• Welcome to Religious Forums, a friendly forum to discuss all religions in a friendly surrounding.

    Your voice is missing! You will need to register to get access to the following site features:
    • Reply to discussions and create your own threads.
    • Our modern chat room. No add-ons or extensions required, just login and start chatting!
    • Access to private conversations with other members.

    We hope to see you as a part of our community soon!

whats your beef with brexit?

The Holy Bottom Burp

Active Member
Human, all too human, as Nietzsche (or his translator) said ─ the old traditional typing of sweaty, slack, lusty, Catholic Mediterraneans and icebound, virtuous, disciplined, Protestant northerners, with France in the middle.

And emigration to another EU country where things are better is consciously part of the EU setup, and according to the press a major Brexit chafing point. If I were an educated Latvian I wouldn't stay in Latvia.
I didn't mean to generalise too much, it is not just that the EU was seen as economically advantageous for countries like Greece, I also suspect wealthy members like the fact that it preserves the status quo in terms of the balance of power (political and economic). Recession is beginning to recede now, but the countries most damaged by it was not the traditional powerhouses like Germany or the UK, it was the poorer nations. That is why I think some commentators think the UK is cutting off its nose to spite its face with Brexit. Not so I'd say, we do not owe our prosperity to the EU, or our economic resilience. We will have to renegotiate our trading terms with our trading partners, but the idea that we will be hit with prohibitive tolls on all our exports is scaremongering, it wont happen. Business is business, people will always want to trade regardless of the system of government, a war of taxation on imports helps nobody.
Certainly to form a free trade zone. And behind that, idealism, the dream of a united Europe where WW2 could never happen again.

And that would account for the curious adventure with the Euro, which deprived those states which chose it of their economic flexibility ─ not least Greece, Italy and Spain.
Sure, the "free trade zone" makes sense, but that is nothing more than an administrative agreement between the countries that make up Europe. I won't tax the hell out of your exports if you don't tax the hell out of mine. It doesn't even call for a "single currency" if the truth be told, currency is just a way of counting the beans after all.

The original intent of the EU may have been to help preserve peace in Europe, but the world is a very different place now. It is pretty much unthinkable that the major players in Europe would ever contemplate war in this day and age, or that an aggressive militaristic administration might gain power in Germany, France, Italy,Spain or the UK; extreme politics is a busted flush, it is possibly only the Islamic fundamentalists who think there is some mileage in it. However, that kind of thinking originates from religious belief, not rational thought or an appreciation of history. I accept there remains extreme left wing and right wing parties in Europe, but they represent minority thinking. Every now and then they gain publicity because they win a seat or two, but the general pattern is they come and go. People use them to register a protest vote.

So, I think the UK leaving the EU may be the beginning of the end for it. If, as I suspect we will, carry on without economic calamity other nations may begin to question the value of it. If member states find themselves practically bankrupt again, begging for a loan to pay the bills, the people might just say "Why are we in this thing again?", and seek their own exit.
 

blü 2

Veteran Member
Premium Member
We will have to renegotiate our trading terms with our trading partners, but the idea that we will be hit with prohibitive tolls on all our exports is scaremongering, it wont happen.
a. I really hope that's right. b. Where's the well-informed, fully briefed, hard-nosed, experienced, highly skilled British Negotiating Team needed to effect this, right this moment?
So, I think the UK leaving the EU may be the beginning of the end for it.
That brings up the enormously cumbersome voting system by which the enormously cumbersome EU Agreement can be amended. If this model fails as you say, the next try will sure look different.
 

blü 2

Veteran Member
Premium Member
Spain Portugal Italy all under austerity too,highest unemployment for years and most probably years to come.
Mr Micawber put it this way, you'll remember:

"Annual income twenty pounds, annual expenditure nineteen pounds nineteen and six, result happiness. Annual income twenty pounds, annual expenditure twenty pounds nought and six, result misery."
If they'd retained their own currencies, they'd still be suffering from their own economic vices, but they'd have a lot more economic flexibility than they do. Greece too, of course.
 

LuisDantas

Aura of atheification
Premium Member
Spain Portugal Italy all under austerity too,highest unemployment for years and most probably years to come.
That is true of Brazil as well. It turns out that we are to a large extent descendants of those three cultures (mainly Portugal). We have never been a part of the EU.
 

DavidFirth

Well-Known Member
Scotland should be allowed to stay in. It benefits Scotland to be in the union even though England suffers for it.

If Scotland is not allowed by the UK to remain in the EU, then Scotland should go independent. That's my two cents.
 

England my lionheart

Rockerjahili Rebel
Premium Member
Scotland should be allowed to stay in. It benefits Scotland to be in the union even though England suffers for it.

If Scotland is not allowed by the UK to remain in the EU, then Scotland should go independent. That's my two cents.

I agree but I think the Scots showed in the election that they are not wanting independence showed
 

DavidFirth

Well-Known Member
I agree but I think the Scots showed in the election that they are not wanting independence showed

There is supposed to be another election, so far delayed. I think it will be delayed until/unless unrest reaches a peak not seen before. It probably won't happen and Scotland will remain in the UK.
 

Rival

Si m'ait Dieus
Staff member
Premium Member
There is supposed to be another election, so far delayed. I think it will be delayed until/unless unrest reaches a peak not seen before. It probably won't happen and Scotland will remain in the UK.
There is no other referendum scheduled.
 

The Holy Bottom Burp

Active Member
a. I really hope that's right. b. Where's the well-informed, fully briefed, hard-nosed, experienced, highly skilled British Negotiating Team needed to effect this, right this moment?
To a. I'd say money is a great motivator, it tends to override everything else. I'm not worried that is about to change. To b. I'd say Politics is more guess work than a lot of politicians would like to admit, and to be honest we are entering new territory here; it was not seriously envisioned that we would leave the EU as a "mature" member by our own government, and no more the other members of the alliance. In true bureaucratic style I expect it to be a tad messy and long winded. We'll get there eventually though.
 
Top