• Welcome to Religious Forums, a friendly forum to discuss all religions in a friendly surrounding.

    Your voice is missing! You will need to register to get access to the following site features:
    • Reply to discussions and create your own threads.
    • Our modern chat room. No add-ons or extensions required, just login and start chatting!
    • Access to private conversations with other members.

    We hope to see you as a part of our community soon!

What is the evidence you looking for?

Heyo

Veteran Member
I not going to ask you have your wish :) but what you asking for is a human way of thinking. God does not think In this way.
Why should a God follow a demand from a human being :confused:
Who's talking about gods? Assuming you don't think of yourself as a god, it was a humans (your) request for comments what would be acceptable as evidence. I think @ChristineM answered your request perfectly.
 

Spirit of Light

Be who ever you want
How do you know how a god thinks?
:) i do not know fully how a god thinks, but after so many years within spiritual practice and study of the teaching i have understood that a God do not think as humans, nu and has ego, a God does not need to prove to anyone, only humans demand of higher beings what humans is to lady to realize them self. God, Buddha or other enlightened beings has already given us humans all we need to realize the truth and to realize what God vasking of us, it is human beings who see it as a demand because we have to actually do something to gain the answer. God does not need prove to a disbeliever that God exist. God already know
 

Spirit of Light

Be who ever you want
Who's talking about gods? Assuming you don't think of yourself as a god, it was a humans (your) request for comments what would be acceptable as evidence. I think @ChristineM answered your request perfectly.
I am not a God or a Buddha :) my OP was created so it would be possible to answer your understanding, and i ask more questions.

The funny is that disbelievers demand believers or Even God to show them proof that God exist. But when a believer ask of an non believer, prove God does not exist, they can not come up with a clear answer. So they attack believers.

You see only when someone realize enlightenment would they be fully able to give those proofs, but as får as i know nobody in RF is enlightened beings:)
 

osgart

Nothing my eye, Something for sure
Well God has the ability to do whatsoever God wishes. I would like to see God make creatures without serious errors and faults in a place God himself would govern.

Nature does seem to be totally indifferent to the sufferings of its creatures. Why is that?
 

Spirit of Light

Be who ever you want
Well God has the ability to do whatsoever God wishes. I would like to see God make creatures without serious errors and faults in a place God himself would govern.

Nature does seem to be totally indifferent to the sufferings of its creatures. Why is that?
In my understanding the errors arise because of humans karma, result of wrongdoing from the past. Karma do stick to us until we have repayed, or fixed our life so we dont do immoral action, speech and thoughts
 

ChristineM

"Be strong", I whispered to my coffee.
Premium Member
:) i do not know fully how a god thinks, but after so many years within spiritual practice and study of the teaching i have understood that a God do not think as humans, nu and has ego, a God does not need to prove to anyone, only humans demand of higher beings what humans is to lady to realize them self. God, Buddha or other enlightened beings has already given us humans all we need to realize the truth and to realize what God vasking of us, it is human beings who see it as a demand because we have to actually do something to gain the answer. God does not need prove to a disbeliever that God exist. God already know

And your evidence for this series of statements?
 

Spirit of Light

Be who ever you want
And your evidence for this series of statements?
Well you have the bible, Torah, Quran, Buddhist Suttas, Hindu scripture, Zhuan Falun from Falun Gong, all this books contain evidence that can be verified across the teachings. But no science are not on the level of underunderstanding the truth in spiritual scripture. Because science look out on the physical world wheras spiritual teaching look within our mind to purify it to we realize the true meaning of our exisence and thereby understanding that the teaching is true.

I do not expect any atheists to see my answer as proof, and honestly that does not bother me, because spiritual teaching does not need scientific proof for those who use hour after hour study the teaching, we gain our answer from the teaching.
 

ChristineM

"Be strong", I whispered to my coffee.
Premium Member
Well you have the bible, Torah, Quran, Buddhist Suttas, Hindu scripture, Zhuan Falun from Falun Gong, all this books contain evidence that can be verified across the teachings. But no science are not on the level of underunderstanding the truth in spiritual scripture. Because science look out on the physical world wheras spiritual teaching look within our mind to purify it to we realize the true meaning of our exisence and thereby understanding that the teaching is true.

I do not expect any atheists to see my answer as proof, and honestly that does not bother me, because spiritual teaching does not need scientific proof for those who use hour after hour study the teaching, we gain our answer from the teaching.

Nope, those books have comments written by man and as far as i know, nothing of substance can be verified. Sure, third party evidence exists that some people and some places existed. But of the key stuff that builds a religion.

As i explained yesterday on another thread and you agreed, people can and are often well above the levels you insist are barred to science. And i think you just agreed with me, spirituality is of the mind and therefore imagination, and dreams.

Thanks for the agreement, you are most welcome to your own mind
 

Mock Turtle

Oh my, did I say that!
Premium Member
I not going to ask you have your wish :) but what you asking for is a human way of thinking. God does not think In this way.
Why should a God follow a demand from a human being :confused:

So prayers don't work - if not demands, they are at least entreaties?
 

Mock Turtle

Oh my, did I say that!
Premium Member
In my understanding the errors arise because of humans karma, result of wrongdoing from the past. Karma do stick to us until we have repayed, or fixed our life so we dont do immoral action, speech and thoughts

This is all just too easy an explanation and such that we could find an explanation for almost anything - if we had sufficient imagination.
 

Spirit of Light

Be who ever you want
Nope, those books have comments written by man and as far as i know, nothing of substance can be verified. Sure, third party evidence exists that some people and some places existed. But of the key stuff that builds a religion.

As i explained yesterday on another thread and you agreed, people can and are often well above the levels you insist are barred to science. And i think you just agreed with me, spirituality is of the mind and therefore imagination, and dreams.

Thanks for the agreement, you are most welcome to your own mind
I did not agree that it is imagination :) science dont know halv of what the mind is, and what it can do, read the spiritual teachings and cultivate them and you will know :)

Sorry to say it but science is as false as your claim of spiritual teaching:)
 

Spirit of Light

Be who ever you want
Mods: if any of you see this, maybe it would be right to move it to a debate Forum because Q& A is not meant for debat, and it look like this getting close to debate.
 

Aupmanyav

Be your own guru
You see only when someone realize enlightenment would they be fully able to give those proofs, but as far as i know nobody in RF is enlightened beings:)
Amanaki, I am a realized person and I cannot give any proof of existence of God / Allah, for the simple reason that no such entity exists. How can I give proof of what does not exist?
.. read the spiritual teachings and cultivate them and you will know :)
Amanaki, just because you are not clear in your thoughts, do not assume that others need to study scriptures. They might already have done that and might have decided on something which may be different from your views.
 
Last edited:

SalixIncendium

अग्निविलोवनन्दः
Staff member
Premium Member
Amanaki, I am a realized person and I cannot give any proof of existence of God / Allah, because no such entity exists. How can I give proof of what does not exist?

Just because such a being doesn't exist in your current understanding/realization does not necessarily mean that it doesn't exist in another's.

I really don't see how it's in any way useful for a "realized person" to tell another that his or her deity does not exist. I will remind you that in Hinduism, one path on the road to realization is bhakti yoga.
 

ChristineM

"Be strong", I whispered to my coffee.
Premium Member
I did not agree that it is imagination :)

science dont know halv of what the mind is,
and what it can do, read the spiritual teachings and cultivate them and you will know :)

Sorry to say it but science is as false as your claim of spiritual teaching:)


You stated "wheras spiritual teaching look within our mind "

Nor do you or anyone else, but you believe. Belief is not knowledge, it is imagination.

And yet you are happy to grasp quantum mechanics to post on RF. How false is that? As false as your claim that spiritual stuff transcends reality

I am not arguing against what you believe. My argument is that you claim it as fact without any form of proor
 

Spirit of Light

Be who ever you want
Amanaki, I am a realized person and I cannot give any proof of existence of God / Allah, for the simple reason that no such entity exists. How can I give proof of what does not exist?Amanaki, just because you are not clear in your thoughts, do not assume that others need to study scriptures. They might already have done that and might have decided on something which may be different from your views.
When you say you are an realized person, what does that mean in your understanding? How do you know you are an enlightened being?
 

Aupmanyav

Be your own guru
Just because such a being doesn't exist in your current understanding/realization does not necessarily mean that it doesn't exist in another's.
I will remind you that in Hinduism, one path on the road to realization is bhakti yoga.
If it does, then they are welcome to believe as they will. I have made my search and decided for myself.
I interjected because Amanaki said there is no realized person in RF. On the contrary, I think that there are many realized persons in RF.
And you also know that in Advaita, there is no 'bhakti', because you are yourself that.
When you say you are an realized person, what does that mean in your understanding? How do you know you are an enlightened being?
It means that there are now no questions that puzzle me. I have answers to all questions relating to religion and spirituality. No ambiguity, no doubts, 'Nir + vana' - no tree obstructing my view - 'nirvana', 'jnana'. No 'dvandva', as we say in Hinduism - not knowing whether this is correct or that.
 
Last edited:
Top