Religious Education Forum  

Welcome Guest to ReligiousForums.com . You are currently not registered. When you become registered you will be able to interact with our large base of already registered users discussing topics. Some annoying Ads will also disappear when you register. Registering doesn't cost a thing and only takes a few seconds. We provide areas to chat and debate all World Religions. Please go to our register page!
Home Who's Online Today's Posts Mark Forums Read
Go Back   Religious Education Forum / Discuss Individual Religions (DIR) / Abrahamic Religions DIR / Christianity DIR
Sitemap Popular RF Forums REGISTER Search Mark Forums Read

Reply
 
Thread Tools Display Modes
  #1  
Old 09-12-2012, 04:50 AM
Yoana Offline
Title:Freshman Member
 
Join Date: Jul 2012
Gender: Undisclosed
Posts: 7
Frubals: 11
Yoana will work for frubals
Default Was Jesus crucified i.e nailed on a cross or hanged on a tree? Please Answer!

I'm a Syrian Orthodox Christian, I know there is a God. However, I need to find the answer to this question.
In the bible it Acts 5:30 "The God of our fathers raised up Jesus, whom ye slew and hanged on a tree."
Now at first I thought the cross is made out of the tree essence, it's just another way of saying it. Then I was reading the Talmud one day and it said the same thing. What do I believe? The crucifixion on the cross and then contradicts the Talmud or believe what is said about the crucifixion in the book of Acts and the Talmud which then contradicts the gospels.
Someone correct and elaborate please............

Thank you.
Reply With Quote
  #2  
Old 09-12-2012, 05:11 AM
Pegg's Avatar
Pegg Offline
Religion: Jehovah's Witness
Title:Hallowed Member
Shield of 10,000 Thoughts: Awarded for contributing 10,000 posts - Issue reason: For contributing 10,000 posts! 
 
Join Date: Jul 2010
Location: australia
Gender: Female
Posts: 11,601
Frubals: 372
Pegg forgot to mention that frubals can be harmful if swallowedPegg forgot to mention that frubals can be harmful if swallowedPegg forgot to mention that frubals can be harmful if swallowedPegg forgot to mention that frubals can be harmful if swallowedPegg forgot to mention that frubals can be harmful if swallowedPegg forgot to mention that frubals can be harmful if swallowed
Default

Quote:
Originally Posted by Yoana View Post
I'm a Syrian Orthodox Christian, I know there is a God. However, I need to find the answer to this question.
In the bible it Acts 5:30 "The God of our fathers raised up Jesus, whom ye slew and hanged on a tree."
Now at first I thought the cross is made out of the tree essence, it's just another way of saying it. Then I was reading the Talmud one day and it said the same thing. What do I believe? The crucifixion on the cross and then contradicts the Talmud or believe what is said about the crucifixion in the book of Acts and the Talmud which then contradicts the gospels.
Someone correct and elaborate please............

Thank you.
Hi,
the answer is in the original words used by the gospel writers.

The Greek word rendered “cross” in many modern Bible versions (“torture stake” in NW) is stau·ros′. In classical Greek, this word meant merely an upright stake, or pale.
Later it also came to be used for an execution stake having a crosspiece. The Imperial Bible-Dictionary acknowledges this, saying: “The Greek word for cross, [stau·ros′], properly signified a stake, an upright pole, or piece of paling, on which anything might be hung, or which might be used in impaling [fencing in] a piece of ground. . . . Even amongst the Romans the crux (from which our cross is derived) appears to have been originally an upright pole.—Edited by P. Fairbairn (London, 1874), Vol. I, p. 376.

The other word used in the gosples is xy′lon (at Acts 5:30 The God of our forefathers raised up Jesus, whom YOU slew, hanging him upon a stake/xy'lon)
which means a pale of wood.
A Greek-English Lexicon, by Liddell and Scott, defines xy′lon this as meaning: “Wood cut and ready for use, firewood, timber, etc. . . . piece of wood, log, beam, post . . . cudgel, club . . . stake on which criminals were impaled . . . of live wood, tree.

So Jesus didnt die on a cross as is commonly believed, but rather on an upright pole or 'tree' ... a xylon or stauros according to the bible writers.

the cross stems from the influence of Rome and pagan religion on christianity in later centuries.
__________________
Isaiah 2:2 "...the mountain of the house of Jehovah will become firmly established...and to it all the nations must stream" BIBLE STUDY

Last edited by Pegg; 09-12-2012 at 05:26 AM..
Reply With Quote
  #3  
Old 09-12-2012, 11:20 AM
fallingblood's Avatar
fallingblood Offline
Religion: Christian
Title:Agnostic Theist
Shield of Research: Awarded for meticulous attention to detail and comprehensive reading around a subject - Issue reason:  
 
Join Date: Nov 2009
Gender: Male
Posts: 9,809
Frubals: 449
fallingblood gets a little nauseated when you chew your frubals with your mouth openfallingblood gets a little nauseated when you chew your frubals with your mouth openfallingblood gets a little nauseated when you chew your frubals with your mouth openfallingblood gets a little nauseated when you chew your frubals with your mouth openfallingblood gets a little nauseated when you chew your frubals with your mouth openfallingblood gets a little nauseated when you chew your frubals with your mouth openfallingblood gets a little nauseated when you chew your frubals with your mouth open
Default

Quote:
Originally Posted by Yoana View Post
I'm a Syrian Orthodox Christian, I know there is a God. However, I need to find the answer to this question.
In the bible it Acts 5:30 "The God of our fathers raised up Jesus, whom ye slew and hanged on a tree."
Now at first I thought the cross is made out of the tree essence, it's just another way of saying it. Then I was reading the Talmud one day and it said the same thing. What do I believe? The crucifixion on the cross and then contradicts the Talmud or believe what is said about the crucifixion in the book of Acts and the Talmud which then contradicts the gospels.
Someone correct and elaborate please............

Thank you.
What Pegg says is the Jehovah Witnesses' opinion on the subject. It's fine, and I won't argue with it as we are in a directory. I just want to point that it is not a mainstream position.



Most would claim that it is a cross. This has been the position since the very early church. The cross is also the most likely candidate from a historical position. Looking at Roman crucifixion, the method was by using a cross. Usually, from what we can gather from the evidence, the upright beam would be permanently set up outside the city (at least in the case of Jerusalem). The cross beam was the part that would be carried from the city to the place of execution. The reason is quite simple. The upright beam simply would have been too heavy to carry.

Looking to the Greek, the term, stauros, actually can and does refer to a cross. Now, it does have different meanings, but even when used to refer to an upright pole, it often also included a cross-beam. And we get that in various other writings from that time.

Now, the statement that Jesus was crucified upon a tree is actually more of a symbolic idea. The terminology here is actually a throwback to Deuteronomy.
Reply With Quote
  #4  
Old 09-12-2012, 01:27 PM
Harmonious Offline
Religion: Orthodox Jew
Title:Theist
 
Join Date: May 2008
Location: New York
Gender: Female
Posts: 1,922
Frubals: 117
Harmonious sleeps on a big pile of frubals.  This is how some of them end up with drool stains.Harmonious sleeps on a big pile of frubals.  This is how some of them end up with drool stains.Harmonious sleeps on a big pile of frubals.  This is how some of them end up with drool stains.
Default

Quote:
Originally Posted by Yoana View Post
I'm a Syrian Orthodox Christian, I know there is a God. However, I need to find the answer to this question.
In the bible it Acts 5:30 "The God of our fathers raised up Jesus, whom ye slew and hanged on a tree."
Now at first I thought the cross is made out of the tree essence, it's just another way of saying it. Then I was reading the Talmud one day and it said the same thing. What do I believe? The crucifixion on the cross and then contradicts the Talmud or believe what is said about the crucifixion in the book of Acts and the Talmud which then contradicts the gospels.
Someone correct and elaborate please............

Thank you.
Not for nothing, but... Where would you have found this in the Talmud? And more to the point, why would you be looking for information about Jesus in the Talmud?
Reply With Quote
  #5  
Old 09-12-2012, 04:06 PM
Pegg's Avatar
Pegg Offline
Religion: Jehovah's Witness
Title:Hallowed Member
Shield of 10,000 Thoughts: Awarded for contributing 10,000 posts - Issue reason: For contributing 10,000 posts! 
 
Join Date: Jul 2010
Location: australia
Gender: Female
Posts: 11,601
Frubals: 372
Pegg forgot to mention that frubals can be harmful if swallowedPegg forgot to mention that frubals can be harmful if swallowedPegg forgot to mention that frubals can be harmful if swallowedPegg forgot to mention that frubals can be harmful if swallowedPegg forgot to mention that frubals can be harmful if swallowedPegg forgot to mention that frubals can be harmful if swallowed
Default

Quote:
Originally Posted by fallingblood View Post
Now, the statement that Jesus was crucified upon a tree is actually more of a symbolic idea. The terminology here is actually a throwback to Deuteronomy.
and that is a good point

Jesus was tried under jewish law and put to death according to Jewish customs.

Deuteronomy 21:22 “And in case there comes to be in a man a sin deserving the sentence of death, and he has been put to death, and you have hung him upon a stake, 23 his dead body should not stay all night on the stake; but you should by all means bury him on that day, because something accursed of God is the one hung up; and you must not defile your soil, which Jehovah your God is giving you as an inheritance

This also explains why the legs of those being executed were broken...the bodies had to be removed before sunset in keeping with this law. Breaking the legs would hasten the death so that the body could be removed. This wasnt a roman style of execution at all...they kept bodies hanging for however long they wanted to. But the jews had to take the body down before it got dark.

So if Jesus was hung according to jewish law, then it stands to reason that he would have been hung according to the custom of the jews, not the romans.
__________________
Isaiah 2:2 "...the mountain of the house of Jehovah will become firmly established...and to it all the nations must stream" BIBLE STUDY
Reply With Quote
  #6  
Old 09-12-2012, 05:36 PM
fallingblood's Avatar
fallingblood Offline
Religion: Christian
Title:Agnostic Theist
Shield of Research: Awarded for meticulous attention to detail and comprehensive reading around a subject - Issue reason:  
 
Join Date: Nov 2009
Gender: Male
Posts: 9,809
Frubals: 449
fallingblood gets a little nauseated when you chew your frubals with your mouth openfallingblood gets a little nauseated when you chew your frubals with your mouth openfallingblood gets a little nauseated when you chew your frubals with your mouth openfallingblood gets a little nauseated when you chew your frubals with your mouth openfallingblood gets a little nauseated when you chew your frubals with your mouth openfallingblood gets a little nauseated when you chew your frubals with your mouth openfallingblood gets a little nauseated when you chew your frubals with your mouth open
Default

Quote:
Originally Posted by Pegg View Post
and that is a good point

Jesus was tried under jewish law and put to death according to Jewish customs.

Deuteronomy 21:22 “And in case there comes to be in a man a sin deserving the sentence of death, and he has been put to death, and you have hung him upon a stake, 23 his dead body should not stay all night on the stake; but you should by all means bury him on that day, because something accursed of God is the one hung up; and you must not defile your soil, which Jehovah your God is giving you as an inheritance

This also explains why the legs of those being executed were broken...the bodies had to be removed before sunset in keeping with this law. Breaking the legs would hasten the death so that the body could be removed. This wasnt a roman style of execution at all...they kept bodies hanging for however long they wanted to. But the jews had to take the body down before it got dark.

So if Jesus was hung according to jewish law, then it stands to reason that he would have been hung according to the custom of the jews, not the romans.
Since this is a directory, I won't want to argue, or debate, as that is not the purpose of this directory. So, what I'm suggesting, if you are up for it, for a new thread in the debate section, which deals with this topic. If you are interested, I can make a new thread.
Reply With Quote
  #7  
Old 09-12-2012, 08:24 PM
Harmonious Offline
Religion: Orthodox Jew
Title:Theist
 
Join Date: May 2008
Location: New York
Gender: Female
Posts: 1,922
Frubals: 117
Harmonious sleeps on a big pile of frubals.  This is how some of them end up with drool stains.Harmonious sleeps on a big pile of frubals.  This is how some of them end up with drool stains.Harmonious sleeps on a big pile of frubals.  This is how some of them end up with drool stains.
Default

Quote:
Originally Posted by fallingblood View Post
Since this is a directory, I won't want to argue, or debate, as that is not the purpose of this directory. So, what I'm suggesting, if you are up for it, for a new thread in the debate section, which deals with this topic. If you are interested, I can make a new thread.
I would like to see that thread.
Reply With Quote
  #8  
Old 09-13-2012, 01:18 AM
Pegg's Avatar
Pegg Offline
Religion: Jehovah's Witness
Title:Hallowed Member
Shield of 10,000 Thoughts: Awarded for contributing 10,000 posts - Issue reason: For contributing 10,000 posts! 
 
Join Date: Jul 2010
Location: australia
Gender: Female
Posts: 11,601
Frubals: 372
Pegg forgot to mention that frubals can be harmful if swallowedPegg forgot to mention that frubals can be harmful if swallowedPegg forgot to mention that frubals can be harmful if swallowedPegg forgot to mention that frubals can be harmful if swallowedPegg forgot to mention that frubals can be harmful if swallowedPegg forgot to mention that frubals can be harmful if swallowed
Default

Quote:
Originally Posted by fallingblood View Post
Since this is a directory, I won't want to argue, or debate, as that is not the purpose of this directory. So, what I'm suggesting, if you are up for it, for a new thread in the debate section, which deals with this topic. If you are interested, I can make a new thread.
yep ok, that would be good
__________________
Isaiah 2:2 "...the mountain of the house of Jehovah will become firmly established...and to it all the nations must stream" BIBLE STUDY
Reply With Quote
  #9  
Old 09-13-2012, 02:24 AM
Breathe Offline
Title:Taking a break, again.
Shield of Creativity: Awarded for wonderfully original and innovative thinking - Issue reason: For your exceptional and original contributions to the forum Shield of Peace: Awarded for exceptional effort in upholding and promoting the peace - Issue reason:  Shield of 10,000 Thoughts: Awarded for contributing 10,000 posts - Issue reason: For 10,000 posts!! Congrats Carl!! 
 
Join Date: Oct 2008
Gender: Undisclosed
Posts: 17,080
Frubals: 1630
Breathe comes from a planet that was invaded by an army of frubals and is fearful of the same here on Earth
Breathe comes from a planet that was invaded by an army of frubals and is fearful of the same here on EarthBreathe comes from a planet that was invaded by an army of frubals and is fearful of the same here on EarthBreathe comes from a planet that was invaded by an army of frubals and is fearful of the same here on EarthBreathe comes from a planet that was invaded by an army of frubals and is fearful of the same here on EarthBreathe comes from a planet that was invaded by an army of frubals and is fearful of the same here on EarthBreathe comes from a planet that was invaded by an army of frubals and is fearful of the same here on EarthBreathe comes from a planet that was invaded by an army of frubals and is fearful of the same here on EarthBreathe comes from a planet that was invaded by an army of frubals and is fearful of the same here on Earth
Default

Quote:
Originally Posted by fallingblood View Post
Now, the statement that Jesus was crucified upon a tree is actually more of a symbolic idea. The terminology here is actually a throwback to Deuteronomy.
I was told by someone that the "crucified on a tree" verse was basically a way of expressing frustration with it. Like the same way someone may say "Get rid of that damn weed!" about a plant or flower they didn't like.

Was I told wrong, or is that just another possible interpretation?
Reply With Quote
  #10  
Old 09-13-2012, 02:47 AM
Yoana Offline
Title:Freshman Member
 
Join Date: Jul 2012
Gender: Undisclosed
Posts: 7
Frubals: 11
Yoana will work for frubals
Default

Quote:
Originally Posted by Harmonious View Post
Not for nothing, but... Where would you have found this in the Talmud? And more to the point, why would you be looking for information about Jesus in the Talmud?
I don't know it's in there. I was reading it because I was studying stuff about Judiasm so then I ended up reading the Talmud. I guess reading it to expand my knowledge regarding such issues.
Reply With Quote
Reply

Thread Tools
Display Modes

Similar Threads



All times are GMT -6. The time now is 09:25 AM.


Copyright © 2014 Advameg, Inc.

SEO by vBSEO ©2010, Crawlability, Inc.