[NON-CHRISTIANS] Does the trinity or three seperate beings make more sense? (God)

[Bishka]

To all the non-Christians on the forums, which makes more sense in your mind, the idea of the trinity of that they are three seperate beings?

This is not to debate whether they are real or not, but why does one or the other make more sense?

[Gentoo]

They both make sense to me, I don't know if one concept makes more sense than the other to me. But if I had to choose for the sake of debate, I would say that the trinity makes more sense than having them be three separate beings.

[Bishka]

Originally Posted by Gentoo

They both make sense to me, I don't know if one concept makes more sense than the other to me. But if I had to choose for the sake of debate, I would say that the trinity makes more sense than having them be three separate beings.

Why is that?

[linwood]

Originally Posted by beckysoup61

Why is that?

What she said.

The Christian concept of the trinity has eluded my understanding for decades.

[Gentoo]

Originally Posted by beckysoup61

Why is that?

I guess perhaps it's because that's how I view the pantheons of the ages relating to God and Goddess, they each separate deities, but can be a single greater deity too. They have different methods, reasons, and personalities, but they all work together as one for a greater purpose with those differences.

[Bishka]

Originally Posted by linwood

What she said.

The Christian concept of the trinity has eluded my understanding for decades.

She mentioned that she would say the trinity made more sense, why in your view, would it not make sense?

[TashaN]

Originally Posted by beckysoup61

To all the non-Christians on the forums, which makes more sense in your mind, the idea of the trinity of that they are three seperate beings?

This is not to debate whether they are real or not, but why does one or the other make more sense?

None of them make any sense to me for sure, but if you insist, i guess three separate gods make more sense to me than the trinity in term of why to believe in such thing. That's because they raised two more gods and make them into higher status to reach to God "the father's" same status for several known and unknown reasons. No offence for those who believe in the trinity, just my opnion.

[TashaN]

I guess people tried to raise the concept of three gods into one thing called "trinity" because they didn't want anyone to accuse them of having multiple gods while they preach to people that they believe in one God.

[Kay]

It depends on how the Trinity is defined. I was always attracted to a "modalist" view of the Trinity. But of course, this made me a heretic.

At this point I would say that God is God, Jesus was a mystic who was "Christed," and the "Holy Spirit" is God's presence upon the earth. But of course, this too would make me a heretic.

[lilithu]

Originally Posted