Should Films Make Fun of the Bible?

[Trey of Diamonds]

I remember watching the "Life of Brian" when I was a teenager and my mother scowling at me from the kitchen, unwilling to tell me what I could and could not watch but more than willing to express her displeasure in my choices. Now we have a new Biblical comedy for todays generation, "Year One".

What are you thoughts about films like this? Blasphemy? Irreverent? Funny as hell?

'Year One' polishes forbidden fruit in comedic poke at the Bible
'Year One' polishes forbidden fruit in comedic poke at the Bible - CNN.com

NEW YORK (CNN) -- In the midst of the ongoing culture wars, can it be a good idea to put out a comedy about two Stone Age men who wander into the Bible?

Harold Ramis thinks so.

"Year One," which he directed, concerns two men -- played by Jack Black and Michael Cera -- who leave their home and, in their travels, meet biblical characters such as Cain, Abel, Abraham and Isaac. Among the locales: ancient Sodom, which "didn't seem worse than Las Vegas to me," Ramis told CNN.

"Year One" comes out Friday.

Ramis, whose writing and directing credits include "Groundhog Day" and "Analyze This," said it was time for a new biblical epic -- of sorts.

"No one had done this film for our generation," he told CNN. It's like, you know, when 'Animal House' [which Ramis co-wrote] came out, there were college films. Every generation had college films, but our generation didn't have one yet, and I don't know that our generation - this young, new generation of kids has a, you know, a sandal epic yet, and this is the one. This is for them."

Ramis rounded up a cast of comedians familiar to any watcher of Judd Apatow-produced movies -- no surprise, since Apatow is a producer of "Year One." Christopher Mintz-Plasse ("Superbad"), Horatio Sanz ("Saturday Night Live," "Step Brothers") and Bill Hader ("Tropic Thunder") all have parts.

"A lot of them were new to me," said Ramis. "[But] Jack knew them, Michael knew them, they were connected -- all connected through Judd Apatow, through 'Saturday Night Live' ... the comedy world is a club."

Black joked that everyone's a member of a secret society, requiring retinal scans, that meets "inside the O of the Hollywood sign -- the first O," he noted.

"All the projects are laid out on a table," he said. "And we talk generally about how we're gonna take over the planet, take over the comedy and keep a vise grip on it."
Black said he revels in the chance to find the humor in the Bible.

"That was the fun of this thing," he said. "It's like, we are going to have some fun with the Bible; you don't see it very often. It hasn't really been done since Monty Python days. 'Life of Brian.' "

However, the film could get more than it asked for. Films poking fun at the Bible -- or, indeed, treating the Bible with anything less than reverence -- have been the subject of protests and criticism.

"Life of Brian," the Python troupe's 1979 comedy about an assumed messiah that parodied the story of Jesus, was protested by clergy in the U.S. and banned outright in Ireland. French protesters threw Molotov cocktails into a Paris theater showing "The Last Temptation of Christ," Martin Scorsese's 1988 film version of Nikos Kazantzakis' novel.

More recently, Mel Gibson's "The Passion of the Christ," though a huge financial success, was criticized by some observers for alleged anti-Semitism, as well as its violence.

Ramis, who observed that a number of biblical films focus on the New Testament, said he deliberately chose to make the Old Testament his subject.

"I told people that I wanted to do for the Old Testament what Monty Python did for the Gospels," he said. "Which is just to kind of take a funny look and project a contemporary sensibility back to these treasured myths of Western civilization.
"It wasn't so much to attack any particular religion," he added. "I figure all religions are good. They all make sense on paper; it's just the exploitation of religion that's been a problem, by ... people using religion to justify war, or to justify government or, you know, 'God made me do it.' "

Ramis said one of his intentions with "Year One," which he co-wrote with "Office" writers Gene Stupnitsky and Lee Eisenberg, was to focus on people, not God. Paraphrasing the liberal clergyman and activist William Sloane Coffin, he said, God's not the event itself, but "God's in our reaction to the event."

"I wanted to do a film that kind of addressed these fundamental beliefs and urged people to take personal responsibility, no matter what they believe God is or isn't," Ramis said. "It's still up to us in the final analysis."

Which is not to say that the film skimps on its comedy -- and with Ramis, Black, Cera, Hank Azaria, David Cross and producer Judd Apatow ("The 40-Year-Old Virgin," "Superbad") around, there's no shortage of jokes.

"It's really just a good, dumb, broad comedy," Ramis told Entertainment Weekly.
Improvisation often played a role, said Cera and Black.

"We weren't locked to anything," Cera said. "It was a very honest set. If something wasn't working then we would address it."

"We got a lot of different options [from observers], and they were able to play with different options in the editing room. I thought it was a cool way to do it," said Black. "I've never done a movie like that -- and now I wanna do that on all my movies."

The handful of early reviews have been positive, and Ramis is pleased with the result. He's particularly happy the film was received warmly in the Sodom shooting location -- Sibley, located in northwest Louisiana, in the heart of the Bible Belt.

"It's funny, because Southern people living in the heart of the Bible belt, there's a Baptist church every 150 feet in that area, and here we are in Sodom, in the city of Sodom," he said. "And they just got into it, they enjoyed it so much."

[Falvlun]

I don't see why we can't poke fun at religion. It's a time honored way of getting to the heart of serious issues.

If someone finds it blasphemous, then they just shouldn't go see it.

[rojse]

I remember doing some research about Life of Brian. I loved the slogan that said that LOB was so good it was banned In Ireland.

From the previews, I have my doubts about whether "Year One" will have the insightful humour that Life of Brian had (it didn't even come across as a religious parody), but I hope to be proven wrong.

[BucephalusBB]

Originally Posted by Falvlun

I don't see why we can't poke fun at religion. It's a time honored way of getting to the heart of serious issues.

If someone finds it blasphemous, then they just shouldn't go see it.

I agree, and if people disagree with that, please, by all means, make fun of my atheism..

[Trey of Diamonds]

Originally Posted by Bouncing Ball

I agree, and if people disagree with that, please, by all means, make fun of my atheism..

You know, we should have a comedy about atheism. There has to be some great jokes in there somewhere.

[monta]

Originally Posted by Trey of Diamonds

I remember watching the "Life of Brian" when I was a teenager and my mother scowling at me from the kitchen, unwilling to tell me what I could and could not watch but more than willing to express her displeasure in my choices. Now we have a new Biblical comedy for todays generation, "Year One".

What are you thoughts about films like this? Blasphemy? Irreverent? Funny as hell?

lol my Mum banned Life of 'Brian' in our house, this was made easier by the fact it was banned in Ireland. My sister went to au pair in the UK and it was on TV and she fell of the sofa laughing at it , while the family she was living with looked on in chagrin.

I think maybe it wouldn't be as funny if it wasn't taboo. If people were less sensitive to religious parody in film, the films wouldn't get made, year one has to be a lot less offensive then some films made about religion that weren't made for laughs.

[rojse]

Originally Posted by Trey of Diamonds

You know, we should have a comedy about atheism. There has to be some great jokes in there somewhere.

Go God Go - Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia

Thank you, South Park.

[Storm]

Year One looks painfully stupid, but I loved Life Of Brian and Dogma. Religion is fair game in my book.

[Engyo]

My question is whether these films are about the Bible itself, or about the ways in which people interpret, explain, understand and otherwise interact with the Bible'?

[Trey of Diamonds]

Originally Posted by Engyo

My question is whether these films are about the Bible itself, or about the ways in which people interpret, explain, understand and otherwise interact with the Bible'?

From the article.

Ramis said one of his intentions with "Year One," which he co-wrote with "Office" writers Gene Stupnitsky and Lee Eisenberg, was to focus on people, not God. Paraphrasing the liberal clergyman and activist William Sloane Coffin, he said, God's not the event itself, but "God's in our reaction to the event."

So I would say its about peoples interpretation.