• Welcome to Religious Forums, a friendly forum to discuss all religions in a friendly surrounding.

    Your voice is missing! You will need to register to get access to the following site features:
    • Reply to discussions and create your own threads.
    • Our modern chat room. No add-ons or extensions required, just login and start chatting!
    • Access to private conversations with other members.

    We hope to see you as a part of our community soon!

The Bible, Purim, and Peoplehood

Jayhawker Soule

-- untitled --
Premium Member
The Jewish holiday of Purim began last night, and earlier today I happened upon an interesting interview with Professor Jacob L. Wright in The Times of Israel under the headline:


Excerpting ...

As Jews around the world hear the Book of Esther read aloud this Purim, they might not know that they’re listening to the most biblical of all Jewish texts — or so claims Prof. Jacob L. Wright in the final chapter of his thought-provoking new book, “Why the Bible Began: An Alternative History of Scripture and Its Origins.”

... Wright believes it was national rather than religious ideology that motivated anonymous scribes to write the Bible over various periods spanning the fall of the previous Kingdom of Israel in 722 BCE, the decline of Judah, and the centuries after the Babylonian capture of Jerusalem. The Bible’s ultimate purpose, he states, was to create an unprecedented sense of peoplehood for the Jews, especially after the end of Judah.

There are several key terms to keep track of here. The author distinguishes between a nation and a state, writing that the former is “a political community held together by shared memories and a will to act in solidarity,” while the latter is “a polity with institutions of government and a territory that can be conquered and destroyed.” He also distinguishes between “national” and “ethnic,” stating that the ancient Israelites consisted of multiple ethnicities, including among the Transjordanian and Negev communities.

But, you might ask, what about religion? What about monotheism, Yahweh or the Ten Commandments? For the author, they are very much part of the narrative – only in a perhaps unfamiliar way. The incorporation of a shared monotheistic religion was one way that biblical scribes preserved a Jewish sense of peoplehood, editing out past references to polytheism as they did so.

With respect to Israel’s national deity, Wright argues that at the beginning, there were many deities bearing the name Yahweh: “Maybe, at some level, they referred to the same god. But they represented rival cities and regions. At some point, and especially after the fall of the Northern kingdom in 722 BCE, many were looking for a new point of unity. Without a palace or a dynasty, the biblical scribes affirmed that Yahweh is the nation’s God, and that there is only Yahweh. ‘Hear O Israel, Yhwh is our God, Yhwh is one!’”

In my opinion it really is an interesting interview. I've ordered the book. Hopefully, it will arrive tomorrow.
 

DNB

Christian
The entirety of Jewish Scripture (TaNaKh) demands the religious observance of the descendants of Abraham, and those who chose to become proselytes. The nation only stood unified and under the auspices of God, provided that they followed all the religious precepts legislated by YHWH - Israel is a religious entity, not a racially or politically defined one.

Their multiple demises, more prominently the destruction and deportations of 722 BC, and 597 - 586 BC, were due solely to their neglect of their religious obligations - this, the authors made abundantly clear.

There was never a divine covenant established between God and the Patriarchs, that did not emphatically and incessantly stipulate that the conditions were based exclusively on Israel's obedience to the Law, or God's ways.
 

Elihoenai

Well-Known Member
The entirety of Jewish Scripture (TaNaKh) demands the religious observance of the descendants of Abraham, and those who chose to become proselytes. The nation only stood unified and under the auspices of God, provided that they followed all the religious precepts legislated by YHWH - Israel is a religious entity, not a racially or politically defined one.

Their multiple demises, more prominently the destruction and deportations of 722 BC, and 597 - 586 BC, were due solely to their neglect of their religious obligations - this, the authors made abundantly clear.

There was never a divine covenant established between God and the Patriarchs, that did not emphatically and incessantly stipulate that the conditions were based exclusively on Israel's obedience to the Law, or God's ways.
Deuteronomy 26:18

18 And the Lord hath avouched thee this day to be his peculiar people, as he hath promised thee, and that thou shouldest keep all his commandments;



The Existence of Israel is Entirely Conditional on the Total Devotion to the Religion of the Elohim/God of Israel. Be Not Deceived, Genetics has got Nothing to do with the Identity/Existence of Israel. This means it's Impossible for an Atheist, Apostate or Uncommitted/Lukewarm person to be Israel. The Elohim/God of Israel Creates Whole Hearted Israel through Total Obedience to All His Commandments.
 
Last edited:

DNB

Christian
Deuteronomy 26:18

18 And the Lord hath avouched thee this day to be his peculiar people, as he hath promised thee, and that thou shouldest keep all his commandments;



The Existence of Israel is Entirely Conditional on the Total Devotion to the Religion of the Elohim/God of Israel. Be Not Deceived, Genetics has got Nothing to do with the Identity/Existence of Israel. This means it's Impossible for an Atheist, Apostate or Uncommitted/Lukewarm person to be Israel. The Elohim/God of Israel Creates Whole Hearted Israel through Total Obedience to All His Commandments.
Yes, agreed. God chose a Abraham and his descendants for one reason alone: to represent Him throughout the nations.
Israel (one who wrestles with God) is a theocracy, and not a political institution nor biological race.
 

Elihoenai

Well-Known Member
Yes, agreed. God chose a Abraham and his descendants for one reason alone: to represent Him throughout the nations.
Israel (one who wrestles with God) is a theocracy, and not a political institution nor biological race.
1 Samuel 16:7

7 But the Lord said unto Samuel, Look not on his countenance, or on the height of his stature; because I have refused him: for the Lord seeth not as man seeth; for man looketh on the outward appearance, but the Lord looketh on the heart.



Naturally the World is Racialised given that Man looketh on the Outward Appearance. The World is Ordered by a Racial Hierarchy that is Ordained by Elohim/God. The Leaders of this Racial Hierarchy are English/Germans and so-called Jews.

I live in London England, and as part of the 24/7 Surveillance by the State, for years they have made continuous futile efforts to Racialise me. I'm only Racialised on paper when filling in Racial Data Forms. Elohim/God has called Israel Out of the World.


Amish Abduction - Trailer
 
Top