• Welcome to Religious Forums, a friendly forum to discuss all religions in a friendly surrounding.

    Your voice is missing! You will need to register to get access to the following site features:
    • Reply to discussions and create your own threads.
    • Our modern chat room. No add-ons or extensions required, just login and start chatting!
    • Access to private conversations with other members.

    We hope to see you as a part of our community soon!

Referee benched for being a woman.

Nanda

Polyanna
A female referee is told that she cannot officiate over a boy's basketball game at a private religious academy, because their rules state that a woman can not be in a position of power over a man.

Yahoo!
 

Isabella Lecour

Active Member
WOW. Those boys are being set up for gender discrimination lawsuits when they reach a position of authority inside the work force. I don't want to imagination how they will treat their fellow female co-worker or even their wife. How will they treat their mother when they become "adults?"

Was this game against a public school? If so...how does a religious school's policy trump public school and there-by federal law at the same time?
 

w00t

Active Member
A female referee is told that she cannot officiate over a boy's basketball game at a private religious academy, because their rules state that a woman can not be in a position of power over a man.

Yahoo!

Oh dear! I wonder how they would react if a woman became President of the USofA!
 

ChristineES

Tiggerism
Premium Member
As a Christian, I have to say they are wrong. It doesn't actually say in the Bible that women can't be in a "power" position over a man. In fact, In the OT, they had a Judge (a ruler) named Deborah who ruled over the Israelites for many years. Deborah even had a husband.
But who am I to tell what to do at their institution.

Judges 4:4 And Deborah, a prophetess, the wife of Lapidoth, she judged Israel at that time.
 
That's really not right. They neeed to realise men and women have equal parts in our world, and one cannot be rejected in any field if they wish to participate, or undertake.
 

logician

Well-Known Member
I hate to say this, but about every person I've met that went to a Catholic high school I thought had a rather jaded personality. Not that they were necessarily bad or mean(although some definitely were), just different.
 

nutshell

Well-Known Member
Religious organizations are free to discriminate in this way - it's an exception to Title VII, I believe.

Not saying I agree with it.
 

Captain Civic

version 2.0
Crazy Catholics. What's next, the father will burst in on the son and his wife having sex and yelling "don't use that condom!"?
 

djrez4

Swollen Member
That's really not right. They neeed to realise men and women have equal parts in our world, and one cannot be rejected in any field if they wish to participate, or undertake.

There's a large difference between "cannot" and "shouldn't be." Women most definitely can be rejected. Whether they should be is another question, entirely.

We must also acknowledge that men and women are not the same. We work in different way, both mentally and physically.

Enjoy: YouTube - Tale of Two Brains
 

Ozzie

Well-Known Member
A female referee is told that she cannot officiate over a boy's basketball game at a private religious academy, because their rules state that a woman can not be in a position of power over a man.

Yahoo!
Somebody has to be in charge.
 

Nanda

Polyanna
There's a large difference between "cannot" and "shouldn't be." Women most definitely can be rejected. Whether they should be is another question, entirely.

We must also acknowledge that men and women are not the same. We work in different way, both mentally and physically.

Enjoy: YouTube - Tale of Two Brains

You're not suggesting that the differences between men and women would keep her from being a competent referee?
 

JamBar85

Master Designer
A female referee is told that she cannot officiate over a boy's basketball game at a private religious academy, because their rules state that a woman can not be in a position of power over a man.

Yahoo!

That's ridiculous.

"We need a referee."
"No problem, I know a really good one. Never makes mistakes and always gives the right decisions."
"Brilliant. Send them in right away......... oh wait, shes a woman?"
"Yeah? so?"
"Oh we can't have that because a book said so. Guess we will have to go back to using Gerald the basketball hater again"
 

djrez4

Swollen Member
You're not suggesting that the differences between men and women would keep her from being a competent referee?

I'm not suggesting that, but I'm open to the possibility that there are neurological differences between us that could make men a better referee. It's equally possible that women make better referees because of how they're wired. I don't have enough information to go one way or the other.

This is the sort of thing that got the president of Harvard fired recently.
 

Francine

Well-Known Member
A female referee is told that she cannot officiate over a boy's basketball game at a private religious academy, because their rules state that a woman can not be in a position of power over a man.

Since when are boys "men" ?
 
Top