Religious Education Forum  

Welcome to Religious Forums
Welcome Guest to ReligiousForums.com . You are currently not registered. When you become registered you will be able to interact with our large base of already registered users discussing topics. Some annoying Ads will also disappear when you register. Registering doesn't cost a thing and only takes a few seconds. We provide areas to chat and debate all World Religions. Please go to our register page!

Home Who's Online Today's Posts Mark Forums Read
Go Back   Religious Education Forum / Everything But the Kitchen Sink / The Arts / Literature
Reload this Page Are Comic Books Literature? (moral, preacher, recall, miracle)
Sitemap Popular RF Forums REGISTER Search Mark Forums Read

Reply
Page 1 of 12 1 2311 > Last »
 
Thread Tools Display Modes
  #1  
Old 04-02-2009, 06:17 AM
Trey of Diamonds's Avatar
Religion: Unitarian
Title:Uber Member
  
Join Date: Aug 2006
Location: Houston
Gender: Male
Posts: 4,204
Frubals: 5451956
Trey of Diamonds tries to work the phrase, 'more fun than a barrel of frubals' into every conversation
Trey of Diamonds tries to work the phrase, 'more fun than a barrel of frubals' into every conversationTrey of Diamonds tries to work the phrase, 'more fun than a barrel of frubals' into every conversationTrey of Diamonds tries to work the phrase, 'more fun than a barrel of frubals' into every conversationTrey of Diamonds tries to work the phrase, 'more fun than a barrel of frubals' into every conversationTrey of Diamonds tries to work the phrase, 'more fun than a barrel of frubals' into every conversationTrey of Diamonds tries to work the phrase, 'more fun than a barrel of frubals' into every conversationTrey of Diamonds tries to work the phrase, 'more fun than a barrel of frubals' into every conversationTrey of Diamonds tries to work the phrase, 'more fun than a barrel of frubals' into every conversationTrey of Diamonds tries to work the phrase, 'more fun than a barrel of frubals' into every conversationTrey of Diamonds tries to work the phrase, 'more fun than a barrel of frubals' into every conversationTrey of Diamonds tries to work the phrase, 'more fun than a barrel of frubals' into every conversationTrey of Diamonds tries to work the phrase, 'more fun than a barrel of frubals' into every conversationTrey of Diamonds tries to work the phrase, 'more fun than a barrel of frubals' into every conversationTrey of Diamonds tries to work the phrase, 'more fun than a barrel of frubals' into every conversationTrey of Diamonds tries to work the phrase, 'more fun than a barrel of frubals' into every conversationTrey of Diamonds tries to work the phrase, 'more fun than a barrel of frubals' into every conversationTrey of Diamonds tries to work the phrase, 'more fun than a barrel of frubals' into every conversationTrey of Diamonds tries to work the phrase, 'more fun than a barrel of frubals' into every conversationTrey of Diamonds tries to work the phrase, 'more fun than a barrel of frubals' into every conversationTrey of Diamonds tries to work the phrase, 'more fun than a barrel of frubals' into every conversationTrey of Diamonds tries to work the phrase, 'more fun than a barrel of frubals' into every conversationTrey of Diamonds tries to work the phrase, 'more fun than a barrel of frubals' into every conversationTrey of Diamonds tries to work the phrase, 'more fun than a barrel of frubals' into every conversationTrey of Diamonds tries to work the phrase, 'more fun than a barrel of frubals' into every conversation
Default Are Comic Books Literature?
This has been a long lasting debate so I thought I'd see what folks here thought.

THE BEAT » Blog Archive » Are comics literature?
Graphic novel viewed as contemporary literature, professor says - Columbia Missourian
San Francisco News - The Difference Between Comics and Literature - page 1 (weird but goes into the legal issues of calling comics literature, specifically paying taxes on them.)
Hugo Awards add Graphic Novel Category - ComicMix news
__________________
[COLOR=red]<> <> <>[/COLOR] Trey of Diamonds [COLOR=red]<> <> <>[/COLOR]
[URL]http://www.facebook.com/profile.php?id=720988663[/URL]
[URL]http://www.comicspace.com/trey/[/URL]

"If you would be a real seeker after truth, it is necessary that at least once in your life you doubt, as far as possible, all things."
[I]~ Rene Descartes[/I]
Reply With Quote
  #2  
Old 04-02-2009, 08:15 AM
Storm's Avatar
Storm Offline
Religion: Rogue Panentheist/ UU
Title:Proud Queer
Prolific Poster Award: - Issue reason: You have achieved over 10,000 posts at RF. Congratulations!! 
 
Join Date: Apr 2007
Location: Portland, OR
Gender: Female
Posts: 26,194
Frubals: 20874569
Storm is convinced frubals were placed here by superintelligent aliensStorm is convinced frubals were placed here by superintelligent aliensStorm is convinced frubals were placed here by superintelligent aliensStorm is convinced frubals were placed here by superintelligent aliens
Storm is convinced frubals were placed here by superintelligent aliensStorm is convinced frubals were placed here by superintelligent aliensStorm is convinced frubals were placed here by superintelligent aliensStorm is convinced frubals were placed here by superintelligent aliensStorm is convinced frubals were placed here by superintelligent aliensStorm is convinced frubals were placed here by superintelligent aliensStorm is convinced frubals were placed here by superintelligent aliensStorm is convinced frubals were placed here by superintelligent aliensStorm is convinced frubals were placed here by superintelligent aliensStorm is convinced frubals were placed here by superintelligent aliensStorm is convinced frubals were placed here by superintelligent aliensStorm is convinced frubals were placed here by superintelligent aliensStorm is convinced frubals were placed here by superintelligent aliensStorm is convinced frubals were placed here by superintelligent aliensStorm is convinced frubals were placed here by superintelligent aliensStorm is convinced frubals were placed here by superintelligent aliensStorm is convinced frubals were placed here by superintelligent aliensStorm is convinced frubals were placed here by superintelligent aliensStorm is convinced frubals were placed here by superintelligent aliensStorm is convinced frubals were placed here by superintelligent aliensStorm is convinced frubals were placed here by superintelligent aliensStorm is convinced frubals were placed here by superintelligent aliensStorm is convinced frubals were placed here by superintelligent aliensStorm is convinced frubals were placed here by superintelligent aliensStorm is convinced frubals were placed here by superintelligent aliensStorm is convinced frubals were placed here by superintelligent aliensStorm is convinced frubals were placed here by superintelligent aliens
Default
What do you mean by "literature?"
__________________
Questions about my beliefs? Click here.

We do not fear the night, who have loved the stars so fondly.
Reply With Quote
  #3  
Old 04-02-2009, 08:22 AM
tomspug's Avatar
tomspug Offline
Religion: Christianity
Title:Absorbant
  
Join Date: Dec 2007
Location: Roseville, CA
Gender: Male
Posts: 4,239
Frubals: 3485956
tomspug will pole dance for frubalstomspug will pole dance for frubalstomspug will pole dance for frubals
tomspug will pole dance for frubalstomspug will pole dance for frubalstomspug will pole dance for frubalstomspug will pole dance for frubalstomspug will pole dance for frubalstomspug will pole dance for frubalstomspug will pole dance for frubalstomspug will pole dance for frubalstomspug will pole dance for frubalstomspug will pole dance for frubalstomspug will pole dance for frubalstomspug will pole dance for frubalstomspug will pole dance for frubalstomspug will pole dance for frubalstomspug will pole dance for frubalstomspug will pole dance for frubalstomspug will pole dance for frubalstomspug will pole dance for frubalstomspug will pole dance for frubalstomspug will pole dance for frubalstomspug will pole dance for frubalstomspug will pole dance for frubalstomspug will pole dance for frubalstomspug will pole dance for frubalstomspug will pole dance for frubals
Default
I think it depends... They are a visual medium, yes, but sometimes they can be very story-driven and character-driven. I will say 'yes' for now. As far as quality of literature, it tends to fall somewhere above manga and below young adult literature.
Reply With Quote
  #4  
Old 04-02-2009, 08:23 AM
Trey of Diamonds's Avatar
Religion: Unitarian
Title:Uber Member
  
Join Date: Aug 2006
Location: Houston
Gender: Male
Posts: 4,204
Frubals: 5451956
Trey of Diamonds tries to work the phrase, 'more fun than a barrel of frubals' into every conversation
Trey of Diamonds tries to work the phrase, 'more fun than a barrel of frubals' into every conversationTrey of Diamonds tries to work the phrase, 'more fun than a barrel of frubals' into every conversationTrey of Diamonds tries to work the phrase, 'more fun than a barrel of frubals' into every conversationTrey of Diamonds tries to work the phrase, 'more fun than a barrel of frubals' into every conversationTrey of Diamonds tries to work the phrase, 'more fun than a barrel of frubals' into every conversationTrey of Diamonds tries to work the phrase, 'more fun than a barrel of frubals' into every conversationTrey of Diamonds tries to work the phrase, 'more fun than a barrel of frubals' into every conversationTrey of Diamonds tries to work the phrase, 'more fun than a barrel of frubals' into every conversationTrey of Diamonds tries to work the phrase, 'more fun than a barrel of frubals' into every conversationTrey of Diamonds tries to work the phrase, 'more fun than a barrel of frubals' into every conversationTrey of Diamonds tries to work the phrase, 'more fun than a barrel of frubals' into every conversationTrey of Diamonds tries to work the phrase, 'more fun than a barrel of frubals' into every conversationTrey of Diamonds tries to work the phrase, 'more fun than a barrel of frubals' into every conversationTrey of Diamonds tries to work the phrase, 'more fun than a barrel of frubals' into every conversationTrey of Diamonds tries to work the phrase, 'more fun than a barrel of frubals' into every conversationTrey of Diamonds tries to work the phrase, 'more fun than a barrel of frubals' into every conversationTrey of Diamonds tries to work the phrase, 'more fun than a barrel of frubals' into every conversationTrey of Diamonds tries to work the phrase, 'more fun than a barrel of frubals' into every conversationTrey of Diamonds tries to work the phrase, 'more fun than a barrel of frubals' into every conversationTrey of Diamonds tries to work the phrase, 'more fun than a barrel of frubals' into every conversationTrey of Diamonds tries to work the phrase, 'more fun than a barrel of frubals' into every conversationTrey of Diamonds tries to work the phrase, 'more fun than a barrel of frubals' into every conversationTrey of Diamonds tries to work the phrase, 'more fun than a barrel of frubals' into every conversationTrey of Diamonds tries to work the phrase, 'more fun than a barrel of frubals' into every conversation
Default
Quote:
Originally Posted by Storm View Post
What do you mean by "literature?"
Well, that is part of the debate. Those who argue one way or the other often are debating different definitions of the term literature. So to answer the OP question you first have to define your own meaning of literature and then see if comic books fit into that definition.
__________________
[COLOR=red]<> <> <>[/COLOR] Trey of Diamonds [COLOR=red]<> <> <>[/COLOR]
[URL]http://www.facebook.com/profile.php?id=720988663[/URL]
[URL]http://www.comicspace.com/trey/[/URL]

"If you would be a real seeker after truth, it is necessary that at least once in your life you doubt, as far as possible, all things."
[I]~ Rene Descartes[/I]
Reply With Quote
  #5  
Old 04-26-2009, 07:15 PM
Delilah Roo's Avatar
Delilah Roo Offline
Title:Non-Theist
  
Join Date: Apr 2009
Location: New England
Gender: Female
Posts: 81
Frubals: 192871
Delilah Roo has a reputation beyond reputeDelilah Roo has a reputation beyond reputeDelilah Roo has a reputation beyond reputeDelilah Roo has a reputation beyond reputeDelilah Roo has a reputation beyond reputeDelilah Roo has a reputation beyond reputeDelilah Roo has a reputation beyond reputeDelilah Roo has a reputation beyond reputeDelilah Roo has a reputation beyond reputeDelilah Roo has a reputation beyond reputeDelilah Roo has a reputation beyond reputeDelilah Roo has a reputation beyond reputeDelilah Roo has a reputation beyond reputeDelilah Roo has a reputation beyond reputeDelilah Roo has a reputation beyond reputeDelilah Roo has a reputation beyond reputeDelilah Roo has a reputation beyond reputeDelilah Roo has a reputation beyond reputeDelilah Roo has a reputation beyond reputeDelilah Roo has a reputation beyond reputeDelilah Roo has a reputation beyond reputeDelilah Roo has a reputation beyond repute
Default
Sure they can be,

My critasism of comic books is that it seems like the charecters, especialy the villains are one sided. You, as the reader, have no motavation to see them as anything other than evil. No one is compleatly evil, and sometimes comic villians are not deep enough.

(sometimes they are, I am sure anyone who is a real comic book reader will be able to pull out a thousand examples contradicting what I said.)

Delilah
Reply With Quote
  #6  
Old 04-26-2009, 07:36 PM
J Bryson's Avatar
J Bryson Offline
Religion: Unitarian Universalist
Title:Uber Member
  
Join Date: Feb 2009
Location: Southern California
Gender: Male
Posts: 2,283
Frubals: 5589873
J Bryson thinks of frubals as mere sex objects
J Bryson thinks of frubals as mere sex objectsJ Bryson thinks of frubals as mere sex objectsJ Bryson thinks of frubals as mere sex objectsJ Bryson thinks of frubals as mere sex objectsJ Bryson thinks of frubals as mere sex objectsJ Bryson thinks of frubals as mere sex objectsJ Bryson thinks of frubals as mere sex objectsJ Bryson thinks of frubals as mere sex objectsJ Bryson thinks of frubals as mere sex objectsJ Bryson thinks of frubals as mere sex objectsJ Bryson thinks of frubals as mere sex objectsJ Bryson thinks of frubals as mere sex objectsJ Bryson thinks of frubals as mere sex objectsJ Bryson thinks of frubals as mere sex objectsJ Bryson thinks of frubals as mere sex objectsJ Bryson thinks of frubals as mere sex objectsJ Bryson thinks of frubals as mere sex objectsJ Bryson thinks of frubals as mere sex objectsJ Bryson thinks of frubals as mere sex objectsJ Bryson thinks of frubals as mere sex objectsJ Bryson thinks of frubals as mere sex objectsJ Bryson thinks of frubals as mere sex objectsJ Bryson thinks of frubals as mere sex objectsJ Bryson thinks of frubals as mere sex objectsJ Bryson thinks of frubals as mere sex objectsJ Bryson thinks of frubals as mere sex objects
Default
Quote:
Originally Posted by Delilah Roo View Post
Sure they can be,

My critasism of comic books is that it seems like the charecters, especialy the villains are one sided. You, as the reader, have no motavation to see them as anything other than evil. No one is compleatly evil, and sometimes comic villians are not deep enough.

(sometimes they are, I am sure anyone who is a real comic book reader will be able to pull out a thousand examples contradicting what I said.)

Delilah
Well, maybe not a thousand, but I'm sure that I can come up with a few.

Watchmen by Alan Moore is probably the most famous "shades of gray" example in the comic book medium, and I'd say deservedly so.

Preacher by Garth Ennis makes no bones about a split between good and evil, but his ideas on who qualifies as such can be unexpected, and blasphemously enjoyable.

The Dark Knight Returns by Frank Miller manages to imbue some of the most famous characters of all time with moral ambiguity.

Miracleman by Alan Moore is one of the earliest deconstructions of the superhero genre that I can recall, and is a violent meditation on power, society, and responsibility.

Of course, that's just in the superhero genre. Once you start getting into the works of Spiegelman, Pekar, R. Crumb et al, all bets are off.
__________________
The answer to bad religion is not no religion; it’s good religion, religion that is committed to love and not to hate, to bringing people together, not dividing them, and to creating dialogue, not argument. -The Rev. Scotty McLennan
Reply With Quote
  #7  
Old 04-26-2009, 07:58 PM
doppelgänger's Avatar
doppelgänger Offline
Title:Through the Looking Glass
Prolific Poster Award: - Issue reason: You have acheived over 10,000 posts here at RF. Congrats Brendan! Courtesy Award: - Issue reason: This award has been given to you by your peers and is well deserved. Article Award: - Issue reason:  Scholarship Award: - Issue reason: This scolarship award has been given to you by your peers and is well deserved. 
 
Join Date: Aug 2006
Location: In your mind
Gender: Male
Posts: 13,450
Frubals: 8282192
doppelgänger won an award for full-contact competitive frubal jugglingdoppelgänger won an award for full-contact competitive frubal jugglingdoppelgänger won an award for full-contact competitive frubal jugglingdoppelgänger won an award for full-contact competitive frubal juggling
doppelgänger won an award for full-contact competitive frubal jugglingdoppelgänger won an award for full-contact competitive frubal jugglingdoppelgänger won an award for full-contact competitive frubal jugglingdoppelgänger won an award for full-contact competitive frubal jugglingdoppelgänger won an award for full-contact competitive frubal jugglingdoppelgänger won an award for full-contact competitive frubal jugglingdoppelgänger won an award for full-contact competitive frubal jugglingdoppelgänger won an award for full-contact competitive frubal jugglingdoppelgänger won an award for full-contact competitive frubal jugglingdoppelgänger won an award for full-contact competitive frubal jugglingdoppelgänger won an award for full-contact competitive frubal jugglingdoppelgänger won an award for full-contact competitive frubal jugglingdoppelgänger won an award for full-contact competitive frubal jugglingdoppelgänger won an award for full-contact competitive frubal jugglingdoppelgänger won an award for full-contact competitive frubal jugglingdoppelgänger won an award for full-contact competitive frubal jugglingdoppelgänger won an award for full-contact competitive frubal jugglingdoppelgänger won an award for full-contact competitive frubal jugglingdoppelgänger won an award for full-contact competitive frubal jugglingdoppelgänger won an award for full-contact competitive frubal jugglingdoppelgänger won an award for full-contact competitive frubal jugglingdoppelgänger won an award for full-contact competitive frubal juggling
Default
Of course they are. Anyone who says otherwise is just being a snotty, foppish twit. QED.
__________________
Every end is also a beginning. So why don't people walk around with "The Beginning is Nigh!" sandwich boards?
Reply With Quote
  #8  
Old 04-26-2009, 07:59 PM
rojse's Avatar
rojse Offline
Religion: Just looking, thanks.
Title:RF Addict
  
Join Date: May 2007
Location: Australia
Gender: Male
Posts: 7,880
Frubals: 14143761
rojse is starting a reform school for bad little frubalsrojse is starting a reform school for bad little frubalsrojse is starting a reform school for bad little frubalsrojse is starting a reform school for bad little frubalsrojse is starting a reform school for bad little frubals
rojse is starting a reform school for bad little frubalsrojse is starting a reform school for bad little frubalsrojse is starting a reform school for bad little frubalsrojse is starting a reform school for bad little frubalsrojse is starting a reform school for bad little frubalsrojse is starting a reform school for bad little frubalsrojse is starting a reform school for bad little frubalsrojse is starting a reform school for bad little frubalsrojse is starting a reform school for bad little frubalsrojse is starting a reform school for bad little frubalsrojse is starting a reform school for bad little frubalsrojse is starting a reform school for bad little frubalsrojse is starting a reform school for bad little frubalsrojse is starting a reform school for bad little frubalsrojse is starting a reform school for bad little frubalsrojse is starting a reform school for bad little frubalsrojse is starting a reform school for bad little frubalsrojse is starting a reform school for bad little frubalsrojse is starting a reform school for bad little frubalsrojse is starting a reform school for bad little frubalsrojse is starting a reform school for bad little frubalsrojse is starting a reform school for bad little frubalsrojse is starting a reform school for bad little frubalsrojse is starting a reform school for bad little frubalsrojse is starting a reform school for bad little frubalsrojse is starting a reform school for bad little frubalsrojse is starting a reform school for bad little frubalsrojse is starting a reform school for bad little frubalsrojse is starting a reform school for bad little frubalsrojse is starting a reform school for bad little frubals
Default
Quote:
Originally Posted by Trey of Diamonds View Post
This has been a long lasting debate so I thought I'd see what folks here thought.

THE BEAT » Blog Archive » Are comics literature?
Graphic novel viewed as contemporary literature, professor says - Columbia Missourian
San Francisco News - The Difference Between Comics and Literature - page 1 (weird but goes into the legal issues of calling comics literature, specifically paying taxes on them.)
Hugo Awards add Graphic Novel Category - ComicMix news
When Maus can win a Pulitzer Prize (and was an excellent graphic novel), then I say yes, regardless of how you wish to define "litereature".
__________________
"The Earth quakes and the Heavens rattle; the beasts of nature flock together and the nations of men flock apart,; volcanoes usher up heat while elsewhere water becomes ice and melts; and then on other days it just rains."

The Illuminatus! Triology
Reply With Quote
  #9  
Old 04-26-2009, 08:03 PM
zenzero's Avatar
zenzero Offline
Religion: do things religiously
Title:Its only a Label
Courtesy Award: - Issue reason: This award has been given to you by your peers and is well deserved. 
 
Join Date: Feb 2007
Location: Garden of eden
Gender: Male
Posts: 7,288
Frubals: 15733900
zenzero surprised your frubals with crabszenzero surprised your frubals with crabszenzero surprised your frubals with crabs
zenzero surprised your frubals with crabszenzero surprised your frubals with crabszenzero surprised your frubals with crabszenzero surprised your frubals with crabszenzero surprised your frubals with crabszenzero surprised your frubals with crabszenzero surprised your frubals with crabszenzero surprised your frubals with crabszenzero surprised your frubals with crabszenzero surprised your frubals with crabszenzero surprised your frubals with crabszenzero surprised your frubals with crabszenzero surprised your frubals with crabszenzero surprised your frubals with crabszenzero surprised your frubals with crabszenzero surprised your frubals with crabszenzero surprised your frubals with crabszenzero surprised your frubals with crabszenzero surprised your frubals with crabszenzero surprised your frubals with crabszenzero surprised your frubals with crabszenzero surprised your frubals with crabszenzero surprised your frubals with crabszenzero surprised your frubals with crabszenzero surprised your frubals with crabszenzero surprised your frubals with crabs
Default
Friend Trey of Diamonds,

Quote:
Are Comic Books Literature?
Wondering why we did not study *comics* in literature classes?

Love & rgds
Reply With Quote
  #10  
Old 04-26-2009, 08:04 PM
Watchmen's Avatar
Watchmen Offline
Religion: An LDS Exception
Title:Rorschach
  
Join Date: Jun 2008
Location: Sick Bay
Gender: Male
Posts: 3,486
Frubals: 2828800
Watchmen hopes to be reincarnated as a frubal next time aroundWatchmen hopes to be reincarnated as a frubal next time around
Watchmen hopes to be reincarnated as a frubal next time aroundWatchmen hopes to be reincarnated as a frubal next time aroundWatchmen hopes to be reincarnated as a frubal next time aroundWatchmen hopes to be reincarnated as a frubal next time aroundWatchmen hopes to be reincarnated as a frubal next time aroundWatchmen hopes to be reincarnated as a frubal next time aroundWatchmen hopes to be reincarnated as a frubal next time aroundWatchmen hopes to be reincarnated as a frubal next time aroundWatchmen hopes to be reincarnated as a frubal next time aroundWatchmen hopes to be reincarnated as a frubal next time aroundWatchmen hopes to be reincarnated as a frubal next time aroundWatchmen hopes to be reincarnated as a frubal next time aroundWatchmen hopes to be reincarnated as a frubal next time aroundWatchmen hopes to be reincarnated as a frubal next time aroundWatchmen hopes to be reincarnated as a frubal next time aroundWatchmen hopes to be reincarnated as a frubal next time aroundWatchmen hopes to be reincarnated as a frubal next time aroundWatchmen hopes to be reincarnated as a frubal next time aroundWatchmen hopes to be reincarnated as a frubal next time aroundWatchmen hopes to be reincarnated as a frubal next time aroundWatchmen hopes to be reincarnated as a frubal next time aroundWatchmen hopes to be reincarnated as a frubal next time aroundWatchmen hopes to be reincarnated as a frubal next time aroundWatchmen hopes to be reincarnated as a frubal next time aroundWatchmen hopes to be reincarnated as a frubal next time aroundWatchmen hopes to be reincarnated as a frubal next time aroundWatchmen hopes to be reincarnated as a frubal next time aroundWatchmen hopes to be reincarnated as a frubal next time around
Default
Yes - they are.
__________________
There are people who will say that this whole account is a lie, but a thing isn't necessarily a lie even if it didn't necessarily happen. -John Steinbeck, Sweet Thursday
Reply With Quote
Reply
Page 1 of 12 1 2311 > Last »

« Be gentle with me.. :) | My article is finally published »
Thread Tools
Display Modes
Linear Mode Linear Mode

Similar Threads



All times are GMT -6. The time now is 03:19 AM.

Contact Us - Religious Forums - Archive 1, 2 - Top

© 2009 Advameg, Inc.

SEO by vBSEO ©2009, Crawlability, Inc.