It does not have to be infinite time in the afterlife it could merely be infinite punishment that happens again and again and again till the person knows they are wrong. I think that it is reasonable because there are people who do not care about punishments, they will do it repeatedly, they are...
I cannot really say much because it is self explanatory to me the burden would fall upon you who said that it does. I don't see it being compatible with science but you said that it does before.
The Bible is only based on faith because that is what the book is for, the whole book contradicts...