We've had a few threads lately asking for opinions on whether God exists. To me, this is putting the cart before the horse a bit.
It seems to me that getting to the conclusion that the monotheistic god-concept of one particular religion exists needs a few other prior steps:
1. God-claims should be taken seriously.
2. Gods (as a category of thing) are possible.
3. Gods (as a category of thing) exist.
4. A particular god exists.
5. (For monotheistic religions) no other gods exist.
Personally, I'm back before step 1: I haven't accepted the idea that god-concepts are something that ought to be taken seriously. In fact, I lean toward the conclusion that they aren't something that warrants serious attention.
For those of you who have gotten past step 1: why? How did you do it?
And please note that I'm not asking why we should take theism and its effects seriously. Theism - especially religious theism - has all sorts of real effects on the world. I'm asking why we should take claims like "God exists" as serious and reasonable propositions about reality that merit investigation to see whether they're true or false.
So... what do you think? Why are god-claims something that should be taken seriously? Or are they?
It seems to me that getting to the conclusion that the monotheistic god-concept of one particular religion exists needs a few other prior steps:
1. God-claims should be taken seriously.
2. Gods (as a category of thing) are possible.
3. Gods (as a category of thing) exist.
4. A particular god exists.
5. (For monotheistic religions) no other gods exist.
Personally, I'm back before step 1: I haven't accepted the idea that god-concepts are something that ought to be taken seriously. In fact, I lean toward the conclusion that they aren't something that warrants serious attention.
For those of you who have gotten past step 1: why? How did you do it?
And please note that I'm not asking why we should take theism and its effects seriously. Theism - especially religious theism - has all sorts of real effects on the world. I'm asking why we should take claims like "God exists" as serious and reasonable propositions about reality that merit investigation to see whether they're true or false.
So... what do you think? Why are god-claims something that should be taken seriously? Or are they?