Shad
Veteran Member
Might does not make right. It just gives you a better seat at the table.
-
Welcome to Religious Forums, a friendly forum to discuss all religions in a friendly surrounding.
Your voice is missing! You will need to register to get access to the following site features:- Reply to discussions and create your own threads.
- Our modern chat room. No add-ons or extensions required, just login and start chatting!
- Access to private conversations with other members.
We hope to see you as a part of our community soon!
What is wrong with smashing the idols?
- Thread starter sovietchild
- Start date
Might does not make right. It just gives you a better seat at the table.
Shad
Veteran Member
Muslims attempted to destroy it a number of times. Failure to do so does not mean there was no attempt. There were several over the centuries
Jedster
Well-Known Member
Maybe Muhammed got the idea from Abraham who is an important prophet in Islam.
FearGod
Freedom Of Mind
These are claims and not evidences, the article itself says that Muslims left no evidence
to prove that the site was of a temple, so it's just a claim.
FearGod
Freedom Of Mind
When you say they did it because of Islam then Islam was in Egypt 1500 years ago
and not now.
No relation between Islam and destruction of the idols.
FearGod
Freedom Of Mind
Are you guessing of what had happened?
Fearvag...
Here...
1. Muhammad is the prophet of Islam
2. Muslims are called to follow the sunnah of Muhammad
3. Muhammad smashed idols
comprenez-vous?
FearGod
Freedom Of Mind
Do you have an evidence that he did?
Do you have a verse in the quran which instructed prophet Muhammad to smash the idols
or instructing Muslims to smash and destroy the idols, the temples..etc
The temple has been mentioned in the Puranas including the Kashi Khanda (section) of Skanda Purana. The original Vishwanath temple was destroyed by the army of Qutb-ud-din Aibak in 1194 CE, when he defeated the Raja of Kannauj as a commander of Mohammad Ghori. The temple was rebuilt by a Gujarati merchant during the reign of Delhi's Sultan Iltutmish (1211-1266 CE). It was demolished again during the rule of either Hussain Shah Sharqi (1447-1458) or Sikandar Lodhi (1489-1517). Raja Man Singh built the temple during Mughal emperor Akbar's rule, but orthodox Hindus boycotted it as he had let the Mughals marry within his family. Raja Todar Mal further re-built the temple with Akbar's funding at its original site in 1585.[4]
In 1669 CE, Emperor Aurangzeb destroyed the temple and built the Gyanvapi Mosque in its place.[5] The remains of the erstwhile temple can be seen in the foundation, the columns and at the rear part of the mosque.[6]
Kashi Vishwanath Temple - Wikipedia
One of many.
In 1669 CE, Emperor Aurangzeb destroyed the temple and built the Gyanvapi Mosque in its place.[5] The remains of the erstwhile temple can be seen in the foundation, the columns and at the rear part of the mosque.[6]
Kashi Vishwanath Temple - Wikipedia
One of many.
Ahadith are not good enough now?
Ahadith are not good enough now?
You've turned FearGod into a Quranist.
Umm the wikipedia site I linked lists numerous cases of Muslim rulers explicitly destroying Hindu and Buddhist temples in South Asia with over 250 citations and references. What more do you want?
FearGod
Freedom Of Mind
Taliban doesn't represent Islam, Afghanistan was in the hand of Muslims 1500 years ago,
destroying the statues at our recent days doesn't mean it was because of Islam.
FearGod
Freedom Of Mind
I ain't a quranist, I am a Muslim till the last breath in my earthly life.
Mate...
The temple has been mentioned in the Puranas including the Kashi Khanda (section) of Skanda Purana. The original Vishwanath temple was destroyed by the army of Qutb-ud-din Aibak in 1194 CE, when he defeated the Raja of Kannauj as a commander of Mohammad Ghori. The temple was rebuilt by a Gujarati merchant during the reign of Delhi's Sultan Iltutmish (1211-1266 CE). It was demolished again during the rule of either Hussain Shah Sharqi (1447-1458) or Sikandar Lodhi (1489-1517). Raja Man Singh built the temple during Mughal emperor Akbar's rule, but orthodox Hindus boycotted it as he had let the Mughals marry within his family. Raja Todar Mal further re-built the temple with Akbar's funding at its original site in 1585.[4]
In 1669 CE, Emperor Aurangzeb destroyed the temple and built the Gyanvapi Mosque in its place.[5] The remains of the erstwhile temple can be seen in the foundation, the columns and at the rear part of the mosque.[6]
Kashi Vishwanath Temple - Wikipedia
One of many.
FearGod
Freedom Of Mind
Ahadith are not good enough now?
Compared to the quran the hadith has no value.
Qur'an makes little sense taken on its own. I am pretty sure you know this.
FearGod
Freedom Of Mind
Many Hindus converted to Islam during that era, if they chose to build a mosque in the site
of the temple then why you see it as a problem, in Saudi Arabia the polytheists converted to
Islam and of course all ancient temples has no reason to exist, I can't see a problem with
converting the stones from one building to another one.