Welcome to Religious Forums, a friendly forum to discuss all religions in a friendly surrounding.
Your voice is missing! You will need to register to get access to the following site features:We hope to see you as a part of our community soon!
Must someone intend to do evil for their act or behavior to be evil?...
Are you saying that Hitler didn't commit an evil act when he ordered the genocide of the Jews because he wanted to save the world by getting rid of those "evil" people?I think so. It is possible that person makes mistake and his intention is not to do evil or wrong thing. In that case I think it is not really evil, just unfortunate mistake.
Must someone intend to do evil for their act or behavior to be evil?
If so, how does evil differ in that regard (if it differs at all) from what is merely bad?
Yes.Must someone intend to do evil for their act or behavior to be evil?
One centers on intent and the other on effect.If so, how does evil differ in that regard (if it differs at all) from what is merely bad?
Evil is defined (by me) as a choice. The choice to act antithetical to the well being of the existential whole, in favor of one's own desires. How conscious and/or deliberate that decision is, is a tangential issue.Must someone intend to do evil for their act or behavior to be evil?
If so, how does evil differ in that regard (if it differs at all) from what is merely bad?
Not necessarily. An act can be immoral (evil) if the agent is aware (or could or should be aware) of a possible bad outcome.Must someone intend to do evil for their act or behavior to be evil?
Our intentions matter as far as the state of our soul goes -- we should aspire to bring our intentions into line.Must someone intend to do evil for their act or behavior to be evil?
If so, how does evil differ in that regard (if it differs at all) from what is merely bad?
Are you saying that Hitler didn't commit an evil act when he ordered the genocide of the Jews because he wanted to save the world by getting rid of those "evil" people?
But strictly on his intention, one cannot say that it was evil. Having the intention to save the world isn't evil.I believe he had wrong motive and reason and therefore did evil thing. And even if it would not be called evil, it was wrong.