We can dispense with the stone entirely, if you want - considering the issue at hand here is that "heavy" doesn't apply to the "realm" of God (as if anyone knows what this really is), and use some more traditional/generally-accepted aspect of God's "being". Let's try:
- Can God create a universe so large that He can become lost within it?
- Can God create a population of beings so numerous that He can't keep track of them all?
- Does God have the ability to sin?
The original question (or any of the above) is only used to highlight the fact that God being "all powerful" is simply an impossibility. If God cannot create a universe so large He can become lost within it, then that is an example of something He CANNOT do - therefore He isn't "all powerful". And if God CAN create a universe so large He can become lost within it, then He is also proven less than "all powerful" because He is unable to find His way in a universe that large.
If God is incapable of "sin" - either because He is "too perfect" or because His action, by its very definition, is
not sin, then sinning is something He is unable to do... and therefore He is not "all powerful."
I have a sneaking suspicion that I didn't need to explain all of this to you... however it seems a naive thing to point to "orange" and "heavy" and pretend that I am of the opinion that those are the only things that do, or don't make sense to apply to God. In point of fact, if
ANYTHING AT ALL applies to God (which, let's face it... there had better be
SOMETHING, or one might actually be forced to admit that He doesn't exist), then I can formulate a problematic interrogative like any of the above, guaranteed.