Religious Education Forum  

Welcome to Religious Forums
Welcome Guest to ReligiousForums.com . You are currently not registered. When you become registered you will be able to interact with our large base of already registered users discussing topics. Some annoying Ads will also disappear when you register. Registering doesn't cost a thing and only takes a few seconds. We provide areas to chat and debate all World Religions. Please go to our register page!

Home Who's Online Today's Posts Mark Forums Read
Go Back   Religious Education Forum / Religious Topics / Religious Debates
Sitemap Popular RF Forums REGISTER Search Mark Forums Read

Reply
 
Thread Tools Display Modes
  #1  
Old 07-12-2008, 02:06 PM
spiritually inclined's Avatar
spiritually inclined Offline
Religion: N/A - AtheistHumanist
Title:Junior Member
 
Join Date: Jun 2007
Location: USA
Gender: Male
Posts: 613
Frubals: 186320
spiritually inclined has a reputation beyond reputespiritually inclined has a reputation beyond reputespiritually inclined has a reputation beyond reputespiritually inclined has a reputation beyond reputespiritually inclined has a reputation beyond reputespiritually inclined has a reputation beyond reputespiritually inclined has a reputation beyond reputespiritually inclined has a reputation beyond repute
spiritually inclined has a reputation beyond reputespiritually inclined has a reputation beyond reputespiritually inclined has a reputation beyond reputespiritually inclined has a reputation beyond reputespiritually inclined has a reputation beyond reputespiritually inclined has a reputation beyond reputespiritually inclined has a reputation beyond reputespiritually inclined has a reputation beyond reputespiritually inclined has a reputation beyond reputespiritually inclined has a reputation beyond reputespiritually inclined has a reputation beyond reputespiritually inclined has a reputation beyond reputespiritually inclined has a reputation beyond reputespiritually inclined has a reputation beyond reputespiritually inclined has a reputation beyond reputespiritually inclined has a reputation beyond reputespiritually inclined has a reputation beyond reputespiritually inclined has a reputation beyond reputespiritually inclined has a reputation beyond reputespiritually inclined has a reputation beyond reputespiritually inclined has a reputation beyond reputespiritually inclined has a reputation beyond reputespiritually inclined has a reputation beyond reputespiritually inclined has a reputation beyond reputespiritually inclined has a reputation beyond reputespiritually inclined has a reputation beyond reputespiritually inclined has a reputation beyond reputespiritually inclined has a reputation beyond repute
Default Should Liberal Christians Leave Organized Religion?

Is there any point in hoping for a reformation of Christianity? Should progressive Christians who approach religion from a metaphorical, community-oriented point of view just give up on organized religion? Is there any point in organized religion?

James
Reply With Quote
  #2  
Old 07-12-2008, 02:27 PM
tomspug's Avatar
tomspug Offline
Religion: Christianity
Title:A Child Inside
 
Join Date: Dec 2007
Location: Roseville, CA
Gender: Male
Posts: 3,221
Frubals: 1647253
tomspug is a Frubal Whoretomspug is a Frubal Whoretomspug is a Frubal Whoretomspug is a Frubal Whore
tomspug is a Frubal Whoretomspug is a Frubal Whoretomspug is a Frubal Whoretomspug is a Frubal Whoretomspug is a Frubal Whoretomspug is a Frubal Whoretomspug is a Frubal Whoretomspug is a Frubal Whoretomspug is a Frubal Whoretomspug is a Frubal Whoretomspug is a Frubal Whoretomspug is a Frubal Whore
tomspug is a Frubal Whoretomspug is a Frubal Whoretomspug is a Frubal Whoretomspug is a Frubal Whoretomspug is a Frubal Whoretomspug is a Frubal Whoretomspug is a Frubal Whoretomspug is a Frubal Whoretomspug is a Frubal Whoretomspug is a Frubal Whoretomspug is a Frubal Whoretomspug is a Frubal Whoretomspug is a Frubal Whoretomspug is a Frubal Whoretomspug is a Frubal Whoretomspug is a Frubal Whoretomspug is a Frubal Whoretomspug is a Frubal Whoretomspug is a Frubal Whoretomspug is a Frubal Whoretomspug is a Frubal Whoretomspug is a Frubal Whoretomspug is a Frubal Whoretomspug is a Frubal Whoretomspug is a Frubal Whoretomspug is a Frubal Whoretomspug is a Frubal Whore
Default

What does 'leaving organized religion' mean? Even if you left it, you would still find people with similar beliefs, inevitably creating a new denomination.
__________________
Did you read the OP?
Reply With Quote
  #3  
Old 07-12-2008, 03:02 PM
spiritually inclined's Avatar
spiritually inclined Offline
Religion: N/A - AtheistHumanist
Title:Junior Member
 
Join Date: Jun 2007
Location: USA
Gender: Male
Posts: 613
Frubals: 186320
spiritually inclined has a reputation beyond reputespiritually inclined has a reputation beyond reputespiritually inclined has a reputation beyond reputespiritually inclined has a reputation beyond reputespiritually inclined has a reputation beyond reputespiritually inclined has a reputation beyond reputespiritually inclined has a reputation beyond reputespiritually inclined has a reputation beyond repute
spiritually inclined has a reputation beyond reputespiritually inclined has a reputation beyond reputespiritually inclined has a reputation beyond reputespiritually inclined has a reputation beyond reputespiritually inclined has a reputation beyond reputespiritually inclined has a reputation beyond reputespiritually inclined has a reputation beyond reputespiritually inclined has a reputation beyond reputespiritually inclined has a reputation beyond reputespiritually inclined has a reputation beyond reputespiritually inclined has a reputation beyond reputespiritually inclined has a reputation beyond reputespiritually inclined has a reputation beyond reputespiritually inclined has a reputation beyond reputespiritually inclined has a reputation beyond reputespiritually inclined has a reputation beyond reputespiritually inclined has a reputation beyond reputespiritually inclined has a reputation beyond reputespiritually inclined has a reputation beyond reputespiritually inclined has a reputation beyond reputespiritually inclined has a reputation beyond reputespiritually inclined has a reputation beyond reputespiritually inclined has a reputation beyond reputespiritually inclined has a reputation beyond reputespiritually inclined has a reputation beyond reputespiritually inclined has a reputation beyond reputespiritually inclined has a reputation beyond reputespiritually inclined has a reputation beyond repute
Default

Quote:
What does 'leaving organized religion' mean? Even if you left it, you would still find people with similar beliefs, inevitably creating a new denomination.
I've met lots of people with similar beliefs to my own without forming my own denomination. Why would I do that?

Leaving organized religion means just that -- deciding to exist outside of organized religion. No membership. No involvement.

James
Reply With Quote
  #4  
Old 07-12-2008, 03:18 PM
d3vaLL's Avatar
d3vaLL Offline
Religion: Humanism
Title:Freshman Member
 
Join Date: Jun 2008
Location: Alabama
Gender: Male
Posts: 95
Frubals: 91786
d3vaLL has a brilliant futured3vaLL has a brilliant futured3vaLL has a brilliant futured3vaLL has a brilliant future
d3vaLL has a brilliant futured3vaLL has a brilliant futured3vaLL has a brilliant futured3vaLL has a brilliant futured3vaLL has a brilliant futured3vaLL has a brilliant futured3vaLL has a brilliant futured3vaLL has a brilliant futured3vaLL has a brilliant futured3vaLL has a brilliant futured3vaLL has a brilliant futured3vaLL has a brilliant futured3vaLL has a brilliant futured3vaLL has a brilliant futured3vaLL has a brilliant futured3vaLL has a brilliant futured3vaLL has a brilliant futured3vaLL has a brilliant future
Default

This is why I stopped going to church in the first place. So many interpretations and opinions by those of one domination, through ignorance, arrogance, misinformation and secular ethics, what is different then meeting up with a bunch of guys at dinner and discussing the same topics?

Admittedly, part of my dissent is due to my agnosticism. I don't believe anyone knows anything absolute about anything. It's a copout. Any attempt at establishing a stance for yourself through an idea eliminates any growth in understanding through others anyway. What is the point?
__________________
"Epiphany requires no action, no declaration, no enthusiasm, no emotion, no mention and no memory." ~ Some drunk guy I heard
Reply With Quote
  #5  
Old 07-12-2008, 03:30 PM
DallasApple's Avatar
DallasApple Online!
Religion: Christian
Title:Depends Upon My Mood..
Kindness Award:  - Issue reason: This award has been given to you by your peers and is well deserved. 
 
Join Date: Dec 2007
Location: Dallas
Gender: Female
Posts: 5,686
Frubals: 3555715
DallasApple is a Frubal WhoreDallasApple is a Frubal WhoreDallasApple is a Frubal WhoreDallasApple is a Frubal WhoreDallasApple is a Frubal WhoreDallasApple is a Frubal WhoreDallasApple is a Frubal WhoreDallasApple is a Frubal WhoreDallasApple is a Frubal WhoreDallasApple is a Frubal Whore
DallasApple is a Frubal WhoreDallasApple is a Frubal WhoreDallasApple is a Frubal WhoreDallasApple is a Frubal WhoreDallasApple is a Frubal Whore
DallasApple is a Frubal WhoreDallasApple is a Frubal WhoreDallasApple is a Frubal WhoreDallasApple is a Frubal WhoreDallasApple is a Frubal WhoreDallasApple is a Frubal WhoreDallasApple is a Frubal WhoreDallasApple is a Frubal WhoreDallasApple is a Frubal WhoreDallasApple is a Frubal WhoreDallasApple is a Frubal WhoreDallasApple is a Frubal WhoreDallasApple is a Frubal WhoreDallasApple is a Frubal WhoreDallasApple is a Frubal WhoreDallasApple is a Frubal WhoreDallasApple is a Frubal WhoreDallasApple is a Frubal WhoreDallasApple is a Frubal WhoreDallasApple is a Frubal WhoreDallasApple is a Frubal WhoreDallasApple is a Frubal Whore
Default

Hmmm...

I guess it depends if the "organization" is helping people..I mean really helping people with their efforts..In all the ways..Not condemning..Just helping people..

Love

Dallas
__________________
At this point..? Im at a loss for signature words..
Reply With Quote
  #6  
Old 07-12-2008, 03:35 PM
stephenw's Avatar
stephenw Offline
Religion: Gnostic Christian
Title:Arthur Dent wannabe
 
Join Date: Nov 2007
Location: Ireland
Gender: Male
Posts: 2,992
Frubals: 2662640
stephenw is a Frubal Whorestephenw is a Frubal Whorestephenw is a Frubal Whorestephenw is a Frubal Whorestephenw is a Frubal Whorestephenw is a Frubal Whorestephenw is a Frubal Whore
stephenw is a Frubal Whorestephenw is a Frubal Whorestephenw is a Frubal Whorestephenw is a Frubal Whorestephenw is a Frubal Whorestephenw is a Frubal Whorestephenw is a Frubal Whorestephenw is a Frubal Whorestephenw is a Frubal Whorestephenw is a Frubal Whorestephenw is a Frubal Whore
stephenw is a Frubal Whorestephenw is a Frubal Whorestephenw is a Frubal Whorestephenw is a Frubal Whorestephenw is a Frubal Whorestephenw is a Frubal Whorestephenw is a Frubal Whorestephenw is a Frubal Whorestephenw is a Frubal Whorestephenw is a Frubal Whorestephenw is a Frubal Whorestephenw is a Frubal Whorestephenw is a Frubal Whorestephenw is a Frubal Whorestephenw is a Frubal Whorestephenw is a Frubal Whorestephenw is a Frubal Whorestephenw is a Frubal Whorestephenw is a Frubal Whorestephenw is a Frubal Whorestephenw is a Frubal Whorestephenw is a Frubal Whorestephenw is a Frubal Whorestephenw is a Frubal Whorestephenw is a Frubal Whorestephenw is a Frubal Whorestephenw is a Frubal Whorestephenw is a Frubal Whorestephenw is a Frubal Whorestephenw is a Frubal Whorestephenw is a Frubal Whorestephenw is a Frubal Whore
Default

I'd like an organisation where I could go to debate, discuss and learn. Kind of like a real life version of this place.
__________________
Reply With Quote
  #7  
Old 07-12-2008, 03:41 PM
Terrywoodenpic's Avatar
Terrywoodenpic Offline
Religion: Anglican-heretic
Title:Oldest Heretic
Kindness Award:  - Issue reason: The kindness award has been given to you by your peers and is well deserved.  Congrats. 
 
Join Date: Jun 2005
Location: UK
Gender: Male
Posts: 6,026
Frubals: 571672
Terrywoodenpic thinks frubals grow on trees
Terrywoodenpic thinks frubals grow on treesTerrywoodenpic thinks frubals grow on treesTerrywoodenpic thinks frubals grow on treesTerrywoodenpic thinks frubals grow on treesTerrywoodenpic thinks frubals grow on treesTerrywoodenpic thinks frubals grow on treesTerrywoodenpic thinks frubals grow on treesTerrywoodenpic thinks frubals grow on treesTerrywoodenpic thinks frubals grow on treesTerrywoodenpic thinks frubals grow on trees
Terrywoodenpic thinks frubals grow on treesTerrywoodenpic thinks frubals grow on treesTerrywoodenpic thinks frubals grow on treesTerrywoodenpic thinks frubals grow on treesTerrywoodenpic thinks frubals grow on treesTerrywoodenpic thinks frubals grow on treesTerrywoodenpic thinks frubals grow on treesTerrywoodenpic thinks frubals grow on treesTerrywoodenpic thinks frubals grow on treesTerrywoodenpic thinks frubals grow on treesTerrywoodenpic thinks frubals grow on treesTerrywoodenpic thinks frubals grow on treesTerrywoodenpic thinks frubals grow on treesTerrywoodenpic thinks frubals grow on treesTerrywoodenpic thinks frubals grow on treesTerrywoodenpic thinks frubals grow on treesTerrywoodenpic thinks frubals grow on treesTerrywoodenpic thinks frubals grow on treesTerrywoodenpic thinks frubals grow on treesTerrywoodenpic thinks frubals grow on treesTerrywoodenpic thinks frubals grow on treesTerrywoodenpic thinks frubals grow on treesTerrywoodenpic thinks frubals grow on treesTerrywoodenpic thinks frubals grow on treesTerrywoodenpic thinks frubals grow on treesTerrywoodenpic thinks frubals grow on treesTerrywoodenpic thinks frubals grow on trees
Default

A liberal Christian is not necessarily progressive, nor a progressive Christian a liberal one.
It is difficult but not impossible to be a practising Christian out side a church.

Even a heretic like myself finds comfort and strength amongst others how ever few.
The Anglican faith is a very broad church... some might say a church of misfits.

It is a church that functions best through common practices rather than dogma.
__________________
Blessed are those who bring peace, they shall be children of God
Amen! Truly I say to you: Gather in my name. I am with you.
Reply With Quote
  #8  
Old 07-12-2008, 04:03 PM
d3vaLL's Avatar
d3vaLL Offline
Religion: Humanism
Title:Freshman Member
 
Join Date: Jun 2008
Location: Alabama
Gender: Male
Posts: 95
Frubals: 91786
d3vaLL has a brilliant futured3vaLL has a brilliant futured3vaLL has a brilliant futured3vaLL has a brilliant future
d3vaLL has a brilliant futured3vaLL has a brilliant futured3vaLL has a brilliant futured3vaLL has a brilliant futured3vaLL has a brilliant futured3vaLL has a brilliant futured3vaLL has a brilliant futured3vaLL has a brilliant futured3vaLL has a brilliant futured3vaLL has a brilliant futured3vaLL has a brilliant futured3vaLL has a brilliant futured3vaLL has a brilliant futured3vaLL has a brilliant futured3vaLL has a brilliant futured3vaLL has a brilliant futured3vaLL has a brilliant futured3vaLL has a brilliant future
Default

Quote:
Originally Posted by Terrywoodenpic View Post
It is a church that functions best through common practices rather than dogma.
Is it not then, similar to a social club in its primary function? (honest question, not being smug)
__________________
"Epiphany requires no action, no declaration, no enthusiasm, no emotion, no mention and no memory." ~ Some drunk guy I heard
Reply With Quote
  #9  
Old 07-12-2008, 04:21 PM
Terrywoodenpic's Avatar
Terrywoodenpic Offline
Religion: Anglican-heretic
Title:Oldest Heretic
Kindness Award:  - Issue reason: The kindness award has been given to you by your peers and is well deserved.  Congrats. 
 
Join Date: Jun 2005
Location: UK
Gender: Male
Posts: 6,026
Frubals: 571672
Terrywoodenpic thinks frubals grow on trees
Terrywoodenpic thinks frubals grow on treesTerrywoodenpic thinks frubals grow on treesTerrywoodenpic thinks frubals grow on treesTerrywoodenpic thinks frubals grow on treesTerrywoodenpic thinks frubals grow on treesTerrywoodenpic thinks frubals grow on treesTerrywoodenpic thinks frubals grow on treesTerrywoodenpic thinks frubals grow on treesTerrywoodenpic thinks frubals grow on treesTerrywoodenpic thinks frubals grow on trees
Terrywoodenpic thinks frubals grow on treesTerrywoodenpic thinks frubals grow on treesTerrywoodenpic thinks frubals grow on treesTerrywoodenpic thinks frubals grow on treesTerrywoodenpic thinks frubals grow on treesTerrywoodenpic thinks frubals grow on treesTerrywoodenpic thinks frubals grow on treesTerrywoodenpic thinks frubals grow on treesTerrywoodenpic thinks frubals grow on treesTerrywoodenpic thinks frubals grow on treesTerrywoodenpic thinks frubals grow on treesTerrywoodenpic thinks frubals grow on treesTerrywoodenpic thinks frubals grow on treesTerrywoodenpic thinks frubals grow on treesTerrywoodenpic thinks frubals grow on treesTerrywoodenpic thinks frubals grow on treesTerrywoodenpic thinks frubals grow on treesTerrywoodenpic thinks frubals grow on treesTerrywoodenpic thinks frubals grow on treesTerrywoodenpic thinks frubals grow on treesTerrywoodenpic thinks frubals grow on treesTerrywoodenpic thinks frubals grow on treesTerrywoodenpic thinks frubals grow on treesTerrywoodenpic thinks frubals grow on treesTerrywoodenpic thinks frubals grow on treesTerrywoodenpic thinks frubals grow on treesTerrywoodenpic thinks frubals grow on trees
Default

Quote:
Originally Posted by d3vaLL View Post
Is it not then, similar to a social club in its primary function? (honest question, not being smug)
Not at all... it implies the Church is worship based , rather than spending its time arguing the minutiae of dogma.
It knows that its extremities have widely differing attitudes, but that they can all still worship Jesus together in love.

Over several hundred years many churches have split from it, and in the future many more will probably do so still. However the church of God continues to grow in its many parts.
__________________
Blessed are those who bring peace, they shall be children of God
Amen! Truly I say to you: Gather in my name. I am with you.
Reply With Quote
  #10  
Old 07-12-2008, 05:29 PM
lunamoth's Avatar
lunamoth Offline
Religion: Episcopalian
Title:Will to Love
Courtesy Award:  - Issue reason: This award had been given to you by your peers and is well deserved.