Religious Education Forum  

Welcome to Religious Forums
Welcome Guest to ReligiousForums.com . You are currently not registered. When you become registered you will be able to interact with our large base of already registered users discussing topics. Some annoying Ads will also disappear when you register. Registering doesn't cost a thing and only takes a few seconds. We provide areas to chat and debate all World Religions. Please go to our register page!

Home Who's Online Today's Posts Mark Forums Read
Go Back   Religious Education Forum / Religious Topics / Religious Debates
Sitemap Popular RF Forums REGISTER Search Mark Forums Read

Reply
 
Thread Tools Display Modes
  #61  
Old 07-13-2008, 07:39 PM
DeepShadow's Avatar
DeepShadow Offline
Religion: Christian (LDS)
Title:White Crow
Scholarship Award:  - Issue reason: This award has been given to you by your peers and is well deserved.   Congratulations! Ambassador Award: Award designated for members who show great knowledge of their religion. - Issue reason: You are the first person to receive this award.  This has been given to you by your peers and is well deserved. Courtesy Award:  - Issue reason:  
 
Join Date: Jun 2004
Location: Florida
Gender: Male
Posts: 2,495
Frubals: 278218
DeepShadow eats frubals for breakfastDeepShadow eats frubals for breakfastDeepShadow eats frubals for breakfastDeepShadow eats frubals for breakfastDeepShadow eats frubals for breakfastDeepShadow eats frubals for breakfastDeepShadow eats frubals for breakfastDeepShadow eats frubals for breakfastDeepShadow eats frubals for breakfastDeepShadow eats frubals for breakfastDeepShadow eats frubals for breakfastDeepShadow eats frubals for breakfast
DeepShadow eats frubals for breakfastDeepShadow eats frubals for breakfastDeepShadow eats frubals for breakfastDeepShadow eats frubals for breakfastDeepShadow eats frubals for breakfastDeepShadow eats frubals for breakfastDeepShadow eats frubals for breakfastDeepShadow eats frubals for breakfastDeepShadow eats frubals for breakfastDeepShadow eats frubals for breakfastDeepShadow eats frubals for breakfastDeepShadow eats frubals for breakfastDeepShadow eats frubals for breakfastDeepShadow eats frubals for breakfastDeepShadow eats frubals for breakfastDeepShadow eats frubals for breakfastDeepShadow eats frubals for breakfastDeepShadow eats frubals for breakfastDeepShadow eats frubals for breakfastDeepShadow eats frubals for breakfastDeepShadow eats frubals for breakfastDeepShadow eats frubals for breakfastDeepShadow eats frubals for breakfastDeepShadow eats frubals for breakfastDeepShadow eats frubals for breakfastDeepShadow eats frubals for breakfastDeepShadow eats frubals for breakfastDeepShadow eats frubals for breakfastDeepShadow eats frubals for breakfastDeepShadow eats frubals for breakfastDeepShadow eats frubals for breakfastDeepShadow eats frubals for breakfastDeepShadow eats frubals for breakfastDeepShadow eats frubals for breakfast
Default

Free agency is internal, not external. I can take away the fork and block the outlet, to use BalanceFX's example, but none of this interferes with the child's internal self-will.

But what happens when my children grow up and decide they know better? They go away to college and think that forks and outlets would be fun to play with? We have the power to throw God out of our lives, and the consequences of that can have collateral damage.
__________________
Brain-Trainers--Work those lobes, flex those synapses!

Votever hyu say, meester "I'm so schmot I don't gotta make sense." --Commander Vole, from Girl Genius
Reply With Quote
  #62  
Old 07-13-2008, 07:53 PM
BalanceFx's Avatar
BalanceFx Offline
Religion: Atheist
Title:Non-Theist
 
Join Date: May 2008
Location: USA
Gender: Male
Posts: 1,190
Frubals: 637794
BalanceFx thinks frubals grow on trees
BalanceFx thinks frubals grow on treesBalanceFx thinks frubals grow on treesBalanceFx thinks frubals grow on treesBalanceFx thinks frubals grow on treesBalanceFx thinks frubals grow on treesBalanceFx thinks frubals grow on treesBalanceFx thinks frubals grow on treesBalanceFx thinks frubals grow on treesBalanceFx thinks frubals grow on treesBalanceFx thinks frubals grow on treesBalanceFx thinks frubals grow on treesBalanceFx thinks frubals grow on treesBalanceFx thinks frubals grow on trees
BalanceFx thinks frubals grow on treesBalanceFx thinks frubals grow on treesBalanceFx thinks frubals grow on treesBalanceFx thinks frubals grow on treesBalanceFx thinks frubals grow on treesBalanceFx thinks frubals grow on treesBalanceFx thinks frubals grow on treesBalanceFx thinks frubals grow on treesBalanceFx thinks frubals grow on treesBalanceFx thinks frubals grow on treesBalanceFx thinks frubals grow on treesBalanceFx thinks frubals grow on treesBalanceFx thinks frubals grow on treesBalanceFx thinks frubals grow on treesBalanceFx thinks frubals grow on treesBalanceFx thinks frubals grow on treesBalanceFx thinks frubals grow on treesBalanceFx thinks frubals grow on treesBalanceFx thinks frubals grow on treesBalanceFx thinks frubals grow on treesBalanceFx thinks frubals grow on treesBalanceFx thinks frubals grow on treesBalanceFx thinks frubals grow on treesBalanceFx thinks frubals grow on treesBalanceFx thinks frubals grow on treesBalanceFx thinks frubals grow on treesBalanceFx thinks frubals grow on treesBalanceFx thinks frubals grow on trees
Default

Quote:
Originally Posted by DeepShadow View Post
Free agency is internal, not external. I can take away the fork and block the outlet, to use BalanceFX's example, but none of this interferes with the child's internal self-will.

But what happens when my children grow up and decide they know better? They go away to college and think that forks and outlets would be fun to play with? We have the power to throw God out of our lives, and the consequences of that can have collateral damage.
But I didnt invalidate my sons free will and justify it with because I said so. I explained it when he got older at length. He has science kits all over the place and has built motion sensors and RC cars. (Even a solar propellar car)

When he decides for himself - he will be able to do so with real examples of what exists.

And the throwing of gods out of one life... That makes a presupposition that god was ever there in the first place and is irrelavant to the point your arguing.

If I as a parent have no problem violating free agency of my children until they know for themselves and can make their own decisions why doesnt god do the same. My motivation is out of love.

You said he can prevent wars but he hasnt prevented them all, but he cant affect free agency. Why? And where in the bible or the BoM does it say that god cant violate free agency?
Reply With Quote
  #63  
Old 07-13-2008, 07:58 PM
BalanceFx's Avatar
BalanceFx Offline
Religion: Atheist
Title:Non-Theist
 
Join Date: May 2008
Location: USA
Gender: Male
Posts: 1,190
Frubals: 637794
BalanceFx thinks frubals grow on trees
BalanceFx thinks frubals grow on treesBalanceFx thinks frubals grow on treesBalanceFx thinks frubals grow on treesBalanceFx thinks frubals grow on treesBalanceFx thinks frubals grow on treesBalanceFx thinks frubals grow on treesBalanceFx thinks frubals grow on treesBalanceFx thinks frubals grow on treesBalanceFx thinks frubals grow on treesBalanceFx thinks frubals grow on treesBalanceFx thinks frubals grow on treesBalanceFx thinks frubals grow on treesBalanceFx thinks frubals grow on trees
BalanceFx thinks frubals grow on treesBalanceFx thinks frubals grow on treesBalanceFx thinks frubals grow on treesBalanceFx thinks frubals grow on treesBalanceFx thinks frubals grow on treesBalanceFx thinks frubals grow on treesBalanceFx thinks frubals grow on treesBalanceFx thinks frubals grow on treesBalanceFx thinks frubals grow on treesBalanceFx thinks frubals grow on treesBalanceFx thinks frubals grow on treesBalanceFx thinks frubals grow on treesBalanceFx thinks frubals grow on treesBalanceFx thinks frubals grow on treesBalanceFx thinks frubals grow on treesBalanceFx thinks frubals grow on treesBalanceFx thinks frubals grow on treesBalanceFx thinks frubals grow on treesBalanceFx thinks frubals grow on treesBalanceFx thinks frubals grow on treesBalanceFx thinks frubals grow on treesBalanceFx thinks frubals grow on treesBalanceFx thinks frubals grow on treesBalanceFx thinks frubals grow on treesBalanceFx thinks frubals grow on treesBalanceFx thinks frubals grow on treesBalanceFx thinks frubals grow on treesBalanceFx thinks frubals grow on trees
Default

Quote:
Originally Posted by DisneyMan View Post
And will you make sure their entire lives that they won't make any mistakes?
  • First I am incapable of making sure.
  • Second I will not be here for their entire lives. (Hopefully right?)
  • Third No, mistakes are the fastest way to learn the solution, your own solution which may be quite different. (Obviously some mistakes dont want to make. Outlets and forks is one of those)
  • Fourth, Because I said So, is not a valid justification in my house for me or mom.
Reply With Quote
Reply



Thread Tools
Display Modes

Similar Threads


Similar Threads


All times are GMT -6. The time now is 06:40 PM.


© 2008 Advameg, Inc.

SEO by vBSEO ©2007, Crawlability, Inc.