Religious Education Forum  

Welcome to Religious Forums
Welcome Guest to ReligiousForums.com . You are currently not registered. When you become registered you will be able to interact with our large base of already registered users discussing topics. Some annoying Ads will also disappear when you register. Registering doesn't cost a thing and only takes a few seconds. We provide areas to chat and debate all World Religions. Please go to our register page!

Home Who's Online Today's Posts Mark Forums Read
Go Back   Religious Education Forum / Religious Topics / Religious Debates / General Religious Debates
Sitemap Popular RF Forums REGISTER Search Mark Forums Read

Reply
 
Thread Tools Display Modes
  #1  
Old 02-04-2007, 06:53 PM
Ozzie's Avatar
Ozzie Online!
Religion: Buddhist blindsight
Title:Same path not footprint.
 
Join Date: Sep 2006
Gender: Male
Posts: 2,423
Frubals: 467617
Ozzie eats frubals for breakfast
Ozzie eats frubals for breakfastOzzie eats frubals for breakfastOzzie eats frubals for breakfastOzzie eats frubals for breakfastOzzie eats frubals for breakfast
Ozzie eats frubals for breakfastOzzie eats frubals for breakfastOzzie eats frubals for breakfastOzzie eats frubals for breakfastOzzie eats frubals for breakfastOzzie eats frubals for breakfastOzzie eats frubals for breakfastOzzie eats frubals for breakfastOzzie eats frubals for breakfastOzzie eats frubals for breakfastOzzie eats frubals for breakfastOzzie eats frubals for breakfastOzzie eats frubals for breakfastOzzie eats frubals for breakfastOzzie eats frubals for breakfastOzzie eats frubals for breakfastOzzie eats frubals for breakfastOzzie eats frubals for breakfastOzzie eats frubals for breakfastOzzie eats frubals for breakfastOzzie eats frubals for breakfastOzzie eats frubals for breakfastOzzie eats frubals for breakfastOzzie eats frubals for breakfastOzzie eats frubals for breakfastOzzie eats frubals for breakfastOzzie eats frubals for breakfastOzzie eats frubals for breakfastOzzie eats frubals for breakfastOzzie eats frubals for breakfast
Default Book of Revelation:Commentary on the End of the Roman Empire or of our times?

A recent documentary inspires a thread on the Book of Revelation. I am not a Bible scholar, nor a Christian. However, I wonder how literally this Book should be interpreted. Presuming Christians here on the forum are conversant with scholarly opinion on this Book, how should John's words be interpreted: as a commentary on the Romans and Caligula in particular, or as a prophetic message about the end of days to come?
Reply With Quote
  #2  
Old 02-05-2007, 12:34 PM
Moni_Gail's Avatar
Moni_Gail Offline
Religion: No clue!
Title:ELIGE MAGISTRUM
 
Join Date: Oct 2006
Location: Nebraska
Gender: Female
Posts: 366
Frubals: 43580
Moni_Gail has much to be proud ofMoni_Gail has much to be proud of
Moni_Gail has much to be proud ofMoni_Gail has much to be proud of
Default

One documentary I watched on this very subject suggested it was about Nero and not Caligula. :shrug Though I must say I'd more readily believe that than the end of the world bit that many subscribe to.
__________________
"Man is the Religious Animal. He is the only Religious Animal. He is the only animal that has the True Religion-- several of them."

Mark Twain
Reply With Quote
  #3  
Old 02-05-2007, 12:51 PM
wizanda's Avatar
wizanda Offline
Religion: One
Title:Senior Member
 
Join Date: Oct 2004
Location: Nottingham
Gender: Male
Posts: 1,831
Frubals: 61595
wizanda has a brilliant futurewizanda has a brilliant future
wizanda has a brilliant futurewizanda has a brilliant futurewizanda has a brilliant futurewizanda has a brilliant futurewizanda has a brilliant futurewizanda has a brilliant futurewizanda has a brilliant futurewizanda has a brilliant futurewizanda has a brilliant futurewizanda has a brilliant futurewizanda has a brilliant futurewizanda has a brilliant futurewizanda has a brilliant futurewizanda has a brilliant futurewizanda has a brilliant futurewizanda has a brilliant futurewizanda has a brilliant futurewizanda has a brilliant futurewizanda has a brilliant futurewizanda has a brilliant futurewizanda has a brilliant futurewizanda has a brilliant futurewizanda has a brilliant futurewizanda has a brilliant futurewizanda has a brilliant futurewizanda has a brilliant futurewizanda has a brilliant futurewizanda has a brilliant futurewizanda has a brilliant futurewizanda has a brilliant futurewizanda has a brilliant futurewizanda has a brilliant futurewizanda has a brilliant future
Default

I have written an article on the end being forged as it repeats word for word, how he bowed in front of the same angel and told not to a chapter between and then changes the context and wording; also closing the book, which wouldn't have been known until canonized.
The start also appears fake where they added sprinkling of blood, as that is Balaam teaching and wasn’t there to begin, as it mistakenly identifies Christ.

Also the author is not the same author as that of the gospels, as the wording is different, John was adept at writing Greek the author of Revelations isn’t and makes basic grammatical flaws.
__________________
Oneness - True Faith

Last edited by wizanda; 02-05-2007 at 12:53 PM.
Reply With Quote
  #4  
Old 02-05-2007, 01:40 PM
angellous_evangellous's Avatar
angellous_evangellous Offline
Religion: Christian
Title:pater familias
Prolific Poster Award:  - Issue reason: 10,000 posts Scholarship Award:  - Issue reason: This award has been given to your peers and is well deserved. Humor Award:  - Issue reason: This award has been given to you by your peers and is well deserved. Article Award:  - Issue reason:  
 
Join Date: Jan 2005
Location: D/FW, TX
Gender: Male
Posts: 23,720
Frubals: 4539590
angellous_evangellous is a Frubal Whoreangellous_evangellous is a Frubal Whoreangellous_evangellous is a Frubal Whoreangellous_evangellous is a Frubal Whoreangellous_evangellous is a Frubal Whoreangellous_evangellous is a Frubal Whoreangellous_evangellous is a Frubal Whoreangellous_evangellous is a Frubal Whoreangellous_evangellous is a Frubal Whoreangellous_evangellous is a Frubal Whoreangellous_evangellous is a Frubal Whoreangellous_evangellous is a Frubal Whoreangellous_evangellous is a Frubal Whore
angellous_evangellous is a Frubal Whoreangellous_evangellous is a Frubal Whoreangellous_evangellous is a Frubal Whore
angellous_evangellous is a Frubal Whoreangellous_evangellous is a Frubal Whoreangellous_evangellous is a Frubal Whoreangellous_evangellous is a Frubal Whoreangellous_evangellous is a Frubal Whoreangellous_evangellous is a Frubal Whoreangellous_evangellous is a Frubal Whoreangellous_evangellous is a Frubal Whoreangellous_evangellous is a Frubal Whoreangellous_evangellous is a Frubal Whoreangellous_evangellous is a Frubal Whore
Default

Quote:
Originally Posted by Moni_Gail
One documentary I watched on this very subject suggested it was about Nero and not Caligula. :shrug Though I must say I'd more readily believe that than the end of the world bit that many subscribe to.
It doesn't matter if it was written for Nero or Caligula.

The point is simply: does John's apocalypse address an ancient persecution? Did it have meaning to the original audiences?
__________________
"Scully, one of these days, we're going to look back on this moment and laugh." - Fox
Reply With Quote
  #5  
Old 02-05-2007, 01:45 PM
angellous_evangellous's Avatar
angellous_evangellous Offline
Religion: Christian
Title:pater familias
Prolific Poster Award:  - Issue reason: 10,000 posts Scholarship Award:  - Issue reason: This award has been given to your peers and is well deserved. Humor Award:  - Issue reason: This award has been given to you by your peers and is well deserved. Article Award:  - Issue reason:  
 
Join Date: Jan 2005
Location: D/FW, TX
Gender: Male
Posts: 23,720
Frubals: 4539590
angellous_evangellous is a Frubal Whoreangellous_evangellous is a Frubal Whoreangellous_evangellous is a Frubal Whoreangellous_evangellous is a Frubal Whoreangellous_evangellous is a Frubal Whoreangellous_evangellous is a Frubal Whoreangellous_evangellous is a Frubal Whoreangellous_evangellous is a Frubal Whoreangellous_evangellous is a Frubal Whoreangellous_evangellous is a Frubal Whoreangellous_evangellous is a Frubal Whoreangellous_evangellous is a Frubal Whoreangellous_evangellous is a Frubal Whore
angellous_evangellous is a Frubal Whoreangellous_evangellous is a Frubal Whoreangellous_evangellous is a Frubal Whore
angellous_evangellous is a Frubal Whoreangellous_evangellous is a Frubal Whoreangellous_evangellous is a Frubal Whoreangellous_evangellous is a Frubal Whoreangellous_evangellous is a Frubal Whoreangellous_evangellous is a Frubal Whoreangellous_evangellous is a Frubal Whoreangellous_evangellous is a Frubal Whoreangellous_evangellous is a Frubal Whoreangellous_evangellous is a Frubal Whoreangellous_evangellous is a Frubal Whore
Default

Quote:
Originally Posted by Ozzie
A recent documentary inspires a thread on the Book of Revelation. I am not a Bible scholar, nor a Christian. However, I wonder how literally this Book should be interpreted. Presuming Christians here on the forum are conversant with scholarly opinion on this Book, how should John's words be interpreted: as a commentary on the Romans and Caligula in particular, or as a prophetic message about the end of days to come?
1) The canonical book "Revelation" is written in the form of apocalypse patterned after Jewish apocalyptic which usually addresses the fall of a government currently persecuting the author's group. It is written in highly symbolic language, framing the fall of the powerful government in cosmological terms (eg., the fall of such a powerful government can only happen if the stars fall out of the heavens, etc).

2) The symbolic language only makes sense if it has some relationship to contemporary situations (eg., the situation of the author/audience) - not situations present after 2000 years - or even 100 years.

So it can't be interpreted literally at any time, but the symbols only make sense to the specific context of the original author/audience.
__________________
"Scully, one of these days, we're going to look back on this moment and laugh." - Fox
Reply With Quote
  #6  
Old 02-05-2007, 01:46 PM
Booko's Avatar
Booko Offline
Religion: Baha'i
Title:Deviled Hen
Above and Beyond Award:  - Issue reason: This award has been given to you by the award committee and is well deserved. Prolific Poster Award:  - Issue reason: For 10,000 posts Humor Award:  - Issue reason:  Scholarship Award:  - Issue reason:  
 
Join Date: Mar 2006
Location: Persona non grata
Gender: Female
Posts: 18,467
Frubals: 1216063
Booko is a Frubal WhoreBooko is a Frubal WhoreBooko is a Frubal Whore
Booko is a Frubal WhoreBooko is a Frubal WhoreBooko is a Frubal WhoreBooko is a Frubal WhoreBooko is a Frubal WhoreBooko is a Frubal WhoreBooko is a Frubal WhoreBooko is a Frubal Whore
Booko is a Frubal WhoreBooko is a Frubal WhoreBooko is a Frubal WhoreBooko is a Frubal WhoreBooko is a Frubal WhoreBooko is a Frubal WhoreBooko is a Frubal WhoreBooko is a Frubal WhoreBooko is a Frubal WhoreBooko is a Frubal WhoreBooko is a Frubal WhoreBooko is a Frubal WhoreBooko is a Frubal WhoreBooko is a Frubal WhoreBooko is a Frubal WhoreBooko is a Frubal WhoreBooko is a Frubal WhoreBooko is a Frubal WhoreBooko is a Frubal WhoreBooko is a Frubal WhoreBooko is a Frubal WhoreBooko is a Frubal WhoreBooko is a Frubal WhoreBooko is a Frubal WhoreBooko is a Frubal WhoreBooko is a Frubal Whore
Default

Quote:
Originally Posted by angellous_evangellous
The point is simply: does John's apocalypse address an ancient persecution? Did it have meaning to the original audiences?
It may well be the meaning those audiences got from the text. And their meaning may be just one "correct" meaning to get from it.

However, I wonder how that fits with ideas that there will be some grand golden age after all the dust settles. The Hebrew prophets go into that as well.

Well, actually pretty much every religion has that sort of thing. Even some "mythologies" do. (like Ragnarok for the Norse)
Reply With Quote
  #7  
Old 02-05-2007, 01:48 PM
Booko's Avatar
Booko Offline
Religion: Baha'i
Title:Deviled Hen
Above and Beyond Award:  - Issue reason: This award has been given to you by the award committee and is well deserved. Prolific Poster Award:  - Issue reason: For 10,000 posts Humor Award:  - Issue reason:  Scholarship Award:  - Issue reason:  
 
Join Date: Mar 2006
Location: Persona non grata
Gender: Female
Posts: 18,467
Frubals: 1216063
Booko is a Frubal WhoreBooko is a Frubal WhoreBooko is a Frubal Whore
Booko is a Frubal WhoreBooko is a Frubal WhoreBooko is a Frubal WhoreBooko is a Frubal WhoreBooko is a Frubal WhoreBooko is a Frubal WhoreBooko is a Frubal WhoreBooko is a Frubal Whore
Booko is a Frubal WhoreBooko is a Frubal WhoreBooko is a Frubal WhoreBooko is a Frubal WhoreBooko is a Frubal WhoreBooko is a Frubal WhoreBooko is a Frubal WhoreBooko is a Frubal WhoreBooko is a Frubal WhoreBooko is a Frubal WhoreBooko is a Frubal WhoreBooko is a Frubal WhoreBooko is a Frubal WhoreBooko is a Frubal WhoreBooko is a Frubal WhoreBooko is a Frubal WhoreBooko is a Frubal WhoreBooko is a Frubal WhoreBooko is a Frubal WhoreBooko is a Frubal WhoreBooko is a Frubal WhoreBooko is a Frubal WhoreBooko is a Frubal WhoreBooko is a Frubal WhoreBooko is a Frubal WhoreBooko is a Frubal Whore
Default

2) The symbolic language only makes sense if it has some relationship to contemporary situations (eg., the situation of the author/audience) - not situations present after 2000 years - or even 100 years.

So it can't be interpreted literally at any time, but the symbols only make sense to the specific context of the original author/audience.[/quote]

I would dispute this to some extent, AE, as the way I stumbled on my current religion was studing eschatologies from various religions, including John's Apocalypse of course. Not that I would've made the connection without Zoroastrian prophecies, because I doubt I would've.
Reply With Quote
  #8  
Old 02-05-2007, 01:51 PM
angellous_evangellous's Avatar
angellous_evangellous Offline
Religion: Christian
Title:pater familias
Prolific Poster Award:  - Issue reason: 10,000 posts Scholarship Award:  - Issue reason: This award has been given to your peers and is well deserved. Humor Award:  - Issue reason: This award has been given to you by your peers and is well deserved. Article Award:  - Issue reason:  
 
Join Date: Jan 2005
Location: D/FW, TX
Gender: Male
Posts: 23,720
Frubals: 4539590
angellous_evangellous is a Frubal Whoreangellous_evangellous is a Frubal Whoreangellous_evangellous is a Frubal Whoreangellous_evangellous is a Frubal Whoreangellous_evangellous is a Frubal Whoreangellous_evangellous is a Frubal Whoreangellous_evangellous is a Frubal Whoreangellous_evangellous is a Frubal Whoreangellous_evangellous is a Frubal Whoreangellous_evangellous is a Frubal Whoreangellous_evangellous is a Frubal Whoreangellous_evangellous is a Frubal Whoreangellous_evangellous is a Frubal Whore
angellous_evangellous is a Frubal Whoreangellous_evangellous is a Frubal Whoreangellous_evangellous is a Frubal Whore
angellous_evangellous is a Frubal Whoreangellous_evangellous is a Frubal Whoreangellous_evangellous is a Frubal Whoreangellous_evangellous is a Frubal Whoreangellous_evangellous is a Frubal Whoreangellous_evangellous is a Frubal Whoreangellous_evangellous is a Frubal Whoreangellous_evangellous is a Frubal Whoreangellous_evangellous is a Frubal Whoreangellous_evangellous is a Frubal Whoreangellous_evangellous is a Frubal Whore
Default

Quote:
Originally Posted by Booko
I would dispute this to some extent, AE, as the way I stumbled on my current religion was studing eschatologies from various religions, including John's Apocalypse of course. Not that I would've made the connection without Zoroastrian prophecies, because I doubt I would've.
So what's the dispute?
__________________
"Scully, one of these days, we're going to look back on this moment and laugh." - Fox
Reply With Quote
  #9  
Old 02-05-2007, 02:12 PM
Moni_Gail's Avatar
Moni_Gail Offline
Religion: No clue!
Title:ELIGE MAGISTRUM
 
Join Date: Oct 2006
Location: Nebraska
Gender: Female
Posts: 366
Frubals: 43580
Moni_Gail has much to be proud ofMoni_Gail has much to be proud of
Moni_Gail has much to be proud ofMoni_Gail has much to be proud of
Default

Quote:
Originally Posted by angellous_evangellous
It doesn't matter if it was written for Nero or Caligula.

The point is simply: does John's apocalypse address an ancient persecution? Did it have meaning to the original audiences?
Ah, then I will definitely bow out of this one since that was the only helpful thing I had to add to the discussion.
__________________
"Man is the Religious Animal. He is the only Religious Animal. He is the only animal that has the True Religion-- several of them."

Mark Twain
Reply With Quote
  #10  
Old 02-05-2007, 02:16 PM
angellous_evangellous's Avatar
angellous_evangellous Offline
Religion: Christian
Title:pater familias
Prolific Poster Award:  - Issue reason: 10,000 posts Scholarship Award:  - Issue reason: This award has been given to your peers and is well deserved. Humor Award:  - Issue reason: This award has been given to you by your peers and is well deserved. Article Award:  - Issue reason:  
 
Join Date: Jan 2005
Location: D/FW, TX
Gender: Male
Posts: 23,720
Frubals: 4539590
angellous_evangellous is a Frubal Whoreangellous_evangellous is a Frubal Whoreangellous_evangellous is a Frubal Whoreangellous_evangellous is a Frubal Whoreangellous_evangellous is a Frubal Whoreangellous_evangellous is a Frubal Whoreangellous_evangellous is a Frubal Whoreangellous_evangellous is a Frubal Whoreangellous_evangellous is a Frubal Whoreangellous_evangellous is a Frubal Whoreangellous_evangellous is a Frubal Whoreangellous_evangellous is a Frubal Whoreangellous_evangellous is a Frubal Whore
angellous_evangellous is a Frubal Whoreangellous_evangellous is a Frubal Whoreangellous_evangellous is a Frubal Whore
angellous_evangellous is a Frubal Whoreangellous_evangellous is a Frubal Whoreangellous_evangellous is a Frubal Whoreangellous_evangellous is a Frubal Whoreangellous_evangellous is a Frubal Whoreangellous_evangellous is a Frubal Whoreangellous_evangellous is a Frubal Whoreangellous_evangellous is a Frubal Whoreangellous_evangellous is a Frubal Whoreangellous_evangellous is a Frubal Whoreangellous_evangellous is a Frubal Whore
Default

Quote:
Originally Posted by Moni_Gail
Ah, then I will definitely bow out of this one since that was the only helpful thing I had to add to the discussion.
awww, it's ok.