by their fruits you will know them.
21 "Not everyone who says to Me, 'Lord, Lord,' shall enter the kingdom of heaven, but he who does the will of My Father in heaven. 22 Many will say to Me in that day, 'Lord, Lord, have we not prophesied in Your name, cast out demons in Your name, and done many wonders in Your name?' 23 And then I will declare to them, 'I never knew you; depart from Me, you who practice lawlessness!'
24 "Therefore whoever hears these sayings of Mine, and does them, I will liken him to a wise man who built his house on the rock: 25 and the rain descended, the floods came, and the winds blew and beat on that house; and it did not fall, for it was founded on the rock.
26 "But everyone who hears these sayings of Mine, and does not do them, will be like a foolish man who built his house on the sand: 27 and the rain descended, the floods came, and the winds blew and beat on that house; and it fell. And great was its fall."

Quote Roli
H e may not be a Father to you, but He is a Father to those who make HiM their Father,because, you don't know Him, His word, His character,nature or even His Son Jesus. but yet you claim to be Godly. How is that possible,can you explain?
Do you pick and choose tenets of other religions according to your lifestyle and form and fashion them into a convincing theology. To God that is blasphemy.
You don't believe because you have not trusted with your heart, only attempted to understand with your mind.
John 10:1 A thief and robber come in another way then that of the gate,(which is Jesus)
To be Godly can only mean 1 thing , examplify God 100%, follow His way, not our way,not adding this ,removing that, replacing the Holy scriptures with some other doctrine,or having certain mindsets that are totally contray to His word.
Jesus is that example to follow ,but herein is the worlds problem,they scratch their head an say, that can't be the only way and for various reasons.
Can you still maintain a belief in God,yes!, even become super spiritual, even profess to be holy , but if not according to God's way, what do we have.
Believing in God does not make you Holy ,Godly, christian, or a good person.

QUOTE=lilithu]

But God for me is not an "explanation." The idea that God created the universe is rather incidental to my daily life. Much more important is God as the ideal towards which I strive, a relationship for which I work to cultivate. For me, to say that "I believe in God" isn't just saying that I believe that God exists, the way that a toaster exists. Who cares? When I say "I believe in God" I mean it like I believe in truth, love, beauty, justice... I mean it like when I say to someone I love "I believe in you."

Quote Roli
I understand how it can be incidental,until you have a revealtion of Him it will only seem like just another expression of a tenet or belief,if that really does anything for you
The truth of God is found in His word and you seem to be so far removed from His truth by just a few statements i have seen here, God is not just about love,joy, peace, goodness, unity, there is a side to God that is totally contray to popular belief ,but is written through out His word that is HE is Holy, righteous, Just ,in the sense where he will punish sin where it is found, because sin will not be present where God dwells, he is sovereign,etc. etc.
 

michel

Administrator Emeritus
Staff member
roli said:
[/color]
I understand how it can be incidental,until you have a revealtion of Him it will only seem like just another expression of a tenet or belief,if that really soes anything for you
The truth of God is found in His word and you seem to be so far removed from His truth by just a few statements i have sen here, God is not just about love,joy, peace, goodness, unity, there is a side to God that is totally contray to popular belief ,but is written through out His word that is HE is Holy, righteous, Just ,in the sense where he will punish sin where it is found, because sin will not be present where God dwells, he is sovereign,etc. etc.
He does not lie and His word is His word and shall accomplish what He says it will do
roli, I don't mean to be disrespectful, but I think that for you to pass a moral, theological judgement on another member of the forum in the above way is hardly 'in the spirit of your faith'.

Matthew 7:1 Judge not, that ye be not judged.
Luke 6:37 Judge not, and, ye shall not be judged: condemn: not, and, ye shall not be condemned: forgive,: and, ye shall be forgiven:

How can you possibly quote passages that suit your argument, while, at the same time, you are falling foul of the above ?:help:
 

roli

Born Again,Spirit Filled
michel said:
roli, I don't mean to be disrespectful, but I think that for you to pass a moral, theological judgement on another member of the forum in the above way is hardly 'in the spirit of your faith'.

Matthew 7:1 Judge not, that ye be not judged.
Luke 6:37 Judge not, and, ye shall not be judged: condemn: not, and, ye shall not be condemned: forgive,: and, ye shall be forgiven:

How can you possibly quote passages that suit your argument, while, at the same time, you are falling foul of the above ?:help:
Although it is a person's right to express their views, I would just think it is in my rights to set the record straight according to what I believe to be said in the word and line up what has been by others ,especially when it contridicts His word.
I'm sorry as well to hear someone profess tenets of God, then in the same breath refute who He claims to be,which is a Father and Savior among other things,picking and choosing,cutting and pasting certain doctrines to form a belief is an entitlement,but it will be up for discussion with those who practice that particular religion ,I'm sure

I would like to think I know the scriptures enough to be certain that Christ taught against those who refute the word of God.I thought I did this in the bond of peace,
I was not trying to be judgemental,just comparing one person's professions with what is actually said in the scriptures ,that is not judging in my eyes but holding people accountable to the fact that if they choose to speak about a religious perspective, for heavens sake get it straight.
 

roli

Born Again,Spirit Filled
michel said:
roli, I don't mean to be disrespectful, but I think that for you to pass a moral, theological judgement on another member of the forum in the above way is hardly 'in the spirit of your faith'.

Matthew 7:1 Judge not, that ye be not judged.
Luke 6:37 Judge not, and, ye shall not be judged: condemn: not, and, ye shall not be condemned: forgive,: and, ye shall be forgiven:

How can you possibly quote passages that suit your argument, while, at the same time, you are falling foul of the above ?:help:
Michel,I am not on a tangent of aimlessly criticising and fault finding unless it goes against God's word.
Unless you are a born again believer and the Holy sprit dwells in you ,you really should'nt use scriptures,unless you have the revealation of the Holy Spirit.
You may understand some natural illustrations and termonology,but the dimension God speaks to Christians thru is ,the spirit realm or supernatural and invisible
I won't argue that one ,take that to God, I know by experience and revealation

So many use logic and reason to try and understand and expound scripture and do the word a grave injustice, rendering the spoken word powerless and ineffective thru human intuition,not to insult your ability to read something and understand it,but you will miss the essence of what God says in His word unless you have a spiritual conversion ,that is just fact. as this scripture Jesus shares
You share scripture I hope you read as well
The bible is a book of MYSTERIES for those outside
Mar 4:11 And he said unto them, Unto you christians)it is given to know the mystery of the kingdom of God: but unto them that are outside all [these] things are done in parables:

Mar 4:12 That seeing they may see, and not perceive; and hearing they may hear, and not understand; lest at any time they should be converted, and [their] sins should be forgiven them.


1Cor 2: 9 But as it is written:
"Eye has not seen, nor ear heard,Nor have entered into the heart of manThe things which God has prepared for those who love Him."*
10 But God has revealed them to us through His Spirit. For the Spirit searches all things, yes, the deep things of God. 11 For what man knows the things of a man except the spirit of the man which is in him? Even so no one knows the things of God except the Spirit of God. 12 Now we have received, not the spirit of the world, but the Spirit who is from God, that we might know the things that have been freely given to us by God.
13 These things we also speak, not in words which man's wisdom teaches but which the *Holy Spirit teaches, comparing spiritual things with spiritual. 14 But the natural man does not receive the things of the Spirit of God, for they are foolishness to him; nor can he know them, because they are spiritually discerned. 15 But he who is spiritual judges all things, yet he himself is rightly judged by no one. 16 For "who has known the mind of the Lord that he may instruct Him?"* But we have the mind of Christ.


Michel, before I was a christian I had my own concepts and interpretaions of the word of God,I threw out scripture left and right as a religious hyprocrite,saying don't do this, this means this and that,then turn around and do the very thing I professed others not to do, not on purpose of course, not to mention using scripture out of context which was a grave injustice and a gross misrepresentation of God's intentions thru His word.

I never saw into the spiritual aspect of God,Christ,the bible ,or even the church through my natural eyes,until God's spirit touched me 8yrs ago did I begin to understand ,appreciate and appropriate His word and the revealation of it.
I was so far off, looking back now.
But people today who don't have Jesus Christ as Lord and Savior have not had there spritual eyes enlightened by the power of God but continue to walk in the realm of logic ,intellect and reason,trying to assess and disect and interpret that which can only be thru God's spirit .

If you sinned against Jesus by twisting His word, disbelieving what He says, etc and HE said you will be punished and the wages of your sin is death,and was about to cast you into Hell would you say to Him , don't Judge lest He be judged.

We are to judge righteously according to truth of His word as Jesus did.
Iam to rightly divide the word of God as 2 Tim2:15
By the way ,it is not me that condemns or judges, it's your own heart ( conscience)that will do the that my friend and it is God's job, thru His spirit to condemn,convict,reveal and judge
John 3:18 says he who does not believe (trust in ,rely on, adhere to and follow,obey)is condemned already ,,,,because he has not believed (trust in ,rely on, adhere to and follow,obey) in God's only son(Jesus),we must believe in everything in God's word,
Not one or two things and disbelieve the rest,but all things,but you will not believe and accept until you have His spirit living in you that gives you the eyes to see , the ears to hear and the heart to recieve,
When scripture is twisted,misused and misappropriated,as it was in Jesus day do you think for a minute He did not defend it according to the truth as I pointed out in the last thread inwhich you proceeded to respond to and here where your doing it again, you can rest assure I will defend the context and misinterpretations of the scriptures,but only as I line it up with what the scriptures actually say.
 

lilithu

The Devil's Advocate
Roli, the OP asked us theists whether our faith requires time and energy of us, and I gave my reflections. I did not claim to be speaking on anyone else's behalf. As I said, I will not debate my personal views on God. You are free to respond to the original questions as fits your own views.

And since this is in a debate forum, you are free to try to preach to me, but I will not waste any more of my time responding to you here.

addendum:
I guess that last part was a bit mean. I recognize that I was not respecting your divine spark. Look, I respect that you have very firm beliefs on God. And I understand that you think that I am spreading falsehoods about God, compared to what you know of God. I don't even mind if you think that I am going to hell. But I do ask that you respect that I am entitled to my own beliefs, which are not based entirely on your scriptures. I never claimed to be speaking as a Christian. There are people other than just Christians who believe in God.
 

Named

Member
Unless you are a born again believer and the Holy sprit dwells in you ,you really should'nt use scriptures,unless you have the revealation of the Holy Spirit.
You mean, "Unless you believe this farcical nonsense, you will see it for what it is: crap"

'Creationist scientist' is an incongruous insult to science.
Creation is story which under no circumstances will ANY embellishments contradict the starting position.
Ludicrous! Science is searching for the answer, creationist science is searching for a way to cram 'evidence' between a question and an answer. (which by the way is IMPOSSIBLE to fail in)
There are INFINITE routes between any A and B... If one believes he knows the truth, all that does not flatter this notion will be abandoned, and all that is in the fray will be violently twisted by a predisposition. That is viable research by WHAT stretch of the imagination?

-_-

Yeah, I thought i'd actually respond to the NetDoc quote >_>
 
Top