• Welcome to Religious Forums, a friendly forum to discuss all religions in a friendly surrounding.

    Your voice is missing! You will need to register to get access to the following site features:
    • Reply to discussions and create your own threads.
    • Our modern chat room. No add-ons or extensions required, just login and start chatting!
    • Access to private conversations with other members.

    We hope to see you as a part of our community soon!

Religion and Politics?

Salty Booger

Royal Crown Cola (RC)
Just a few questions:

Does the religious beliefs of a political candidate matter?

Would you feel better knowing that a politician has some religious conviction?

Would you feel better knowing that a politician has no religious conviction?

Does a politician's religious convictions equate to greater individual morality?

Do you believe religion plays a major role in American politics currently?
 

Rival

Si m'ait Dieus
Staff member
Premium Member
Does the religious beliefs of a political candidate matter?
No.

Would you feel better knowing that a politician has some religious conviction?
Not really. There are plenty of nutcase religious people.

Would you feel better knowing that a politician has no religious conviction?
Not really. Plenty of crazy atheists too.

Does a politician's religious convictions equate to greater individual morality?
Likely not.

Do you believe religion plays a major role in American politics currently?
For some reason, yes.
 

Yazata

Active Member
Just a few questions:

Does the religious beliefs of a political candidate matter?

Depends on the nature of the belief and on how the belief might motivate the candidate to act.

Would you feel better knowing that a politician has some religious conviction?

Yes and no, depending on the nature of the belief.

Would you feel better knowing that a politician has no religious conviction?

Yes and no, depending on whether the individual was a militant atheist who is hostile to any and all religious expression and practice. On the other hand I might favor somebody who is willing to ask questions and admits to not having all the answers. That would signal intellect and honesty to me.

Does a politician's religious convictions equate to greater individual morality?

In practice, not a whole lot.

Do you believe religion plays a major role in American politics currently?

Probably less than a lot of people think.
 

MNoBody

Well-Known Member
Just a few questions:

Does the religious beliefs of a political candidate matter?

Would you feel better knowing that a politician has some religious conviction?

Would you feel better knowing that a politician has no religious conviction?

Does a politician's religious convictions equate to greater individual morality?

Do you believe religion plays a major role in American politics currently?
No, it doesn't matter, not until they let it interfere with them discharging their duties [just doing their job in a competent manner]......
but it certainly is a "tell" [poker terminology]
and they are playing a game,
and our "skin" is in the pot, so to speak
and theocratic institutions are the pox of history [according to the track records in any case].

it is a good character indicator.
 

Secret Chief

Stiff Member
Would you feel better knowing that a politician has some religious conviction?
Depends what the conviction is. If it's a dubious one I'd certainly want to know about it.

Would you feel better knowing that a politician has no religious conviction?

Not really one way or the other.

Does a politician's religious convictions equate to greater individual morality?

Kidding, right?

Do you believe religion plays a major role in American politics currently?

Seems to. (I'm not an American).
 

Estro Felino

Believer in free will
Premium Member
Well...since I believe in secularism , I guess that an atheist politician would be the best thing.
I am not trying to demean theists (I am one, and a very proud one), but I think that a People is supposed to be guided by common values; values other than religious.

Of course this is just my humble, personal opinion.:)

As for the US...I am not the right person to answer that question. I hope religious and non-religious people are united by common values.
 

SalixIncendium

अग्निविलोवनन्दः
Staff member
Premium Member
Just a few questions:

Does the religious beliefs of a political candidate matter?

Would you feel better knowing that a politician has some religious conviction?

Would you feel better knowing that a politician has no religious conviction?

Does a politician's religious convictions equate to greater individual morality?

Do you believe religion plays a major role in American politics currently?

No.

No.

No.

Depends on the politician.

Yes.
 

sun rise

The world is on fire
Premium Member
Does the religious beliefs of a political candidate matter?

Would you feel better knowing that a politician has some religious conviction?

Would you feel better knowing that a politician has no religious conviction?

No. Belief, especially professed belief to me is virtually meaningless. If someone walks the talk, whether it be a religious person or an atheist humanist, it's meaningful.

Does a politician's religious convictions equate to greater individual morality?

How many examples of that being false do we need?

Do you believe religion plays a major role in American politics currently?

To some.
 

Altfish

Veteran Member
Just a few questions:

Does the religious beliefs of a political candidate matter?
Yes, they worry me.
I am British, there are very few politicians that I know what their religious beliefs are.
Religion and politics do not and should not mix

Would you feel better knowing that a politician has some religious conviction?
Definitely not.

Would you feel better knowing that a politician has no religious conviction?
As long as they do not discriminate about religious people

Does a politician's religious convictions equate to greater individual morality?
Certainly not

Do you believe religion plays a major role in American politics currently?
Yes
 

metis

aged ecumenical anthropologist
Does the religious beliefs of a political candidate matter?
I believe it may.

Would you feel better knowing that a politician has some religious conviction?
My main interest is trying to find out where his/her general philosophy come from, whether that be religious or secular. I would rather have a moral atheist in office than an immoral "true believer".
Does a politician's religious convictions equate to greater individual morality?
Not necessarily.

Do you believe religion plays a major role in American politics currently?
Yes, but not always in a good way.
 

Rival

Si m'ait Dieus
Staff member
Premium Member
Yes, they worry me.
I am British, there are very few politicians that I know what their religious beliefs are.
Religion and politics do not and should not mix


Definitely not.


As long as they do not discriminate about religious people


Certainly not


Yes
Blair is a Catholic and look what he did. Religiosity is not indicative of a good/better candidate and I say this as a religious person myself.
 

Altfish

Veteran Member
Blair is a Catholic and look what he did. Religiosity is not indicative of a good/better candidate and I say this as a religious person myself.
Yeah, he was one I did know.
Rees-Mogg is another that comes to mind; both were liars for a living.
 

Quintessence

Consults with Trees
Staff member
Premium Member
Does the religious beliefs of a political candidate matter?

Assuming their stated religion is actually their religion (aka, their way of life - the narratives that inform their central values, behaviors, sense of life's meaning, and community) and they are also properly religious about that religion, there's nothing more important to know about a human person.

Would you feel better knowing that a politician has some religious conviction?

Of course not - every human has religious convictions. The question is what those deeply-held convictions are. What narratives and values guide their behavior and their relationships? What is their way of life?

Would you feel better knowing that a politician has no religious conviction?

There's no such thing as a human without deeply-held (aka, religious) convictions. Well, technically there are some, but none of those could be running for office. People don't run for public office without deeply-held convictions.

Does a politician's religious convictions equate to greater individual morality?

The idea of "greater individual morality" frankly does not compute to me.

Do you believe religion plays a major role in American politics currently?

It plays a role in all politics in every country, whether or not it is recognized or labeled as such. The narratives of a culture always and inevitably impact politics, as do their central values, the behaviors that emerge from all of this, and the resulting communities for which the governments are for in the first place.
 

PureX

Veteran Member
Just a few questions:

Does the religious beliefs of a political candidate matter?
Only if they believe they must do the bidding of their god before the people they are elected to represent. In these instances, there people should not run for public office in a representational government.To do so is to be deliberately dishonest, and destructive of the form of government the people have chosen to enact.

The same, I believe, is true for this latest Supreme Court Judge nominee. She is of the belief that doing her god's bidding is more important than doing the job she is seeking to be assigned. I feel this is a form of deliberate dishonesty, and misrepresentation. She should not be a civil judge in any court if she cannot set her religious beliefs aside while she's sitting on the bench.
 

Salty Booger

Royal Crown Cola (RC)
She should not be a civil judge in any court if she cannot set her religious beliefs aside while sitting on the bench.
I haven't heard any indication that her religious beliefs will interfere with her job description, which is to interpret the Constitution.
 

PureX

Veteran Member
I haven't heard any indication that her religious beliefs will interfere with her job description, which is to interpret the Constitution.
Nor have we heard her asked, and state, that when the two ideologies clash (as they inevitably will), that she will set "Jesus" aside, and do what's right by the Constitution and the people of the nation. From what I have read about the religious group she belongs to, I suspect it is highly unlikely that she would be willing to do so.
 

Salty Booger

Royal Crown Cola (RC)
Nor have we heard her asked, and state, that when the two ideologies clash (as they inevitably will), that she will set "Jesus" aside, and do what's right by the Constitution and the people of the nation. From what I have read about the religious group she belongs to, I suspect it is highly unlikely that she would be willing to do so.
Looks like we will be guessing until she proves us right or wrong.
 

Kenny

Face to face with my Father
Premium Member
Just a few questions:

Does the religious beliefs of a political candidate matter?

I think so, in certain cases. For an example, if his/her beliefs line up with Satan vs Jesus... it just might make a difference in their voting or direction for the country. An atheist beliefs may include eliminating religion.

HOWEVER, it is more than just what they say about their religious beliefs because usually I can't hear them because what they are doing is shouting so loud.

Would you feel better knowing that a politician has some religious conviction?

Some probably is better than none. Again "Freedom of religion" may be at risk.

Would you feel better knowing that a politician has no religious conviction?

For some... I'm sure.

Does a politician's religious convictions equate to greater individual morality?

Not necessarily. There are always exceptions. What I do know is that when I acquired faith convictions, it did change my morality. But I have seen some that didn't.

Do you believe religion plays a major role in American politics currently?

Always has besides, gun right or no rights play a major role, pro-life or pro-death plays a major role, pro-socialism vs pro-capitalism etc etc etc.
 
Top