Religious Education Forum  

Welcome to Religious Forums
Welcome Guest to ReligiousForums.com . You are currently not registered. When you become registered you will be able to interact with our large base of already registered users discussing topics. Some annoying Ads will also disappear when you register. Registering doesn't cost a thing and only takes a few seconds. We provide areas to chat and debate all World Religions. Please go to our register page!

Home Who's Online Today's Posts Mark Forums Read
Go Back   Religious Education Forum / Discuss Individual Religions / Abrahamic Religions / Christianity / Christian Denominations / Catholic
Reload this Page The SSPX (Jesus, priests, moral, reject, tradition)
Sitemap Popular RF Forums REGISTER Search Mark Forums Read

Reply
Page 2 of 2 < 12
 
Thread Tools Display Modes
  #11  
Old 06-06-2008, 12:02 AM
Victor's Avatar
Victor Online!
Religion: Catholic
Title:Theist
Ambassador Award: Award designated for members who show great knowledge of their religion. - Issue reason: This award has been given to you by the award committee and is well deserved. Prolific Poster Award: - Issue reason: 10000 posts Courtesy Award: - Issue reason:  
 
Join Date: Jun 2005
Location: California, USA
Gender: Male
Posts: 15,876
Frubals: 724025
Victor thinks frubals grow on treesVictor thinks frubals grow on trees
Victor thinks frubals grow on trees
Victor thinks frubals grow on treesVictor thinks frubals grow on treesVictor thinks frubals grow on treesVictor thinks frubals grow on treesVictor thinks frubals grow on treesVictor thinks frubals grow on treesVictor thinks frubals grow on treesVictor thinks frubals grow on treesVictor thinks frubals grow on treesVictor thinks frubals grow on treesVictor thinks frubals grow on treesVictor thinks frubals grow on treesVictor thinks frubals grow on treesVictor thinks frubals grow on treesVictor thinks frubals grow on treesVictor thinks frubals grow on treesVictor thinks frubals grow on treesVictor thinks frubals grow on treesVictor thinks frubals grow on treesVictor thinks frubals grow on treesVictor thinks frubals grow on treesVictor thinks frubals grow on treesVictor thinks frubals grow on treesVictor thinks frubals grow on treesVictor thinks frubals grow on treesVictor thinks frubals grow on treesVictor thinks frubals grow on treesVictor thinks frubals grow on treesVictor thinks frubals grow on trees
Default
Another thing to note is that SSPX hasn't completely withdrawn submission from the Roman Pontiff. Cardinal Castrillon says:

"The Fraternity of St. Pius X is not a consolidated schism per se, but its history has included some schismatic actions."

Cardinal Castrillón: SSPX not in schism

But then again, don't all schismatics commit "schimatic actions"? And, how many actions make you an official schismatic?
__________________
"Man can be defined as an animal that makes dogmas. . . . " G.K. Chesterton
Reply With Quote
  #12  
Old 06-06-2008, 12:07 AM
Scott1's Avatar
Scott1 Offline
Religion: Roman Catholic
Title:Church of the Fonz
Journal Award: - Issue reason:  Article Award: - Issue reason:  
 
Join Date: Jul 2004
Location: MA, USA
Gender: Male
Posts: 8,011
Frubals: 590576
Scott1 thinks frubals grow on trees
Scott1 thinks frubals grow on treesScott1 thinks frubals grow on treesScott1 thinks frubals grow on treesScott1 thinks frubals grow on treesScott1 thinks frubals grow on treesScott1 thinks frubals grow on treesScott1 thinks frubals grow on treesScott1 thinks frubals grow on treesScott1 thinks frubals grow on treesScott1 thinks frubals grow on treesScott1 thinks frubals grow on trees
Scott1 thinks frubals grow on treesScott1 thinks frubals grow on treesScott1 thinks frubals grow on treesScott1 thinks frubals grow on treesScott1 thinks frubals grow on treesScott1 thinks frubals grow on treesScott1 thinks frubals grow on treesScott1 thinks frubals grow on treesScott1 thinks frubals grow on treesScott1 thinks frubals grow on treesScott1 thinks frubals grow on treesScott1 thinks frubals grow on treesScott1 thinks frubals grow on treesScott1 thinks frubals grow on treesScott1 thinks frubals grow on treesScott1 thinks frubals grow on treesScott1 thinks frubals grow on treesScott1 thinks frubals grow on treesScott1 thinks frubals grow on treesScott1 thinks frubals grow on treesScott1 thinks frubals grow on treesScott1 thinks frubals grow on treesScott1 thinks frubals grow on treesScott1 thinks frubals grow on trees
Default
Quote:
Originally Posted by Victor View Post
Another thing to note is that SSPX hasn't completely withdrawn submission from the Roman Pontiff. Cardinal Castrillon says:

"The Fraternity of St. Pius X is not a consolidated schism per se, but its history has included some schismatic actions."
It's important to remember that the Cardinal is speaking about the ENTIRE SSPX not being schismatic... which is true.

The priests are not in schism... JUST the Bishops.
Quote:
1.) The priests of the Society of St. Pius X are validly ordained, but they are suspended from exercising their priestly functions. To the extent that they adhere to the schism of the late Archbishop Lefebvre, they are also excommunicated.
__________________
"Christians don't believe in gravity" - Peter Griffin
Reply With Quote
  #13  
Old 06-06-2008, 12:21 AM
Victor's Avatar
Victor Online!
Religion: Catholic
Title:Theist
Ambassador Award: Award designated for members who show great knowledge of their religion. - Issue reason: This award has been given to you by the award committee and is well deserved. Prolific Poster Award: - Issue reason: 10000 posts Courtesy Award: - Issue reason:  
 
Join Date: Jun 2005
Location: California, USA
Gender: Male
Posts: 15,876
Frubals: 724025
Victor thinks frubals grow on treesVictor thinks frubals grow on trees
Victor thinks frubals grow on trees
Victor thinks frubals grow on treesVictor thinks frubals grow on treesVictor thinks frubals grow on treesVictor thinks frubals grow on treesVictor thinks frubals grow on treesVictor thinks frubals grow on treesVictor thinks frubals grow on treesVictor thinks frubals grow on treesVictor thinks frubals grow on treesVictor thinks frubals grow on treesVictor thinks frubals grow on treesVictor thinks frubals grow on treesVictor thinks frubals grow on treesVictor thinks frubals grow on treesVictor thinks frubals grow on treesVictor thinks frubals grow on treesVictor thinks frubals grow on treesVictor thinks frubals grow on treesVictor thinks frubals grow on treesVictor thinks frubals grow on treesVictor thinks frubals grow on treesVictor thinks frubals grow on treesVictor thinks frubals grow on treesVictor thinks frubals grow on treesVictor thinks frubals grow on treesVictor thinks frubals grow on treesVictor thinks frubals grow on treesVictor thinks frubals grow on treesVictor thinks frubals grow on trees
Default
Quote:
Originally Posted by Scott1 View Post
It's important to remember that the Cardinal is speaking about the ENTIRE SSPX not being schismatic... which is true.

The priests are not in schism... JUST the Bishops.
Even that is debated......Consider:
Although the canon presupposes the existence of common error, occasions might arise where common error could be induced, e.g., when a priest has no faculty to hear confession, but enters the confessional because many people want to confess and he is sure that in the given situation people will think he has jurisdiction. In such a situation the Church will supply the faculty.

New commentary on the Code of Canon ... - Google Book Search

As for the Bishops, you are probably right.
__________________
"Man can be defined as an animal that makes dogmas. . . . " G.K. Chesterton
Reply With Quote
  #14  
Old 06-06-2008, 01:38 PM
Scott1's Avatar
Scott1 Offline
Religion: Roman Catholic
Title:Church of the Fonz
Journal Award: - Issue reason:  Article Award: - Issue reason:  
 
Join Date: Jul 2004
Location: MA, USA
Gender: Male
Posts: 8,011
Frubals: 590576
Scott1 thinks frubals grow on trees
Scott1 thinks frubals grow on treesScott1 thinks frubals grow on treesScott1 thinks frubals grow on treesScott1 thinks frubals grow on treesScott1 thinks frubals grow on treesScott1 thinks frubals grow on treesScott1 thinks frubals grow on treesScott1 thinks frubals grow on treesScott1 thinks frubals grow on treesScott1 thinks frubals grow on treesScott1 thinks frubals grow on trees
Scott1 thinks frubals grow on treesScott1 thinks frubals grow on treesScott1 thinks frubals grow on treesScott1 thinks frubals grow on treesScott1 thinks frubals grow on treesScott1 thinks frubals grow on treesScott1 thinks frubals grow on treesScott1 thinks frubals grow on treesScott1 thinks frubals grow on treesScott1 thinks frubals grow on treesScott1 thinks frubals grow on treesScott1 thinks frubals grow on treesScott1 thinks frubals grow on treesScott1 thinks frubals grow on treesScott1 thinks frubals grow on treesScott1 thinks frubals grow on treesScott1 thinks frubals grow on treesScott1 thinks frubals grow on treesScott1 thinks frubals grow on treesScott1 thinks frubals grow on treesScott1 thinks frubals grow on treesScott1 thinks frubals grow on treesScott1 thinks frubals grow on treesScott1 thinks frubals grow on trees
Default
Quote:
Originally Posted by Victor View Post
Even that is debated......Consider:

What is debated? The priests not being excommunicated?
__________________
"Christians don't believe in gravity" - Peter Griffin
Reply With Quote
  #15  
Old 06-07-2008, 01:21 PM
Victor's Avatar
Victor Online!
Religion: Catholic
Title:Theist
Ambassador Award: Award designated for members who show great knowledge of their religion. - Issue reason: This award has been given to you by the award committee and is well deserved. Prolific Poster Award: - Issue reason: 10000 posts Courtesy Award: - Issue reason:  
 
Join Date: Jun 2005
Location: California, USA
Gender: Male
Posts: 15,876
Frubals: 724025
Victor thinks frubals grow on treesVictor thinks frubals grow on trees
Victor thinks frubals grow on trees
Victor thinks frubals grow on treesVictor thinks frubals grow on treesVictor thinks frubals grow on treesVictor thinks frubals grow on treesVictor thinks frubals grow on treesVictor thinks frubals grow on treesVictor thinks frubals grow on treesVictor thinks frubals grow on treesVictor thinks frubals grow on treesVictor thinks frubals grow on treesVictor thinks frubals grow on treesVictor thinks frubals grow on treesVictor thinks frubals grow on treesVictor thinks frubals grow on treesVictor thinks frubals grow on treesVictor thinks frubals grow on treesVictor thinks frubals grow on treesVictor thinks frubals grow on treesVictor thinks frubals grow on treesVictor thinks frubals grow on treesVictor thinks frubals grow on treesVictor thinks frubals grow on treesVictor thinks frubals grow on treesVictor thinks frubals grow on treesVictor thinks frubals grow on treesVictor thinks frubals grow on treesVictor thinks frubals grow on treesVictor thinks frubals grow on treesVictor thinks frubals grow on trees
Default
Quote:
Originally Posted by Scott1 View Post
[/color]
What is debated? The priests not being excommunicated?
Whether they can use there faculties as priest and whether they are valid.
__________________
"Man can be defined as an animal that makes dogmas. . . . " G.K. Chesterton
Reply With Quote
  #16  
Old 06-08-2008, 01:04 AM
Scott1's Avatar
Scott1 Offline
Religion: Roman Catholic
Title:Church of the Fonz
Journal Award: - Issue reason:  Article Award: - Issue reason:  
 
Join Date: Jul 2004
Location: MA, USA
Gender: Male
Posts: 8,011
Frubals: 590576
Scott1 thinks frubals grow on trees
Scott1 thinks frubals grow on treesScott1 thinks frubals grow on treesScott1 thinks frubals grow on treesScott1 thinks frubals grow on treesScott1 thinks frubals grow on treesScott1 thinks frubals grow on treesScott1 thinks frubals grow on treesScott1 thinks frubals grow on treesScott1 thinks frubals grow on treesScott1 thinks frubals grow on treesScott1 thinks frubals grow on trees
Scott1 thinks frubals grow on treesScott1 thinks frubals grow on treesScott1 thinks frubals grow on treesScott1 thinks frubals grow on treesScott1 thinks frubals grow on treesScott1 thinks frubals grow on treesScott1 thinks frubals grow on treesScott1 thinks frubals grow on treesScott1 thinks frubals grow on treesScott1 thinks frubals grow on treesScott1 thinks frubals grow on treesScott1 thinks frubals grow on treesScott1 thinks frubals grow on treesScott1 thinks frubals grow on treesScott1 thinks frubals grow on treesScott1 thinks frubals grow on treesScott1 thinks frubals grow on treesScott1 thinks frubals grow on treesScott1 thinks frubals grow on treesScott1 thinks frubals grow on treesScott1 thinks frubals grow on treesScott1 thinks frubals grow on treesScott1 thinks frubals grow on treesScott1 thinks frubals grow on trees
Default
Quote:
Originally Posted by Victor View Post
Whether they can use there faculties as priest and whether they are valid.
REALLY? Wow... that might have far reaching implications if Canon law decides against the SSPX priests.
__________________
"Christians don't believe in gravity" - Peter Griffin
Reply With Quote
Reply
Page 2 of 2 < 12

« What do you do with a heathen in Mass? | Guilt? »


« What do you do with a heathen in Mass? | Guilt? »
Thread Tools
Display Modes
Linear Mode Linear Mode



All times are GMT -6. The time now is 10:52 AM.

Contact Us - Religious Forums - Archive 1, 2 - Top

© 2008 Advameg, Inc.

SEO by vBSEO ©2007, Crawlability, Inc.