• Welcome to Religious Forums, a friendly forum to discuss all religions in a friendly surrounding.

    Your voice is missing! You will need to register to get access to the following site features:
    • Reply to discussions and create your own threads.
    • Our modern chat room. No add-ons or extensions required, just login and start chatting!
    • Access to private conversations with other members.

    We hope to see you as a part of our community soon!

Recent content by Poseidon Soter

  1. P

    Why should the US (and others, e.g. France) punish Syria?

    Who appointed them the world's policeman? And if it is for humanitarian reasons, what about all the other humanitarian causes out there?
  2. P

    Strict Islamic dress - a question to those who wear this

    So your argument would also apply to all other acts done to please a deity? And belief in deities that desire/dictate that acts be done to please them is what is ultimately primitive, more than the specific nature of the act in this case?
  3. P

    Why should the US (and others, e.g. France) punish Syria?

    Well, against a backdrop of previous US/Western engagement in the region, I think US/Western intervention in this case just further complicates the situation in the region. It's unlikely to make a huge difference to Assad's calculations, and given Iran's support for the Syrian government, will...
  4. P

    Why should the US (and others, e.g. France) punish Syria?

    But why should the West do so? And who gives them that right?
  5. P

    Strict Islamic dress - a question to those who wear this

    In what way(s) is this a primitive gesture, to your mind?
  6. P

    Why should the US (and others, e.g. France) punish Syria?

    What would you have had the West do in this scenario?
  7. P

    Why should the US (and others, e.g. France) punish Syria?

    I'm not convinced the analogy applies here, though it's an interesting one, to be sure. It's a little more complicated, for a start, not least given previous US/Western engagement in the region.
  8. P

    Why should the US (and others, e.g. France) punish Syria?

    Let's say there is absolute proof (or proof beyond reasonable doubt) that the Syrian government has used chemical weapons against civilians - does that give the West the right to somehow punish the Syrian government for this action? If so, why?
  9. P

    Why should the US (and others, e.g. France) punish Syria?

    But does any of this legitimate France's desire to punish the Syrian government for their latest (alleged) atrocity?
  10. P

    Why should the US (and others, e.g. France) punish Syria?

    Possible, of course. But methinks President Assad works to a different system of logic. And with Russia behind him, presumably he thinks he can act with impunity.
  11. P

    Why should the US (and others, e.g. France) punish Syria?

    That may well be. What about France?
  12. P

    Why should the US (and others, e.g. France) punish Syria?

    I don't doubt that a chemical attack occurred. And it is most likely the Syrian government. But it only just occurred, and I'm not a huge fan of throwing around accusations without proof, so am erring on the side of caution in this respect, for now at least.
  13. P

    Why should the US (and others, e.g. France) punish Syria?

    In this instance, the Syrian government for their alleged use of chemical weapons against civilians (assume, for the moment, that the Syrian government were responsible).
  14. P

    Why should the US (and others, e.g. France) punish Syria?

    To an extent, my questions also apply to this perhaps more hypothetical scenario - whose place would it be?
  15. P

    Why should the US (and others, e.g. France) punish Syria?

    I'm not sure about President Assad being a great statesman - to an extent this depends on what you mean by this - or of the wisdom of the US leaving NATO, but I'm equally unconvinced of the idea that it is the West's place to intervene on this score (as on many other scores). That said, what...
See more
Top