Religious Education Forum  

Welcome Guest to ReligiousForums.com . You are currently not registered. When you become registered you will be able to interact with our large base of already registered users discussing topics. Some annoying Ads will also disappear when you register. Registering doesn't cost a thing and only takes a few seconds. We provide areas to chat and debate all World Religions. Please go to our register page!
Home Who's Online Today's Posts Mark Forums Read
Go Back   Religious Education Forum / Religious Topics / Religious Debates / Scriptural Debates / Biblical Debates
Sitemap Popular RF Forums REGISTER Search Mark Forums Read

Reply
 
Thread Tools Display Modes
  #1  
Old 07-14-2005, 04:19 AM
Lady Crimson's Avatar
Lady Crimson Offline
Religion: Deism
Title:credo quia absurdum
Shield of The Writer: Awarded for commendable contribution to the articles and journals at Religious Forums - Issue reason:  
 
Join Date: Apr 2005
Location: Romania
Gender: Female
Posts: 336
Frubals: 68
Lady Crimson has a stash of frubals in the Cayman IslandsLady Crimson has a stash of frubals in the Cayman Islands
Question Judas, a traitor forever?

Well, we all must know who Judas is...for those whon don't...here's a very basic sketch of him...Please excuse any wrong information because I read the Bible when I was runt and haven't remembered everything

Judas was one of Christ's apostles...He was the one that betrayed Him...He 'sold' Christ for 50 silver coins (or something like that)...When they were in a garden at night, praying (I believe it was an olive garden), Judas kissed Christ...that's how the romans knew who they had to 'arrest'.

Well....If anyone knows the story better, please tell it...cause I probably made as much sense as a castrated dog on ecstasy.

Now...here's my question...Is Judas regarded still as a traitor?...I've heard several stories stating that Judas regreted having 'sold' Christ and threw away the money he received or similar acts...But even if he didn't...should we regard him as a traitor? I mean, If Christ forgave him (which He probably did), why shouldn't we?
Reply With Quote
  #2  
Old 07-14-2005, 05:03 AM
LoPar's Avatar
LoPar Offline
Title:Freshman Member
 
Join Date: Sep 2004
Posts: 19
Frubals: 74
LoPar is a Frubal WhoreLoPar is a Frubal Whore
Default

Does it matter to Judas if we don't forgive him? Likely not if he has received the forgivesness from the man he wronged. Does it matter to ourselves if we can't forgive him? Yes as Jesus asks that we do so.
Reply With Quote
  #3  
Old 07-14-2005, 08:59 AM
michel's Avatar
michel Offline
Religion: Christian
Title:Administrator Emeritus
Shield of The Writer: Awarded for commendable contribution to the articles and journals at Religious Forums - Issue reason:  Shield of Research: Awarded for meticulous attention to detail and comprehensive reading around a subject - Issue reason:  Shield of Creativity: Awarded for wonderfully original and innovative thinking - Issue reason:  Shield of Labour: Awarded for admirable hard work and development of a cause - Issue reason: This award has been given to you by your peers for your work on the newsletter and is well deserved. Shield of 20,000 Thoughts: Awarded for contributing 20,000 posts - Issue reason:  
 
Join Date: Sep 2004
Location: U.K
Gender: Male
Posts: 28,678
Frubals: 2754
michel was audited for avoidance of the frubal taxmichel was audited for avoidance of the frubal tax
michel was audited for avoidance of the frubal taxmichel was audited for avoidance of the frubal taxmichel was audited for avoidance of the frubal taxmichel was audited for avoidance of the frubal taxmichel was audited for avoidance of the frubal taxmichel was audited for avoidance of the frubal taxmichel was audited for avoidance of the frubal taxmichel was audited for avoidance of the frubal taxmichel was audited for avoidance of the frubal tax
Default

Quote:
Originally Posted by Lady Crimson
Well, we all must know who Judas is...for those whon don't...here's a very basic sketch of him...Please excuse any wrong information because I read the Bible when I was runt and haven't remembered everything

Judas was one of Christ's apostles...He was the one that betrayed Him...He 'sold' Christ for 50 silver coins (or something like that)...When they were in a garden at night, praying (I believe it was an olive garden), Judas kissed Christ...that's how the romans knew who they had to 'arrest'.

Well....If anyone knows the story better, please tell it...cause I probably made as much sense as a castrated dog on ecstasy.

Now...here's my question...Is Judas regarded still as a traitor?...I've heard several stories stating that Judas regreted having 'sold' Christ and threw away the money he received or similar acts...But even if he didn't...should we regard him as a traitor? I mean, If Christ forgave him (which He probably did), why shouldn't we?
Here is a summary of the arguments about his role;
Excursus--Theories Advanced for Judas' Betrayal

1.Figurative Theory--Judas is regarded as mere personification of the spirit of Judaism; however, this makes similar figurative folly of all Scriptures by invalidating their historical value.

2.Intentional Theory--Judas intended to betray Jesus from his joining with the Eleven (i.e., before becoming a disciple, out of...

a.Patriotic protectiveness (i.e., Zealot or Sicarii; cf. XIV.A.2.d. above) of race and creed from Jesus, or

b.Assumption of traitor role used to precipitate an action and to manifest the heavenly nature of Jesus by creating a necessity for angelic intervention for Christ's protection (found among the Cainite sect; based upon Matthew 26:53);

however Jesus' manner of denunciation and terminology employed render this view untenable. To have selected an apostle, who intended betrayal from the start, is near to being predestination, as Calvinists contend. For Jesus to then denounce him and converse with him, as is done in the Gospels, would be hard to justify.

3.Demon Possession--Judas was not possessor of his own faculties, as he betrayed Jesus; instead, it was the devil. Jesus said, "Did I not choose you the Twelve and out of you, one is a devil? But he spoke of Judas of Simon Iskarioth, for he, one out of the Twelve, was about to give-over him?" (John 6:70-71).

a.Apocryphal Citations are printed here because of inaccessibility to average folk, not located near my ministerial library or a large university's holdings. Original texts of the major apocryphal New Testament works are available (but seldom in the U.S.) in editions by Constantine von Tischendorf.

1.1) Another woman likewise lived there, whose son was possessed by Satan. 2) This boy, named Judas, as often as Satan seized him, was inclined to bite all that were present; and if he found no one else near him, he would bite his own hands and other parts. 3) But the mother of this miserable boy, hearing of St. Mary and her son Jesus, arose presently, and taking her son in her arms, brought him to the Lady Mary. 4) In the meantime, James and Joses had taken away the infant, the Lord Jesus, to play at a proper season with the other children; and when they went forth, they sat down, and the Lord Jesus with them. 5) Then Judas, who was possessed, came and sat down at the right hand of Jesus. 6) When Satan was acting upon him as usual, he went about to bite the Lord Jesus. 7) And because he could not do it, he struck Jesus on the right side, so that he cried-out. 8) And in the same moment Satan went out of the boy, and ran away like a mad dog. 9) This same boy, who struck Jesus, and out of whom Satan went in the form of a dog, was Judas Iscariot, who betrayed him to the Jews. 10) And that same side, on which Judas struck him, the Jews pierced with a spear.
(I Infancy 14:1-10, The Apocryphal New Testament Philadelphia: Gebbie & Co., n.d.; reprinted. The Lost books of the Bible and the Forgotten Books of Eden. n.p.: Collins World, 1963.)

2.Nearly the same account is summarized by M.R. James:
Judas, a child possessed by the devil, smites Jesus, and the devil leaves him in the form of a dog.
(arabic Infancy Gospel, 35, Montague R. James, translator, The Apocryphal New Testament. Oxford: Clarendon Press, 1924, p. 82 (hereinafter cited as James, Apocryphal NT, following text identification).

b.Biblically associated texts and statements--Any one could have done the betrayal; anyone headstrong toward evil ("hell-bent" in modern English) is said (then and now) to have the devil in them (John 13:2 and 13:27 show the same occurrence [Note how 13:2 speaks of Luke 22:3f. and parallels having occurred, and John 132 shows temptation alone, while Mark 14:10f. and Matthew 26:14 show overt action, which Luke 22:3f. describes as "Satan entering" him; any purpose other than temptation is without warrant.].) Judas sought an opportunity to deliver the Christ to the priests; a devil possessing him would have not depended upon such trial and error.

However,

.Under such a system, Jesus' appeals and reproaches (the sop, John 13:26; the question, Luke 22:48; etc.) become entirely meaningless.

.No one could have been personally responsible for the betrayal under such a system; hence,1.No personal guilt could be applied, and

2.Judas' title "Son of Destruction" (John 17:12) is meaningless.

Jesus made no attempt to heal Judas by casting-out devils (if any); or, alternately, the demon possession was not noticed by others, while every other encountered demon possession was met with an exorcism by Christ or the Twelve; plus, how does one explain successful exorcisms being accomplished (Luke 9:1-11 and parallels; cf. 10:1-12 and statement at 10:17-20) by one demon possessed, and not contradict Christ at Matthew 12:25-29? Clearly such is impossible!

"Double-barreled" Predestinarian Theory--John Calvin (Institutes 3:21:5) defines his predestination as "God's eternal decree, by which he compacted with Himself that he willed to become of each man. For all are not created in equal condition; rather, eternal life is foreordained for some, eternal damnation for others." By this Calvin would contend Judas to have been foreordained to be the betrayer and Judas would have no choice in the matter; though, Calvin asserts (3:22:7) that Judas' election as one of the Twelve never contained a hope of salvation. Such doctrine assumes that Jesus initially selected Judas because He knew that Judas should betray Him (omniscence [omniscience is foreknowledge, not predestination], plus John 2:24; 6:64; 18:4), and in order to "fulfill all prophecies" (cf. Matthew 26:54; John 17:12). Calvin contends that every action of man is a "secret command" by God (Institutes 1:18:1). Calvin's translators render the noun with various synonyms following the consistent adjective "secret"; however, the meaning is always the same.
{If Calvin be accepted in this theory and in this concept of mankind, all humanity performs a puppet skit that would logically conclude universalism. None could be found guilty (protagonist or antagonist), who acted well the part given them. Obedience could be reckoned to the evil ones for a job well done--the pottery would have complied with the purpose given it by the potter, rather than object to being created such as a chamber pot. Such logic is ludicrous for it would relegate God to being a lunatic creator.}

However,

Under such a system, Jesus' appeals and reproaches (the sop, John 13:26; the question Luke 22:48; etc.) become entirely meaningless--as meaningless and ill-defended as Calvin's use of evangelization in his predestinarian system.

Presuppositions upon the Kenotic Theories (Philippians 2:7)--the Word's emptying Himself in His becoming as man--assume total omniscience to the Incarnate One, when, Christ's own declaration of limited authority in His Incarnate state prior to Matthew 28:18 should also indicate an omniscience limited to the needs of each moment of his ministry. B.F. Westcott noted (Gospel According to St. John [Greek text], p. 101) that Jesus' "knowledge appears to be truly the knowledge of the Son of Man, and not merely the knowledge of the Divine Word, though at each moment and in each connection it was, in virtue of His perfect humanity, relatively complete. The Gospel has an historic character which might be destroyed should one press Docetism into its interpretation." That which reduces Jesus' historicity and humanity was withheld from him incarnate, but allowed to him as needed (cf. angelic counsel in the garden, transfiguration visitors, etc.).
http://www.fcclighthouse.com/judas_iscarioth.htm (extract fom)

__________________
My life is an open book; if you don't like the read, put me back on the shelf ....................
Reply With Quote
  #4  
Old 07-14-2005, 09:06 AM
Lady Crimson's Avatar
Lady Crimson Offline
Religion: Deism
Title:credo quia absurdum
Shield of The Writer: Awarded for commendable contribution to the articles and journals at Religious Forums - Issue reason:  
 
Join Date: Apr 2005
Location: Romania
Gender: Female
Posts: 336
Frubals: 68
Lady Crimson has a stash of frubals in the Cayman IslandsLady Crimson has a stash of frubals in the Cayman Islands
Default

The whole thing made me even more confused...

Still, good information...It shows every point of view!
Reply With Quote
  #5  
Old 07-14-2005, 05:41 PM
kreeden's Avatar
kreeden Offline
Religion: Ogre
Title:Virus of the Mind
 
Join Date: Oct 2004
Location: CDN
Gender: Male
Posts: 2,615
Frubals: 267
kreeden volunteers by giving sponge baths at the home for aging frubalskreeden volunteers by giving sponge baths at the home for aging frubalskreeden volunteers by giving sponge baths at the home for aging frubalskreeden volunteers by giving sponge baths at the home for aging frubalskreeden volunteers by giving sponge baths at the home for aging frubals
Default

Good point LoPar .

This question always reminds me of Jesus Christ Superstar , where Judas asks Jesus what he would have done if he had not betrayed him . Think about it . Judas did exacty what he was meant to do . He would had to , to fullfill prophecies . { Psalm 22 I believe ??? , but I could be mistaken }
__________________
Traveler , there is no path .
You make the path by walking it .
Reply With Quote
  #6  
Old 08-04-2005, 09:16 AM
Prophet Rashad Offline
Religion: Holiness
Title:Freshman Member
 
Join Date: Aug 2005
Gender: Male
Posts: 52
Frubals: 97
Prophet Rashad dreams of one day opening a frubal grooming salonProphet Rashad dreams of one day opening a frubal grooming salon
Default

Well like most people in history once titled something it will follow you till the end of time. Like if I say Ted Bundy you will think of him as a killer he may have prayed for salvation right before he was killed. If Judas had betrayed lets say Peter then he would still be branded a traitor but the severity of the name will not be as much but because he betrayed the Christ then he will be branded a traitor forever
Reply With Quote
Reply

Thread Tools
Display Modes

Similar Threads



All times are GMT -6. The time now is 09:41 AM.


Copyright 2014 Advameg, Inc.

SEO by vBSEO ©2010, Crawlability, Inc.