Religious Education Forum  

Welcome Guest to ReligiousForums.com . You are currently not registered. When you become registered you will be able to interact with our large base of already registered users discussing topics. Some annoying Ads will also disappear when you register. Registering doesn't cost a thing and only takes a few seconds. We provide areas to chat and debate all World Religions. Please go to our register page!
Home Who's Online Today's Posts Mark Forums Read
Go Back   Religious Education Forum / Religious Topics / Religious Debates / Same Faith Debates
Reload this Page Non-Theists: Reasonable Theism?
Sitemap Popular RF Forums REGISTER Search Mark Forums Read

Reply
Page 3 of 4 < 123 4 >
 
Thread Tools Display Modes
  #21  
Old 05-27-2009, 08:53 AM
Kilgore Trout's Avatar
Kilgore Trout Offline
Religion: Misanthropic Humanist
Title:So It Goes...
Shield of The Jester: Awarded for unyielding commitment to humour and the entertainment of others - Issue reason:  Shield of 10,000 Thoughts: Awarded for contributing 10,000 posts - Issue reason: For posting prolifics. 
 
Join Date: Feb 2009
Gender: Male
Posts: 17,313
Frubals: 330817630
Kilgore Trout is trying to figure out a way to charge you a frubal fee for each postKilgore Trout is trying to figure out a way to charge you a frubal fee for each postKilgore Trout is trying to figure out a way to charge you a frubal fee for each postKilgore Trout is trying to figure out a way to charge you a frubal fee for each post
Kilgore Trout is trying to figure out a way to charge you a frubal fee for each postKilgore Trout is trying to figure out a way to charge you a frubal fee for each postKilgore Trout is trying to figure out a way to charge you a frubal fee for each postKilgore Trout is trying to figure out a way to charge you a frubal fee for each postKilgore Trout is trying to figure out a way to charge you a frubal fee for each postKilgore Trout is trying to figure out a way to charge you a frubal fee for each postKilgore Trout is trying to figure out a way to charge you a frubal fee for each postKilgore Trout is trying to figure out a way to charge you a frubal fee for each postKilgore Trout is trying to figure out a way to charge you a frubal fee for each postKilgore Trout is trying to figure out a way to charge you a frubal fee for each postKilgore Trout is trying to figure out a way to charge you a frubal fee for each postKilgore Trout is trying to figure out a way to charge you a frubal fee for each postKilgore Trout is trying to figure out a way to charge you a frubal fee for each postKilgore Trout is trying to figure out a way to charge you a frubal fee for each postKilgore Trout is trying to figure out a way to charge you a frubal fee for each postKilgore Trout is trying to figure out a way to charge you a frubal fee for each postKilgore Trout is trying to figure out a way to charge you a frubal fee for each postKilgore Trout is trying to figure out a way to charge you a frubal fee for each postKilgore Trout is trying to figure out a way to charge you a frubal fee for each postKilgore Trout is trying to figure out a way to charge you a frubal fee for each postKilgore Trout is trying to figure out a way to charge you a frubal fee for each postKilgore Trout is trying to figure out a way to charge you a frubal fee for each postKilgore Trout is trying to figure out a way to charge you a frubal fee for each postKilgore Trout is trying to figure out a way to charge you a frubal fee for each postKilgore Trout is trying to figure out a way to charge you a frubal fee for each postKilgore Trout is trying to figure out a way to charge you a frubal fee for each postKilgore Trout is trying to figure out a way to charge you a frubal fee for each postKilgore Trout is trying to figure out a way to charge you a frubal fee for each postKilgore Trout is trying to figure out a way to charge you a frubal fee for each postKilgore Trout is trying to figure out a way to charge you a frubal fee for each post
Default
Quote:
Originally Posted by Halcyon View Post
Forum Note - Same-Faith Debates.


Is there such a thing as a reasonable theistic belief system?


They're all generally reasonable when you understand the context and history of the religion and the people who follow it. Most religions would be reasonable for most people as they don't have a strong drive to question anything.

Quote:
Originally Posted by Halcyon View Post
Are all forms of theism equally irrational, or do some have more merit than others?
They are all irrational, yet some are more easily identifiable as such than others.
Reply With Quote
  #22  
Old 05-28-2009, 05:31 AM
ThereIsNoSpoon's Avatar
ThereIsNoSpoon Offline
Religion: None
Title:Junior Member
  
Join Date: Nov 2008
Location: Germany
Gender: Male
Posts: 690
Frubals: 1458969
ThereIsNoSpoon likes the look on kids' faces when you tell them their frubals are falling offThereIsNoSpoon likes the look on kids' faces when you tell them their frubals are falling offThereIsNoSpoon likes the look on kids' faces when you tell them their frubals are falling offThereIsNoSpoon likes the look on kids' faces when you tell them their frubals are falling offThereIsNoSpoon likes the look on kids' faces when you tell them their frubals are falling offThereIsNoSpoon likes the look on kids' faces when you tell them their frubals are falling offThereIsNoSpoon likes the look on kids' faces when you tell them their frubals are falling offThereIsNoSpoon likes the look on kids' faces when you tell them their frubals are falling offThereIsNoSpoon likes the look on kids' faces when you tell them their frubals are falling offThereIsNoSpoon likes the look on kids' faces when you tell them their frubals are falling offThereIsNoSpoon likes the look on kids' faces when you tell them their frubals are falling offThereIsNoSpoon likes the look on kids' faces when you tell them their frubals are falling offThereIsNoSpoon likes the look on kids' faces when you tell them their frubals are falling offThereIsNoSpoon likes the look on kids' faces when you tell them their frubals are falling offThereIsNoSpoon likes the look on kids' faces when you tell them their frubals are falling offThereIsNoSpoon likes the look on kids' faces when you tell them their frubals are falling offThereIsNoSpoon likes the look on kids' faces when you tell them their frubals are falling offThereIsNoSpoon likes the look on kids' faces when you tell them their frubals are falling offThereIsNoSpoon likes the look on kids' faces when you tell them their frubals are falling offThereIsNoSpoon likes the look on kids' faces when you tell them their frubals are falling offThereIsNoSpoon likes the look on kids' faces when you tell them their frubals are falling offThereIsNoSpoon likes the look on kids' faces when you tell them their frubals are falling off
Default
Quote:
Originally Posted by Halcyon View Post
Forum Note - Same-Faith Debates.


Is there such a thing as a reasonable theistic belief system? Are all forms of theism equally irrational, or do some have more merit than others?
I think theism can be reasonable within itself, which means that within the doctrines of the faith you can of course try to argue rationally.

The problem with theism in general is that the doctrines can't be argued about and therefor it is unreasonable from a less limited perspective.
Reply With Quote
  #23  
Old 05-28-2009, 05:39 AM
Jayhawker Soule's Avatar
Jayhawker Soule Offline
Religion: Judaism
Title:Exquisite Member
Shield of Knowledge: Awarded for outstanding demonstration of high knowledge in a particular field - Issue reason:  Shield of 20,000 Thoughts: Awarded for contributing 20,000 posts - Issue reason: For over 20,000 posts. Congrats Jay. :) 
 
Join Date: May 2004
Gender: Male
Posts: 23,817
Frubals: 13302749
Jayhawker Soule tries counting frubals to get to sleep but only ends up more aroused
Jayhawker Soule tries counting frubals to get to sleep but only ends up more arousedJayhawker Soule tries counting frubals to get to sleep but only ends up more arousedJayhawker Soule tries counting frubals to get to sleep but only ends up more arousedJayhawker Soule tries counting frubals to get to sleep but only ends up more arousedJayhawker Soule tries counting frubals to get to sleep but only ends up more arousedJayhawker Soule tries counting frubals to get to sleep but only ends up more arousedJayhawker Soule tries counting frubals to get to sleep but only ends up more arousedJayhawker Soule tries counting frubals to get to sleep but only ends up more arousedJayhawker Soule tries counting frubals to get to sleep but only ends up more arousedJayhawker Soule tries counting frubals to get to sleep but only ends up more arousedJayhawker Soule tries counting frubals to get to sleep but only ends up more arousedJayhawker Soule tries counting frubals to get to sleep but only ends up more arousedJayhawker Soule tries counting frubals to get to sleep but only ends up more arousedJayhawker Soule tries counting frubals to get to sleep but only ends up more arousedJayhawker Soule tries counting frubals to get to sleep but only ends up more arousedJayhawker Soule tries counting frubals to get to sleep but only ends up more arousedJayhawker Soule tries counting frubals to get to sleep but only ends up more arousedJayhawker Soule tries counting frubals to get to sleep but only ends up more arousedJayhawker Soule tries counting frubals to get to sleep but only ends up more arousedJayhawker Soule tries counting frubals to get to sleep but only ends up more arousedJayhawker Soule tries counting frubals to get to sleep but only ends up more arousedJayhawker Soule tries counting frubals to get to sleep but only ends up more arousedJayhawker Soule tries counting frubals to get to sleep but only ends up more arousedJayhawker Soule tries counting frubals to get to sleep but only ends up more aroused
Default
Quote:
Originally Posted by ThereIsNoSpoon View Post
The problem with theism in general is that the doctrines can't be argued about and therefor it is unreasonable from a less limited perspective.
Nonsense. These arguments and discussion go on all the time at various levels.
__________________
-- gadol kvod habriot --
Reply With Quote
  #24  
Old 05-28-2009, 07:43 AM
Smoke's Avatar
Smoke Offline
Title:Done here.
Shield of Knowledge: Awarded for outstanding demonstration of high knowledge in a particular field - Issue reason:  Shield of 10,000 Thoughts: Awarded for contributing 10,000 posts - Issue reason: You have achieved over 10,000 posts at RF. Congratulations!! 
 
Join Date: Aug 2005
Gender: Male
Posts: 19,902
Frubals: 80133091
Smoke holds up signs in violent demonstrations for frubal rightsSmoke holds up signs in violent demonstrations for frubal rightsSmoke holds up signs in violent demonstrations for frubal rights
Smoke holds up signs in violent demonstrations for frubal rightsSmoke holds up signs in violent demonstrations for frubal rightsSmoke holds up signs in violent demonstrations for frubal rightsSmoke holds up signs in violent demonstrations for frubal rightsSmoke holds up signs in violent demonstrations for frubal rightsSmoke holds up signs in violent demonstrations for frubal rightsSmoke holds up signs in violent demonstrations for frubal rightsSmoke holds up signs in violent demonstrations for frubal rightsSmoke holds up signs in violent demonstrations for frubal rightsSmoke holds up signs in violent demonstrations for frubal rightsSmoke holds up signs in violent demonstrations for frubal rightsSmoke holds up signs in violent demonstrations for frubal rightsSmoke holds up signs in violent demonstrations for frubal rightsSmoke holds up signs in violent demonstrations for frubal rightsSmoke holds up signs in violent demonstrations for frubal rightsSmoke holds up signs in violent demonstrations for frubal rightsSmoke holds up signs in violent demonstrations for frubal rightsSmoke holds up signs in violent demonstrations for frubal rightsSmoke holds up signs in violent demonstrations for frubal rightsSmoke holds up signs in violent demonstrations for frubal rightsSmoke holds up signs in violent demonstrations for frubal rightsSmoke holds up signs in violent demonstrations for frubal rightsSmoke holds up signs in violent demonstrations for frubal rightsSmoke holds up signs in violent demonstrations for frubal rightsSmoke holds up signs in violent demonstrations for frubal rightsSmoke holds up signs in violent demonstrations for frubal rightsSmoke holds up signs in violent demonstrations for frubal rightsSmoke holds up signs in violent demonstrations for frubal rightsSmoke holds up signs in violent demonstrations for frubal rightsSmoke holds up signs in violent demonstrations for frubal rights
Default
Quote:
Originally Posted by Halcyon View Post
Is there such a thing as a reasonable theistic belief system? Are all forms of theism equally irrational, or do some have more merit than others?
It seems quite obvious to me that not all theisms are created equal. I find some theisms very appealing -- though I don't find any of them convincing -- and the ability to be reasonable is a big part of what makes them appealing.
__________________


"If you don't believe that Puerto Rican Americans ought to be able to get married in this country, you are a bigot. If you don't think African Americans should be allowed in the military, you are a bigot. If you think it ought to be legal to refuse to hire Asian Americans, you are a bigot. And in case you're missing the point, there's only one group in America against whom the bigots are winning in all three areas."
-Michael Dixon
Reply With Quote
  #25  
Old 05-28-2009, 08:02 AM
ThereIsNoSpoon's Avatar
ThereIsNoSpoon Offline
Religion: None
Title:Junior Member
  
Join Date: Nov 2008
Location: Germany
Gender: Male
Posts: 690
Frubals: 1458969
ThereIsNoSpoon likes the look on kids' faces when you tell them their frubals are falling offThereIsNoSpoon likes the look on kids' faces when you tell them their frubals are falling offThereIsNoSpoon likes the look on kids' faces when you tell them their frubals are falling offThereIsNoSpoon likes the look on kids' faces when you tell them their frubals are falling offThereIsNoSpoon likes the look on kids' faces when you tell them their frubals are falling offThereIsNoSpoon likes the look on kids' faces when you tell them their frubals are falling offThereIsNoSpoon likes the look on kids' faces when you tell them their frubals are falling offThereIsNoSpoon likes the look on kids' faces when you tell them their frubals are falling offThereIsNoSpoon likes the look on kids' faces when you tell them their frubals are falling offThereIsNoSpoon likes the look on kids' faces when you tell them their frubals are falling offThereIsNoSpoon likes the look on kids' faces when you tell them their frubals are falling offThereIsNoSpoon likes the look on kids' faces when you tell them their frubals are falling offThereIsNoSpoon likes the look on kids' faces when you tell them their frubals are falling offThereIsNoSpoon likes the look on kids' faces when you tell them their frubals are falling offThereIsNoSpoon likes the look on kids' faces when you tell them their frubals are falling offThereIsNoSpoon likes the look on kids' faces when you tell them their frubals are falling offThereIsNoSpoon likes the look on kids' faces when you tell them their frubals are falling offThereIsNoSpoon likes the look on kids' faces when you tell them their frubals are falling offThereIsNoSpoon likes the look on kids' faces when you tell them their frubals are falling offThereIsNoSpoon likes the look on kids' faces when you tell them their frubals are falling offThereIsNoSpoon likes the look on kids' faces when you tell them their frubals are falling offThereIsNoSpoon likes the look on kids' faces when you tell them their frubals are falling off
Default
Quote:
Originally Posted by Jayhawker Soule View Post
Nonsense. These arguments and discussion go on all the time at various levels.
The fundamental belief cant be argued.
I havent seen any christian argue against the existence of God while staying/being a christian.
Reply With Quote
  #26  
Old 05-28-2009, 08:03 AM
Storm's Avatar
Storm Offline
Religion: Rogue Panentheist/ UU
Title:Proud Queer
Shield of Valour: Awarded for heroic and decisive victory in the battlefield of debate - Issue reason:  Shield of The Ambassador: Awarded for being a true herald of a belief system - Issue reason:  Shield of 40,000 Thoughts: Awarded for contributing 40,000 posts - Issue reason: That's a lot of posts! 
 
Join Date: Apr 2007
Location: Lubbock, TX (sigh)
Gender: Female
Posts: 43,770
Frubals: 35056681
Storm uses only the freshest cage-free frubalsStorm uses only the freshest cage-free frubalsStorm uses only the freshest cage-free frubals
Storm uses only the freshest cage-free frubalsStorm uses only the freshest cage-free frubalsStorm uses only the freshest cage-free frubalsStorm uses only the freshest cage-free frubalsStorm uses only the freshest cage-free frubalsStorm uses only the freshest cage-free frubalsStorm uses only the freshest cage-free frubalsStorm uses only the freshest cage-free frubalsStorm uses only the freshest cage-free frubalsStorm uses only the freshest cage-free frubalsStorm uses only the freshest cage-free frubalsStorm uses only the freshest cage-free frubalsStorm uses only the freshest cage-free frubalsStorm uses only the freshest cage-free frubalsStorm uses only the freshest cage-free frubalsStorm uses only the freshest cage-free frubalsStorm uses only the freshest cage-free frubalsStorm uses only the freshest cage-free frubalsStorm uses only the freshest cage-free frubalsStorm uses only the freshest cage-free frubalsStorm uses only the freshest cage-free frubalsStorm uses only the freshest cage-free frubalsStorm uses only the freshest cage-free frubalsStorm uses only the freshest cage-free frubalsStorm uses only the freshest cage-free frubals
Default
Quote:
Originally Posted by ThereIsNoSpoon View Post
The fundamental belief cant be argued.
I havent seen any christian argue against the existence of God while staying/being a christian.
I think Spong would qualify, but I don't know much about him. ETA: Of course, I'm not sure he can still be called a theist.
__________________
We do not fear the night, who have loved the stars so fondly.

Check out my shiny new blog, Knitting In Church!
Reply With Quote
  #27  
Old 05-28-2009, 08:10 AM
Nepenthe Offline
Religion: None-Strong Atheist
Title:Tu Stultus Es
Shield of The Jester: Awarded for unyielding commitment to humour and the entertainment of others - Issue reason:  
 
Join Date: Jan 2009
Location: Los Angeles
Gender: Male
Posts: 4,325
Frubals: 82263129
Nepenthe wonders why you would EVER question a frubalNepenthe wonders why you would EVER question a frubalNepenthe wonders why you would EVER question a frubalNepenthe wonders why you would EVER question a frubal
Nepenthe wonders why you would EVER question a frubalNepenthe wonders why you would EVER question a frubalNepenthe wonders why you would EVER question a frubalNepenthe wonders why you would EVER question a frubalNepenthe wonders why you would EVER question a frubalNepenthe wonders why you would EVER question a frubalNepenthe wonders why you would EVER question a frubalNepenthe wonders why you would EVER question a frubalNepenthe wonders why you would EVER question a frubalNepenthe wonders why you would EVER question a frubalNepenthe wonders why you would EVER question a frubalNepenthe wonders why you would EVER question a frubalNepenthe wonders why you would EVER question a frubalNepenthe wonders why you would EVER question a frubalNepenthe wonders why you would EVER question a frubalNepenthe wonders why you would EVER question a frubalNepenthe wonders why you would EVER question a frubalNepenthe wonders why you would EVER question a frubalNepenthe wonders why you would EVER question a frubalNepenthe wonders why you would EVER question a frubalNepenthe wonders why you would EVER question a frubalNepenthe wonders why you would EVER question a frubal
Default
Quote:
Originally Posted by Autodidact View Post
The universe is much greater than we understand or could ever understand. We do not know, and in all likelihood will never know, the ultimate mystery behind the universe, its true nature and causation, nor is it reasonable to think we would. When I look at the vast area beyond our understanding, my best guess about what that looks like is an unimaginably powerful and incomprehensible creative force or being, God. I acknowledge that I could be wrong, but that is my best guess, which I call "faith." I surmise that this force or being is in some way that I cannot understand, responsible for the entire universe, for the laws of physics that in turn created all life on this planet and many other wonders we will never know.
I agree that I'd consider such an interpretation reasonable yet unconvincing to myself. It's similar to variations of theism- I'm reminded of Martin Gardner, whose henotheism is simply that he believes 'cause it offers him comfort. He acknowledges the philosophical arguments for theism are unconvincing, and even that the classic atheist arguments are more convincing, he doesn't believe in an afterlife and is one of the prominent skeptics of the 20th century on pseudoscience and the supernatural. But he believes because it makes his appreciation of life that much better.

My wife's apatheism is reasonable as well. She simply finds the god subject so utterly irrelevant that if She did exist Her influence on the world is so irrelevant She might as well be perpetually absent. And if She doesn't exist, well then my wife lives her life the exact same way.

I also see Storm's ineffable pananetheism reasonable. I disagree that any of these are convincing to myself but I suppose that's besides the point. These variations of theism/panentheism are reasonably arrived conclusions that I just don't happen to share.
__________________

Last edited by Nepenthe; 05-28-2009 at 08:12 AM.. Reason: typos
Reply With Quote
  #28  
Old 05-30-2009, 09:05 PM
Autodidact's Avatar
Autodidact Offline
Religion: atheist
Title:Intentionally Blank
Shield of 20,000 Thoughts: Awarded for contributing 20,000 posts - Issue reason:  
 
Join Date: Jun 2007
Location: Denver
Gender: Female
Posts: 23,260
Frubals: 41140746
Autodidact bores visitors with stories and photographs of this vast frubal collectionAutodidact bores visitors with stories and photographs of this vast frubal collectionAutodidact bores visitors with stories and photographs of this vast frubal collectionAutodidact bores visitors with stories and photographs of this vast frubal collection
Autodidact bores visitors with stories and photographs of this vast frubal collectionAutodidact bores visitors with stories and photographs of this vast frubal collectionAutodidact bores visitors with stories and photographs of this vast frubal collectionAutodidact bores visitors with stories and photographs of this vast frubal collectionAutodidact bores visitors with stories and photographs of this vast frubal collectionAutodidact bores visitors with stories and photographs of this vast frubal collectionAutodidact bores visitors with stories and photographs of this vast frubal collectionAutodidact bores visitors with stories and photographs of this vast frubal collectionAutodidact bores visitors with stories and photographs of this vast frubal collectionAutodidact bores visitors with stories and photographs of this vast frubal collectionAutodidact bores visitors with stories and photographs of this vast frubal collectionAutodidact bores visitors with stories and photographs of this vast frubal collectionAutodidact bores visitors with stories and photographs of this vast frubal collectionAutodidact bores visitors with stories and photographs of this vast frubal collectionAutodidact bores visitors with stories and photographs of this vast frubal collectionAutodidact bores visitors with stories and photographs of this vast frubal collectionAutodidact bores visitors with stories and photographs of this vast frubal collectionAutodidact bores visitors with stories and photographs of this vast frubal collectionAutodidact bores visitors with stories and photographs of this vast frubal collectionAutodidact bores visitors with stories and photographs of this vast frubal collectionAutodidact bores visitors with stories and photographs of this vast frubal collection
Default
Quote:
Originally Posted by Storm View Post
Auto, you haven't actually answered this. I'm genuinely curious, and I won't be offended if you disapprove.
Well ineffable means it can't be expressed, right? So that seems kind of a conversation stopper. And isn't it contradictory to say on the one hand that God can't be expressed or described, and then start describing a specific pantheon. Wait, let me be more clear. If your basic thing is that God is ineffable, then why put any effort into "eff"ing God? You've already said it can't be done. What are you trying to accomplish?

An ineffable God makes me think again of a Deist type God, that may or may not exist, but if It does, has exactly zero effect on my life.

I mean, why can't people just put a question mark there and leave it at that? It seems dishonest to me when people start making assertions about something we couldn't possibly know. As soon as, for example, someone starts telling me what's going to happen after I die, I assume they're lying--they don't know any more than I do.

But more importantly, for me, "able to be perceived" is the functional equivalent of "exists." Or, to get all pretentious about it, epistemology is ontology. (I was a philosophy major once, centuries ago.)
__________________
Lighthouses are more useful than churches.
Benjamin Franklin
Reply With Quote
  #29  
Old 05-30-2009, 09:10 PM
Storm's Avatar
Storm Offline
Religion: Rogue Panentheist/ UU
Title:Proud Queer
Shield of Valour: Awarded for heroic and decisive victory in the battlefield of debate - Issue reason:  Shield of The Ambassador: Awarded for being a true herald of a belief system - Issue reason:  Shield of 40,000 Thoughts: Awarded for contributing 40,000 posts - Issue reason: That's a lot of posts! 
 
Join Date: Apr 2007
Location: Lubbock, TX (sigh)
Gender: Female
Posts: 43,770
Frubals: 35056681
Storm uses only the freshest cage-free frubalsStorm uses only the freshest cage-free frubalsStorm uses only the freshest cage-free frubals
Storm uses only the freshest cage-free frubalsStorm uses only the freshest cage-free frubalsStorm uses only the freshest cage-free frubalsStorm uses only the freshest cage-free frubalsStorm uses only the freshest cage-free frubalsStorm uses only the freshest cage-free frubalsStorm uses only the freshest cage-free frubalsStorm uses only the freshest cage-free frubalsStorm uses only the freshest cage-free frubalsStorm uses only the freshest cage-free frubalsStorm uses only the freshest cage-free frubalsStorm uses only the freshest cage-free frubalsStorm uses only the freshest cage-free frubalsStorm uses only the freshest cage-free frubalsStorm uses only the freshest cage-free frubalsStorm uses only the freshest cage-free frubalsStorm uses only the freshest cage-free frubalsStorm uses only the freshest cage-free frubalsStorm uses only the freshest cage-free frubalsStorm uses only the freshest cage-free frubalsStorm uses only the freshest cage-free frubalsStorm uses only the freshest cage-free frubalsStorm uses only the freshest cage-free frubalsStorm uses only the freshest cage-free frubalsStorm uses only the freshest cage-free frubals
Default
Quote:
Originally Posted by Autodidact View Post
Well ineffable means it can't be expressed, right? So that seems kind of a conversation stopper. And isn't it contradictory to say on the one hand that God can't be expressed or described, and then start describing a specific pantheon. Wait, let me be more clear. If your basic thing is that God is ineffable, then why put any effort into "eff"ing God? You've already said it can't be done. What are you trying to accomplish?
I just have to, it's a compulsion. And it's hard to obsess over something for 17 years and not come up with a few ideas.

Quote:
I mean, why can't people just put a question mark there and leave it at that?
When have people ever been satisfied with that? Never. We're curious animals, why should God be any different?

Quote:
It seems dishonest to me when people start making assertions about something we couldn't possibly know.
I think that's pushing it. How is it dishonest to say "We can never know for sure, but here's what I think"?
__________________
We do not fear the night, who have loved the stars so fondly.

Check out my shiny new blog, Knitting In Church!
Reply With Quote
  #30  
Old 05-30-2009, 10:10 PM
Autodidact's Avatar
Autodidact Offline
Religion: atheist
Title:Intentionally Blank
Shield of 20,000 Thoughts: Awarded for contributing 20,000 posts - Issue reason:  
 
Join Date: Jun 2007
Location: Denver
Gender: Female
Posts: 23,260
Frubals: 41140746
Autodidact bores visitors with stories and photographs of this vast frubal collectionAutodidact bores visitors with stories and photographs of this vast frubal collectionAutodidact bores visitors with stories and photographs of this vast frubal collectionAutodidact bores visitors with stories and photographs of this vast frubal collection
Autodidact bores visitors with stories and photographs of this vast frubal collectionAutodidact bores visitors with stories and photographs of this vast frubal collectionAutodidact bores visitors with stories and photographs of this vast frubal collectionAutodidact bores visitors with stories and photographs of this vast frubal collectionAutodidact bores visitors with stories and photographs of this vast frubal collectionAutodidact bores visitors with stories and photographs of this vast frubal collectionAutodidact bores visitors with stories and photographs of this vast frubal collectionAutodidact bores visitors with stories and photographs of this vast frubal collectionAutodidact bores visitors with stories and photographs of this vast frubal collectionAutodidact bores visitors with stories and photographs of this vast frubal collectionAutodidact bores visitors with stories and photographs of this vast frubal collectionAutodidact bores visitors with stories and photographs of this vast frubal collectionAutodidact bores visitors with stories and photographs of this vast frubal collectionAutodidact bores visitors with stories and photographs of this vast frubal collectionAutodidact bores visitors with stories and photographs of this vast frubal collectionAutodidact bores visitors with stories and photographs of this vast frubal collectionAutodidact bores visitors with stories and photographs of this vast frubal collectionAutodidact bores visitors with stories and photographs of this vast frubal collectionAutodidact bores visitors with stories and photographs of this vast frubal collectionAutodidact bores visitors with stories and photographs of this vast frubal collectionAutodidact bores visitors with stories and photographs of this vast frubal collection
Default
Quote:
Originally Posted by Storm View Post
I just have to, it's a compulsion. And it's hard to obsess over something for 17 years and not come up with a few ideas.


When have people ever been satisfied with that? Never. We're curious animals, why should God be any different?


I think that's pushing it. How is it dishonest to say "We can never know for sure, but here's what I think"?
Theists rarely do say that, do they? Rather they tend to say ridiculous things (overheard right here at RF) like, "We know that Jesus died to save us," or "I know that God condemns homosexuality," or "I believe there was a global flood because of my faith." Or they just make assertions, like, "When you die, you'll find out about my God." (which like I said lets me know they're lying, because they have no idea what will happen when I die, and that seems the least likely possibility.) So, to come back to the thread, yes, a reasonable theism would have to be an agnostic theism.

In fact, if I did meet an agnostic theist, who said that faith was just their best attempt to connect the dots and squint, that they acknowledged the unlikelihood of their being right, but were just doing their best, and it looked like God to them, I would find that delightfully reasonable.
__________________
Lighthouses are more useful than churches.
Benjamin Franklin
Reply With Quote
Reply
Page 3 of 4 < 123 4 >

« Catholics: How do you reconcile these two positions? | Muslims ONLY: Types of Kufr »
Thread Tools
Display Modes
Linear Mode Linear Mode

Similar Threads



All times are GMT -6. The time now is 06:50 AM.

Contact Us - Religious Forums - Archive 1, 2, 3 - Top

Copyright © 2013 Advameg, Inc.

SEO by vBSEO ©2010, Crawlability, Inc.